Gransnet forums

Chat

This made me CROSS (shouty capitals)

(226 Posts)
Soutra Fri 19-Jun-15 18:27:06

I am not turning into a DM reader but when I heard among other comments from British Muslims on a phone in after Cameron's speech (about disaffected teenagers going off to "fight" for ISIL) the accusations that Britain is not a democracy and does not allow freedom of speech or opinion to our Muslim communities, made me shout at the car radio. What did they think they were enjoying by being able to voice these opinions on national radio? What would happen to them in Syria if they made similar remarks -or even had similar thoughts?
I do not want to start a pro or anti Muslim/ethnic minority/ LGBT/ religious persecution conversation, but one thing is certain, minorities have a heck of a lot more freedom of expression in the UK than in the countries some of them seem to want to return to.
Harrumph
Disgusted
Tunbridge Wells

thatbags Sat 20-Jun-15 08:54:19

I find it interesting (I was going to say amusing but decided it was weird amusement) that if a parent feeds its child salty or sugary snacks, the parent is blamed but if a parent takes its child unnecessarily into a war zone society is blamed. Funny that hmm

soontobe Sat 20-Jun-15 09:19:46

Who is blaming society for that? It is very much down to the parents if you ask me.

jinglbellsfrocks Sat 20-Jun-15 09:36:20

No way is society to blame for this lot Bags. It is totally down to the selfish, stupid, irresponsible women themselves. If they are ever brought back they should be done for child abuse.

jinglbellsfrocks Sat 20-Jun-15 09:38:47

People have to take responsibility for themselves, and that goes for young and old. (though obviously not children)

I agree with you Joan about Islamism, although when I said similar on here it was deleted.

Soutra Sat 20-Jun-15 09:48:07

Not necessarily disagreeing thatbags but what is society if not the aggregation of individuals. Thus parents are part of society and of a community. The exclusivity of some communities bothers me. Nobody asks the opinion of the Guardian-reading teaching community or the Telegraph reading farming community (stereotyping, I know ) because we and they are not an enclosed group to the exclusion of others. But unless the leaders of ethnic and religious "communities" are prepared to take responsibility for what is promulgated in their name they cannot demand special consideration. You are either "in" society or you are not.
The UK has had immigrant groups since I don't know when and some of them still do not integrate (some Orthodox Jewish groups for instance love me the one that won't let women drive their children to school) but what has enriched our society has been the admixture of cultures. Sadly I feel the more "orthodox" Muslim groups have become more polarised and insular, keeping themselves to themselves. Perhaps their insularity, particularly as it affects the women oin their community has played its part in their women and girls going to Syria to join ISIL.

Soutra Sat 20-Jun-15 09:50:06

"Love me" was not a Cockney exclamation, but should have read LIKE. !!!blush
#whatismyipadonthismorning.

Stansgran Sat 20-Jun-15 09:52:14

I do wish those who go to "fight " for ISIS would have their passports refused because as sure as eggs are eggs when things go belly up for them they will be demanding the help of the uk to feed clothe and repair them in perpetuity.

Stansgran Sat 20-Jun-15 09:56:14

For Durhamjen
www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-middle-east-33039815
Don't ever go to Dubai as you may find yourself in this predicament

Atqui Sat 20-Jun-15 09:57:08

When things go 'belly up' for them I doubt Isis will allow them to leave.

loopylou Sat 20-Jun-15 10:02:04

Apparently 'getting back out' is virtually impossible for those who join IS. A report I read recently said they would kill those trying to leave because of the knowledge they hold about IS.
So it's highly unlikely they'll come back, let alone begging GB for assistance

loopylou Sat 20-Jun-15 10:05:30

Dubai Stansgran ? confused
The link is about Saudi Arabia, not the UAE. I've been to Dubai and it's perfectly safe albeit a bit like Las Vegas on speed!

UAE is nothing like Saudi.

Nonnie Sat 20-Jun-15 10:28:25

What I don't like about some Muslims is their certainty that the rest of us are WRONG. If we are not for them we must be against them. I don't think any other religion feels like that. Why must we be punished for not believing what they believe? I know one Muslim very well and she picks and chooses which bits she wants from Islam and ignores the rest which is fine by me but there is absolutely no doubt that if anyone disagrees with her on any subject they are WRONG! It is her way or not way. On the other hand my dentist is a devout Muslim and we have discussed religion openly and calmly without falling out. (and he hasn't done anything bad to my teethgrin)

I recently read that 85% of people who wear the niqab to job interviews doen't get the job and that it is not fair! Well I want to see the face of the person I am interviewing.

