Gransnet forums

Relationships

Standing up to a narcissistic big sister

(66 Posts)
Dazy Wed 23-Sept-26 21:14:51

Hello,
I need advice on a deeply painful situation with my older sister, who has been a cold, controlling bully for the past 25 years, with intermittent warmth and a keen interest to keep me in her life. We were close from age 14 to 30, but when I moved abroad and got married, she treated it as a personal rejection and became oppressive and cruel.
For decades, she has genuinely terrified me, and while we still see each other regularly, I am never really comfortable around her. Three weeks ago at my birthday, she made cutting remarks and totally twisted my past in which she showed cruelty yet she ended up the victim, claiming I abandoned her when my marriage collapsed and that I never shared my struggles. In reality, when I reached out terrified back then, she dismissed me, told me I was a burden and years later she ruthlessly bossed me around while I was raising two tiny kids alone after a brain hemorrhage. My dad even recognized before he died that her constant demands were giving me daily, splitting headaches from sheer strain.
I recently lost my cat, and this grief on top of the birthday remarks and a whole catalogue of exceptionally painful treatment has brought me to a complete tipping point. While I know she has faced horrific personal tragedies herself, I am exhausted by her coldness and sick of swallowing her abusive behavior. I desperately want to stand up to this bully, reject her lies, and protect my sanity, but I’m terrified...she has repeatedly said "I DON'T DO CRITICISM" if I've ever tried to stand up to her in the past...
I'm also worried about the guilt - she's very unwell, she could barely move last time I saw her.

How do I finally hold my ground against someone who terrifies me without being consumed by guilt?
I've written it all down in a long letter but knowing her she'll probably see it as an attack on her. She has zero accountability in life.

Thank you in advance

Smileless2012 Mon 28-Sept-26 11:36:09

Read up on the 'grey rock' method Love.

Keep your emotions hidden. Keep verbal responses brief giving as little information as possible. Don't react to anything intended to produce an emotional response ie anger and hurt.
Keep any conversations to arranging contact with the children and nothing more.

Horti Thu 01-Oct-26 07:10:51

I recognise a lot of this terrible narcissistic behaviour
My husband is a narcissist
I had no idea until fairly recently about this pattern of behaviour that plays out in a predictable way
Now I recognise the pattern I can deal with it to a certain level
Walking away , not reacting , low key responses and oh I recognise this ‘ I don’t take criticism ‘ line ‘
He’s been bad mouthing me to relatives who now think he’s the victim !
It’s classic god I wish I’d had knowledge of this behaviour and how to deal with it years ago
I think girls particularly ( not being sexist ) should be educated to be aware of this pattern of grooming
I’ve been driven to low depths especially during poor health when the daily verbal battering ‘ you are worthless everyone thinks you mad ‘ etc was stepped up and support was non existent
I realise now stepping out of this even emotionally is the only way
I’m now rebuilding my contacts snd interests amongst ‘ normal ‘ people and feel so much better
Beyond that I don’t know yet it all takes time

Esmay Thu 01-Oct-26 07:28:54

Dazy-I sympathesise with you .

It's very painful to have a blood relative behave in a vindictive way against you .

It has happened to me .

And the only thing that you can do is distance yourself or simply walk away .

In my case there is a complete lack of respect.
There was insistence on meeting up and then being shouted and sworn at .
I have felt like a punch bag .
And I have been hit as well .

I'm wishing the strength to walk away from what is a hopeless relationship.

Horti Thu 01-Oct-26 08:15:24

This is a husband not blood relative but yes pattern is the same and can degenerate into violence too

Horti Thu 01-Oct-26 08:17:00

I’m so sorry you've had to suffer this esmay
I have too

polnan Thu 01-Oct-26 08:33:35

Horti I was more or less thinking the same, but didn`t know how to say it, of course we know that some men/boys also experience this, but it does seem a lot of women/girls..

"I think girls particularly ( not being sexist ) should be educated to be aware of this pattern of grooming"

Esmay Thu 01-Oct-26 09:10:52

Horti -
I'm very sorry that you've suffered abuse .
Whether it's from a non -blood relative or blood relative in the family it's horrendous and totally unacceptable.

icanhandthemback Thu 01-Oct-26 09:25:26

Horti, be aware that narcissists do not like the loss of control and their behaviour can escalate. There is a big difference between dealing with a narcissist at a distance and living with one when trying to take back your life.

I think girls particularly ( not being sexist ) should be educated to be aware of this pattern of grooming

Actually, I think male and female should be educated about this.

Smileless2012 Thu 01-Oct-26 09:53:12

I agree that education on this subject is just as important to males as females icanhandthemback.

Horti Thu 01-Oct-26 15:53:31

Yes I’ve heard about escalation problems into violence when victims try to move on or even after that time as revenge

I know some people are labelled incorrectly with this but it’s a truly scary thing when you are close to it
And unpredictable

And can lead to all sorts of health problems for the victim both physical and mental

When I contacted an agency they were able to identify the behaviour but unable to give any ‘ how do you deal with it ‘ info

Very disappointing seems you are on your own

Juneandarchie1 Sun 04-Oct-26 15:53:24

Take it from someone who has suffered the same fate, but at the hands of a younger sister I tried so hard to please.
Once both my parents had died I cut all contact and no regrets at all.
I realise now how evil she was.
Look up some Buddhist reasonings, they explain such a lot and save your sanity and you can then experience a peaceful mind at last

Norah Sun 04-Oct-26 17:51:49

No further contact seems a reasonable approach.

welbeck Mon 05-Oct-26 08:34:22

Horti
Contact Women's Aid.
Confide in GP.

Horti Tue 06-Oct-26 04:44:46

Thank you Wrlbeck
I e done both of these things and tried other agencies but neither could help with ! What you can do about it ‘ but ok listening and verifying the behaviour
That’s the frustration

Doodledog Tue 06-Oct-26 08:15:53

Have you told her how you feel?

I’m uneasy with the ‘cut all ties’ advice, as I know the pain that estrangement can cause - we see it on here every day. Even worse when people have no idea why it happened.

Maybe it will be the only option if she refuses to change her behaviour, but is it worth having a conversation about it to find out her point of view, and see if she’s willing to make an effort?