Shortbread

Deans of Huntly is my favourite. They started as a family firm and have grown, but their shortbread is lovely IMO. You could try and see if they sell online.

Hope you find the comfort food you want.

I remember reading somewhere that Aldi's Belmont brand of shortbread is excellent. I've just looked up the ingredients and it is:

• Wheat Flour (Fortified with Calcium Carbonate, Iron, Niacin, and Thiamin)
• Butter (Milk)
• Sugar
• Cornflour
• Salt

Sounds good to me!

Walkers Highland butter shortbread rounds are my easy go-to ones…. I like them when not home made.

Lidl’s Deluxe range is lovely!!!

I love Morrisons Extra Special round shortbread 😋

Walker’s of Aberlour sell delicious shortbread and have an online shop.

I’d probably get two or three different packets and see. I’m weirdly fussy about shortbread though. I like it a bit crumbly and you have to be able to taste the butter. We’ve had some of those really hard ones before and they just sat in the cupboard for ages because nobody particularly wanted them.

I’d have picked up the seaweed one in Scotland just out of curiosity. I can’t even begin to imagine how strongly you can taste the seaweed in it. Maybe in the end it’s just a bit salty. Have you opened them yet, Stansgran?

I’d probably go for a small packet to start with. After trying the fresh shortbread from that little shop, a shop-bought variety is probably going to have a bit of a hard time competing anyway. And then to have a massive tin of it sitting in the cupboard straight away ... well, I’d rather start with a small one first.

Chrystal’s a small family company based in Loch Lomond , absolutely delicious www.chrystalsshortbread.co.uk

Deans is my go to shortie. Yum

Marks and Spencer all butter shortbread biscuits. In a cellophane bag near the bakery. So good!

My youngest son adores morrisons shortbread in the cellophane bags,near their bakery-its square and you only get 4 in a bag,but he says its lovely & buttery,and soft to eat not hard biscuits.And he is very hard to please.You could try homemade i guess🤔

Look for any that has rice flour in the ingredients, only way to make shortbread. Aldi used to have proper shortbread sold as 12 fingers in a box, but it stopped supplying about a year ago. Sorry, but haven't found any with proper ingredients so no longer buy any of the massed produced stuff only very locally produced.

Only today somewhere I saw a comparison of supermarket shortbreads and Aldi Belmonte came out top with 9 out of ten.

I like Pattersons shortbread fingers, they are not overly sweet and a nice thickness, I buy mine from Tesco £1.50 for 300grams box , in fact I have just eaten 2 with my afternoon cuppa. 😋

Border biscuits do a sharing pack of six varieties which includes shortbread, oat crumbles,Viennese swirls and three other varieties, two of them half coated in chocolate and all delicious.

M&S is the best, nothing fancy, no tin just good old fashioned buttery shortbread in a red wrapper £1 or thereabouts! Yum

OP have you tried Greggs Jammi Heart Shortbread biscuits, my group fight over them when I bring them. • Jammy Heart Biscuit
• Description: A large heart-shaped shortbread or shortcrust biscuit topped with a dollop of raspberry jam in the middle.
• Price: Around £0.85 per biscuit (prices can slightly vary by location).
• Nutrition (59g portion): 271 calories, 13g fat (7.7g saturates), 35g carbohydrates (13g sugars), 3.1g protein, and 0.31g salt.

Seconded Jandy.
Sadly this tin is now empty! I will definitely be ordering another.

I know exactly where Crystals shortbread is made and I'll now make a point of trying it.

Deans are the best

M&S all-butter shortbread thick, shaped biscuits in a tin.
Currently showing out of stock online when I looked, but loads on shelves in their shops. Utterly delicious.

Annoyingly people are buying the M&S tins (in bulk probably) and selling on eBay for double the price 😡

Try sawley kitchen shortbread. I was sent a gift box by some friends. Have to say the family enjoyed it

Maybe M&S are about to launch a new tin? Ready for Christmas?
The one you show, Tilly, was definitely on the shelves this time last year...