Gransnet forums

Chat

Iis it unnatural to love your partner MORE than your children.

(145 Posts)
paddyann Sun 06-May-18 20:33:03

Saw this on MN and was amazed at some of the replies .Apparently it is unnatural to love your OH more than your children.When I got married my mum told me to always make sure my husband came first ove rthe kids except when they wer sick or in need ..obviously .I think I kind of did that ,we have a brilliant relationship with our AD but our own relationship is still strong and the romance intact after 43 years .As mum said your kids grow up and move on and you still have a life together so make that a priority.I think she got it spot on.What do gransnetters think?Was my mum right or are th mumsnetters ?

Faye Tue 08-May-18 09:59:33

Annie that is so sad, it must be a very difficult time for you. flowers

Carolebarrel Tue 08-May-18 10:09:53

Anniebach your story is heartbreaking. I know I would feel the same if I were in your position. I hope you have love and support from others in your life. Please try to find a reason to carry on. Bereavement counselling will help when you feel ready to take that step. Sending love to you x

Shesanana Tue 08-May-18 10:44:01

Anniebach my heart goes out to you flowers

paddyann Tue 08-May-18 10:52:35

the diffference is you had young children and they give you the reason to go on Annie like I said mine are 40 and 30 and have their own lives and families .We see them all the time ,we love them dearly but they, like we did,have to get on with their lives their way.I've been with my OH for 44 years .Some very tough times ,some fantastic ..always better for being together .I am independent ,good with finances etc ,happy to do DIY ,have my own friends and life BUT he is always at the core of every day .I am so sorry for your recent loss and I know your grief will last the rest of your life .It is a very different grief losing a child ,as someone said to me ,theres no NAME for a parent who loses a child ,you're just expected to go on with life .I know lots of folk who moved on from being widowed very quickly ..I know its not what I would do or even consider doing .I know not many will understand that .

gillybob Tue 08-May-18 11:02:13

My sister and I always said that when the time came our mum should go before dad. We knew that dad would manage quite on his own and he does (with my help) he has quite a good social life too. My mum had no social life, no friends and just hung on my (bossy) dads every word. In her eyes he could do no wrong. Silly as it might seem she couldn’t even admire a picture of a good looking film/pop star as said the only man in the world she wanted to admire was her husband. She cut off all her work colleagues as couldn’t bear to spend a minute more away from my dad than absolutely necessary. Sad.

Anniebach Tue 08-May-18 12:58:23

paddyann, it can not be said that I am a widow who moved on quickly, been a widow for forty three years, when I chose my husbands grave stone I had inscribe “I Shall Not Look Upon His Like Again “. This has proved to be true . But the love for my elder daughter is even stronger , when she died I said here “she was my joy, my tears , my world “ this is true, I cannot explained the bond between us , just it was very deep and very strong and I thank God she was his gift to me, I was so blessed to have such a daughter .

Happysexagenarian Tue 08-May-18 14:07:26

paddyann I think I would agree with your Mum.
When I married my husband my only desire was to spend the rest of my life loving him, whether or not we had children. Forty years and three children later I still feel that way. I love all of my children individually, sometimes one more than another depending on their needs at the time. I could not comprehend life without any one of my children, and definitely not without my DH. Together we make two halves of a whole and I dread the day when that whole will be broken. But I have always put DH needs first, before myself or my children and will always continue to do that. Our children have grown into loving, kind, considerate and well-balanced adults, husbands and partners who have taken their cues from our loving relationship. So I think, for us, it has worked out OK. But every partnership and family is different and must do what is right for them.

deaneke Tue 08-May-18 15:52:01

So sorry, Annie.

Anniebach Tue 08-May-18 15:57:30

Thank you deaneke, we don’t decide who we love or how much we love , it just happens .

deaneke Tue 08-May-18 16:43:28

Fantastic post Alygran.

deaneke Tue 08-May-18 16:56:58

Aniebach...please take care of yourself. Seek Cruse if you can.

thecatgrandma Tue 08-May-18 17:58:49

What a ridiculous question ! Your children must always come first, you created them, it doesn’t even warrant a second thought.

Elegran Tue 08-May-18 18:41:04

How about a specific example instead of a generalised rule?

What if your DH is hospitalised with a sudden emergency as you are about to attend a school concert where your child will be performing? Do you let him be admitted alone or do you leave your child to perform without you there?

What if you are asked to look after grandchildren on a day when your DH is being presented with an award?

It is easy to say "Of course X must come first" - but it depends which of them needs you most, and it may not be the same answer under all circumstances.

Anniebach Tue 08-May-18 18:51:27

Not one of those Elegran, but when I was in Labour with our second baby , neighbours stayed with our 22 month old whilst my husband drove me to the hospital , left me and my case at the entrance and shot back home to be with our first born, I had to get myself and the case up to the first floor ? I 100% supported his decision .

Iam64 Tue 08-May-18 19:18:25

That's a great memory Anniebach and a real demonstration of the reality of loving our partners and children x

Rachel711 Tue 08-May-18 19:27:19

I agree with you Bluebell, I love my children more than any man , but I love my grandchildren as much as my children but in a different way. I know it's an artificial situation but if there was Titanic type event who would you give up your place in the lifeboat for?

Daisymay1 Tue 08-May-18 19:28:55

Mine too ?

Blencathra Wed 09-May-18 06:30:48

I agree with SueDonim on the very first reply. I simply don't understand people who need to measure or compare love. Love for a husband or your child are completely different things - I don't see how you even think about it, let alone start. Maybe people feel very insecure and needy.

Blencathra Wed 09-May-18 06:36:03

And rescuing a child or a partner first in a fire is equally stupid! Of course you rescue a child first - they need your help. If it is an adult child then quite possibly you need to rescue the partner first or more likely your adult child is the one to rescue you. I would hope that anyone would rescue a 2 yr old before their partner even if they didn't know the 2 yr old. Why do people come up with such silly questions?!!

Anniebach Wed 09-May-18 08:36:25

There was no mention of age in the question

Nana05 Wed 09-May-18 08:54:01

Most definitely, my partner is there for me 24/7 my children only when they want something or feel they should be

M0nica Wed 09-May-18 08:57:41

Blencathra spot on. I love my spouse, children, and grandchildren equally and differently and respond to their needs on a case by case basis that doesn't include measuring how much I love them.

Annie I do not think that you can compare and contrast the loss of a spouse and child. My DS died several years before my mother's death. My parents were devoted to each other, and my father missed my mother every day for the next 15 years until he died, but it was the loss of his DD that remained the loss that most deeply affected him for the rest of his life. Your child is flesh of your flesh, blood of your blood, it is a completely different more primal loss than the loss of a partner.

Anniebach Wed 09-May-18 09:08:39

MOnica, comparing the loss of a child with the loss of a spouse is no different to asking who do you love more .

M0nica Wed 09-May-18 14:10:25

Which is the point I was making.

Anniebach Wed 09-May-18 14:17:56

Sorry, I misunderstood