Soutra Sat 20-Jun-15 10:40:42

Oh Nonnie only think back to the well-meaning Christian missionaries of history.
They were equally convinced theirs was the only true religion and that it was their sacred mission to "convert the heathen" at all costs. sad

Stansgran Sat 20-Jun-15 10:53:45

Thanks Loopy . 'Twas the only the only Arab town I could spill this morning. I have trouble with Rihyad /Rhiad and iPad won't help.

Nonnie Sat 20-Jun-15 10:54:17

But Soutra did they kill or simply try to convert? History is important but nowadays we have access to so much more information and should be able to rise above what happened so long ago surely?

I would be happy to have a religious discussion with someone from any other faith, and have done so, but it is very difficult with some Muslims. I had a perfectly sensible discussion with a Muslim boss where we agreed to disagree but the same discussion with the aforementioned Muslim woman ended up in me being abused and accused of all sorts of things. Once again I felt that she had no listened to what I said but predecided (is that a word?) what I thought. Many Muslims have done the same abotu what DC said yesterday.

Stansgran Sat 20-Jun-15 10:54:43

SPELL

rosesarered Sat 20-Jun-15 10:58:47

Soutra, am glad that I didn't hear the DC speech and the phone in, because I shout at the radio as well ( truly a sign of aging, as I never used to.)All Muslim communities have to put their own house in order before they cry 'victim' to the rest of us.I think I am also getting tired of the word community as well, most of them have been here long enough not to need one.

durhamjen Sat 20-Jun-15 11:14:32

My passport ran out in 2003. I do not think I am likely to renew it just to go to Saudi, Stansgran.
I hope you have signed his wife's petition to stop the punishment.

trc.taboola.com/eslmedia-theindependent/log/3/click?pi=%2Fvoices%2Feditorials%2Fcollective-punishment-david-camerons-remarks-about-muslims-condoning-isiss-horrors-will-antagonise-those-whose-support-he-needs-10332968.html&ri=f265edd45a81bac60e91eea8ca10d315&sd=v2_4fa9611b84a1cfe160b0cc940ca9aac7_1539256c-62a8-4b6a-9be9-af6279f9ce7d_1434794525_1434795015_CG4Qr5Y-&ui=1539256c-62a8-4b6a-9be9-af6279f9ce7d&it=text&ii=1243238591615928768&pt=text&li=rbox-t2m&url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.independent.co.uk%2Fvoices%2Fcomment%2Ffor-british-muslim-women-isis-may-offer-freedom-10329930.html&vi=1434795016477&r=6

2 articles from the i about isis. Hope the link works. I did not expect it to look like this.

durhamjen Sat 20-Jun-15 11:20:43

www.independent.co.uk/voices/comment/saudi-arabia-is-teaching-isis-a-lesson-in-cruelty-yet-the-uk-continues-to-defend-them-10324161.html

Have you read this, stansgran? Can you explain why the British government thinks Bawadi's punishment is okay?

Jane10 Sat 20-Jun-15 11:25:41

Don't forget the Spanish Inquisition! Seriously though the fervent early Christian missionaries were pretty sure they were right and anyone else was wrong! Even within Christianity people were killed for being of the "wrong" denomination. The Crusades weren't exactly our finest hour either. I did like a comment posted earlier about people/nationalities developing and changing ideologies at different times.
Everything said about Christians and Muslims is true but should perhaps be qualified the word "some"- eg some Muslims insist on women wearing niqab/hijab (but many do not) some Christians wont work on Sundays (but many do) etc. We should be wary of damaging sweeping statements.
However, despite all that, it does seem that we Brits are too polite to point out openly that some Muslims appear to want to remain absolutely separate from us and to refuse to take on British values. They seem happy to take advantage of our freedom of speech to denigrate our values.

loopylou Sat 20-Jun-15 11:33:55

grin Stansgran
My mini iPad does its own thing too with lots of spellings hmm

Soutra Sat 20-Jun-15 12:33:26

No one expected the Spanish Inquisition Jane 10 did they?
I think you make a very good point when you say we should include the word " some".

jinglbellsfrocks Sat 20-Jun-15 13:08:34

I think we should consider the religions only as they are today, not as they have been way back in history. Islamism has had quite long enough to grow up.

trisher Sat 20-Jun-15 13:52:52

I do think that there are some good values in Islam and to condemn a whole religion because of the actions of a few extremists is wrong. There is a great emphasis on charity, some of which is a compulsory part, some a voluntary one. There is a great sense of community and providing for members of the community. One problem is the things we see which bother us, the niquab, the segregation, the subservience of women are the obvious and widely publicised face of Islam. The other things remain hidden.

jinglbellsfrocks Sat 20-Jun-15 14:08:59

The stoning, hanging and beheading goes on today. Not in this country, thank God, though if some had their way, they might.