Gransnet forums

Chat

What happened to British reserve?

(82 Posts)
rosequartz Sun 14-Dec-14 16:00:06

I just typed this as part of a post on another thread and it got me thinking. What has happened to British reserve?
Studio audiences now always seem to be screaming, shouting, caterwauling etc. Do people generally seem to have less self-control than they had when we were younger?
Is this a bad or a good thing - a lot of what we hear on tv seems a complete over-reaction to whatever is happening in the studio. Or is it better to 'let it all out' with enthusiasm?

vampirequeen Sun 14-Dec-14 18:59:57

I'm not concerned about the more touchy feely nature of relationships but I can't stand the hysterical grief now shown by so many people. I don't mean that those who have lost a close relative or friend shouldn't cry and grieve. It's the public grief for someone who was in the public eye that I can't stand.

I remember watching Diana's funeral. People weeping and wailing, throwing flowers and screaming her name. Who were these people? Did they personally know Diana or were they whipped up by a form of mass hysteria that seemed to take over the public and the media?

Since then it seems that, at times, there is a competition to see who can grieve the loudest.

vegasmags Sun 14-Dec-14 19:00:29

I don't like the way one can be expected now to kiss acquaintances. I prefer shaking hands, but this is a custom that seems to be dying out.

vampirequeen Sun 14-Dec-14 19:16:27

I agree about kissing. Is it going to be an air kiss or a cheek kiss? Will it be one, two or even three kisses? Whatever it is it's definitely and invasion of my personal space. A good firm handshake is far preferable.

rosequartz Sun 14-Dec-14 19:38:34

I really dislike the them and us of this sort of discussion
No-one is forcing anyone to join in this thread.

rosequartz Sun 14-Dec-14 19:40:39

Kissing - another thing that has changed! So many people kiss these days that I have embarrassed myself by kissing a couple of people who obviously would have preferred not to have been kissed - as I would prefer not to be kissed by some people tchblush

janerowena Sun 14-Dec-14 19:48:46

I blame The Price is Right. That was the first example of it I ever saw, and I hated it. I'm used to it now, but I remember feeling very uncomfortable, these weird people running down the stairs waving their arms in a most peculiar and awkward fashion.

Gracesgran Sun 14-Dec-14 19:50:28

I'm sure I have said this on her before but in the court of Henry VIII you would have been greeted by a full kiss on he lips. It's just that times have changed and will change again. Our young people will no doubt, in years to come, be complaining about things which discomfort them but seem entirely reasonable to their offspring.

soontobe Sun 14-Dec-14 20:22:25

I agree Gracesgran.
I used to think that generations changed for change sake. But I dont think they do now.
I cant explain why things change, but they do. And a generation is largely in agreement with itself.
My daughter I thought had some new odd ideas about weddings. But we let them happen as it was her wedding.
But then I got talking to a couple of cousins a couple of months later, and their daughters were thinking exactly the same thoughts as my daughter.
I for one like the exuberance of the young. They are friendly and upfront.

Agus Sun 14-Dec-14 20:27:15

this is their time not ours
We are all a part of society and as I'm not dead yet, it is still my time too.

Ana Sun 14-Dec-14 20:29:08

Well said, Agus! tchgrin

Agus Sun 14-Dec-14 20:32:57

The kissy thing, I enjoy with my family, especially GDs but I'm uncomfortable doing this with outsiders.

Whilst living in France, I got to a point where I really got fed up with it.

Gracesgran Sun 14-Dec-14 20:33:37

Agus I have never seen (historically) an older generation make progressive changes but perhaps you have. Of course we are all part of society but I am not sure how that is relevant.

Agus Sun 14-Dec-14 20:33:48

Thank you Ana. Still alive and kicking grin

Grannyknot Sun 14-Dec-14 20:37:46

feetle there is a trend again to be photographed with babies who are stillborn. I've seen photos like that recently of a mum with her baby; and also mum, dad and the infant who was "born sleeping", which is the term used. I don't know how I feel about it.

The photos are unspeakably sad, as can be expected.

soontobe Sun 14-Dec-14 20:41:52

It must help them I assume Grannyknot. Everyone grieves differently. Not sure whether I would have done it. I could imagine my daughter doing it though. Hope she doesnt have to. But, and here I may be oversharing, her husband lost a brother in that way.

Agus Sun 14-Dec-14 20:50:19

It is relevant to me as I still see myself as a a useful member of society still capable of making progressive changes but perhaps you don't.

soontobe Sun 14-Dec-14 20:54:15

But we dont want to deny youngsters their way of doing things. They come first in my opinion.

Gracesgran Sun 14-Dec-14 20:56:47

Agus I am not saying you are not a useful member of society and, of course you could be part of the generation that tends to make progressive change. I would describe that as the 20 - 40 year olds but it may be narrower than that. Of course some older people make hugely important contributions to change and progress but they are few and far between. I would love to hear just how you intend to improve life for the rest of us as you obviously believe you can - which is great.

You really only have to read many of the comments on this thread to see that change is the last thing many older people want and progress always means change.

Anya Sun 14-Dec-14 21:04:56

No, youngsters do not come first. This is not a competition, everyone is equal here.

Anya Sun 14-Dec-14 21:06:49

What a ridiculous demand to make of Agus .... hmm

soontobe Sun 14-Dec-14 21:06:55

So in a boat accident, you wouldnt let a youngster get off before you?

Gracesgran Sun 14-Dec-14 21:19:57

Can you not read Anya. No where did I say that youngsters come first.

It was Agus who personalised this by saying she/he would still see myself as a a useful member of society still capable of making progressive changes. I only asked what those were.

Please do not criticise what you would like to view as what I have written. I don't mind you commenting on what I actually write but making things up is not a discussion. I would not comment on someone personally - I do not know you all beyond what you write.

We all fulfil different functions in society at different times and it is not unreasonable to say that the older and old members of society are not, except with few exceptions, the change makers. That is a fact and not really one to get het up about.

Ana Sun 14-Dec-14 21:35:30

Gracesgran, you wrote 'this is their time not ours' to which Agus responded 'We are all a part of society and as I'm not dead yet, it is still my time too.'

Which it is, of course.

It does seem that you are the one getting het up about nothing, and being rather rude to other members in the process.

Anya Sun 14-Dec-14 21:36:11

Can you not read either....did I say YOU said that? It was soontobe I was responding to, if you read the post previous to yours hmm

Get off your high horse.

Agus Sun 14-Dec-14 21:37:46

Gracesgran it really isn't difficult to understand, I still have a voice and use it along with voices of mixed generations who feel strongly enough to want to at least attempt to right the wrongs.

I find your tone insulting and patronising personally and to our generation.

Don't hold your breath waiting for me to justify myself to you.