Gransnet forums

Chat

Direct or indirect querist?

(29 Posts)
thatbags Mon 09-Nov-15 13:26:16

Are you a direct or indirect querist? I am direct; DH indirect. There was an example this morning.

Him: "Are you going anywhere today?"

Me: "Yes, to G, and I might go along to H later for some sealant for that slight leak under the kitcehn sink."

Him: "I wouldn't go to H today if I were you."

Me: "Oh, why?"

Him: "Because the flood by F is already quite deep so you might get stuck."

Then it dawned on me... he wanted to take the old 4x4 so that he could get through the flooded bits of road. Which left me wondering why he didn't just say: "Can I take the truck today? The roads will be pretty bad." To which I could have answered: "Yes. Sure."

This kind of wandering around the crux of the issue is quite common. I quite often have to work out what he's on about by piecing things together. It can be quite amusing but sometimes, if I'm tired for instance, I just wish he'd get to the point in a more direct way.

stillhere Tue 10-Nov-15 12:43:12

Ooh, fascinating, it took over a year of living with DBH to realise what was going on. It still drives me mad at times. I am direct, he is indirect. It took me months to click, the first example I remember very clearly. I was newly pregnant and so spent ages in our one and only loo at the time (folic acid!). He would loiter outside and ask 'Are you ok?', and I would answer, 'Yes, thank you!'

It finally sunk in that he wasn't at all concerned for my well-being - he wanted the loo!

MiL is exactly the same, so I know where he gets it from. The other week when she was here she spent ages quizzing me about our movements this Xmas (DD and family staying with us for a week) but seemed unable to accept it for some reason. She kept returning to it and I was getting quite irritated, she seemed unable to believe me! I thought I had her sussed - I presumed that she wanted us up there, as she often does, so said Sorry, we just couldn't fit in a visit up there as well. She looked horrified. What she had actually been hoping to do was pass over the care of Great Uncle!

M0nica Tue 10-Nov-15 18:38:18

DH is an indirect querist par excellence and will also turn my direct queries into indirect queries.

Me: Are you going out today?

DH: Why do you need me to be in for a delivery?

absent Wed 11-Nov-15 04:28:43

I am fairly direct in my questions, as I wouldn't ask them if I didn't need an answer, but I am so tired of reminding several family members that if the question involves the word "or", answering yes or no is not in any way satisfactory. (I am also fairly unenthusiastic about "Why not?")