Gransnet forums

Chat

TV news readers' pronunciations

(39 Posts)
railman Wed 02-Aug-17 19:31:31

Is it me I wonder?

Recently, I find myself getting increasingly vexed by the news reader (Breakfast, Lunchtime, and Evening) preference for the phrase "5 time winner", or "Train station" (Yes I know my nom de guerre is a giveaway!).

The "x time" phrase is by far the most irritating - as it is meaningless - do they forget, or simply don't know the difference between plural and singular!!

Why not say "5 times winner" if you must - at least it reflect the plurality of the statement.

Lastly, why oh why do we insist on "exiting the EU' instead of simply "leaving", and the insistence on using "fewer than...." when "less than ...." conveys the same message for us mere mortals.

I know this should perhaps be aimed at 'Pedant's Corner' but there's been so much of this stuff on the telly lately - BBC are particularly prone at the moment!!

hildajenniJ Wed 02-Aug-17 19:43:54

Ooh railman, I too am irritated by train station, it was a railway station all the time that I was growing up. We were asked whether we wanted to leave or remain in the EU on the ballot paper, so where did "Brexit" come from? There was no mention of exit before the vote to leave.

sara4 Wed 02-Aug-17 19:56:14

I feel they use 'less than' when they mean 'fewer than' and 'BBC is ...'. And why do so many people speak so quickly it is hard to follow them.?

Deedaa Wed 02-Aug-17 22:01:07

Train station really annoys me. All my childhood we referred to it as The Station. If we meant a bus or coach station then that was what we would call it. Another one is Horse Riding, or even worse, Horseback Riding (what other bit of it would you ride on?) If we rode horses we went Riding, if we rode bicycles we went Cycling. End of - to use another irritating phrase.

durhamjen Wed 02-Aug-17 22:05:52

"BBC is" is correct. There is only one BBC.

MawBroon Wed 02-Aug-17 23:03:34

Is this really about pronunciation or sloppy grammar and neologisms?

durhamjen Wed 02-Aug-17 23:07:07

Well, that's railman told, then.

Jalima1108 Wed 02-Aug-17 23:17:41

There is a difference between 'fewer than' and 'less than'.
BBC is singular

BlueBelle Thu 03-Aug-17 06:35:26

Train station sounds ok to me when I was a kid it was railway station but language changes and evolves we have to move with the times. I think of it as a train station now
It's the same for a radio you'd never use the word wireless now would you but that's what we grew up with saying
If words and phrases didn't evolve our language would still be .....methinks I ll make some haste to my bedchamber with my beau
Got to move with the times

Christinefrance Thu 03-Aug-17 08:49:20

Yesterday on Breakfast TV I heard that the Duke of Edinburgh was to perform his last solo engagement on his own that day ! !

MawBroon Thu 03-Aug-17 08:51:37

Never one to miss a dig, eh? DJ
Well is it?

Alima Thu 03-Aug-17 08:57:46

As the thread title refers to pronunciation rather than the twisted way with words presenters often use it reminded me of Moira Stuart. She was/is (but on CE show so never hear her) a wonderful news reader. You could hear every word she said and she seemed to take great care in pronouncing the most unfamiliar names or words. Bring back Moira to the evening BBC1 news I say!

railman Thu 03-Aug-17 10:00:34

Like it BlueBelle - I guess that's why the US still uses the word "gotten".

I clearly have a lot to learn about neologisms (whatever they are) and the other stuff, but sometimes it just doesn't sound right to my ear.

railman Thu 03-Aug-17 10:03:31

Yes Jalima I agree, but when you have 12 items in your basket and you go to the "Fewer than 10 ..." does it really matter.

On the self-service version that may be followed by "unexpected item in the bagging area"!!

What's the "bagging area"?

Jalima1108 Thu 03-Aug-17 10:04:48

I don't know what is wrong with 'Train station', after all, we have 'Bus station'.
It is a place where trains stop so that passengers can get on or off (stationary?).
The railway itself doesn't stop or become stationary, the trains travel along it
confused

Jalima1108 Thu 03-Aug-17 10:09:02

when you have 12 items in your basket and you go to the "Fewer than 10 ..." does it really matter.
shock but I would never do that!! grin
I would count to make sure that I had no more than 9.

durhamjen Thu 03-Aug-17 10:25:01

Sorry, Maw, weren't you getting a dig in at railman?

I don't see your point.

MawBroon Thu 03-Aug-17 10:42:09

No, just pointing out that pronunciation doesn't seem to be at issue confused

durhamjen Thu 03-Aug-17 11:08:06

Okay, I'll get back to the ospreys.

Alima Thu 03-Aug-17 11:08:45

Glad you said that Maw, thought I'd got it wrong again.

grannyticktock Thu 03-Aug-17 11:29:27

Huh. I had that "Unexpected item in the bagging area" message the other day, every time I put my bag on the little platform. Eventually I said firmly to the machine,"It's not unexpected, it's a BAG!" and got a funny look from the man at the next till. In the end I put my bag on the floor and loaded up only when the transaction was complete and the machine wasn't looking. I think I got away with it.

durhamjen Thu 03-Aug-17 11:38:58

It amuses me that I have to put the newspaper on that silly platform when that's all I am buying. I usually forget and wonder why nothing happens.

sunseeker Thu 03-Aug-17 11:58:52

dj I get that whenever I buy a birthday card or something very light!

Ana Thu 03-Aug-17 12:03:59

Don't you just scan it? Why should anything else happen?

durhamjen Thu 03-Aug-17 13:45:52

Has to go in the bagging area after scanning, just like sunseeker's birthday card.