Gransnet forums

TV, radio, film, Arts

The "A" Word

(82 Posts)
phoenix Wed 23-Mar-16 18:30:11

First episode of this new drama last night, I thought it showed promise.

Interesting interaction between the characters, plus of course how it dealt with the subject of autism, which I appreciate has many levels and forms.

Did anyone else watch, and if so what did you think?

Deedaa Sat 26-Mar-16 20:46:11

Once he's got into a character we live with it till he finds another one!

LullyDully Wed 30-Mar-16 08:14:57

Can you just take a child out to home school...?..No questioned asked. Surely the doctor would have contacted the school and asked for a report. Could they just let him walk into school one morning having taken him out? A but far fetched IMO.

durhamjen Wed 30-Mar-16 10:01:01

That's not how it happened in my grandson's case.
The local authority is involved, otherwise the parents get fined for not having the child educated.
You have to write to the local authority. Considering the mother was on the laptop all the time finding out about homeschooling, you'd think they would have found that out.
I can't work out the timescale in this. Everything seems to happen very quickly, and nobody was really teaching the boy anyway.
I presume they could just let him walk back in because he had not been taken off the register.

trisher Wed 30-Mar-16 10:53:27

I've stopped taking this programme seriously. Everyone seems to wander in and out of that school as they please, haven't they heard of safeguarding? And the school seems to be sadly ignorant about anything to do with behaviour that needs to be looked at. If they hadn't done anything else they would surely have discussed this at parent's evenings. I also don't understand why the woman's affair seemed to be public knowledge when they moved back , but no-one noticed when the child was out of school and wandering around. I thought it was going to be a serious drama but really it's just a soap opera stance on a serious subject.

LullyDully Wed 30-Mar-16 12:45:26

It certainly doesn't show any school input.

ninathenana Wed 30-Mar-16 14:08:07

I agree the safe guarding in the school should be better portrayed.
As for school noticing the boys unusual behaviour. They never did with my son sad
Parts are spot on but so much doesn't add up

trisher Wed 30-Mar-16 14:50:12

I keep thinking about the school that failed its Ofsted because the inspectors arrived early and the cleaner let them in without asking for ID (no staff there). The inspectors gave it an immediate fail and left. Heaven knows what they would make of this school!!! I hope things have improved nina with the 0-25 strategy looking for early signs, but I suppose you are right.

Leonora47 Wed 30-Mar-16 17:25:00

This boy is fixated on his music , and has perfect recall of all their lyrics.
He also seems to have a good sense of pitch and rhythm. Why has no one has tried music therapy for him?
He might
respond joyfully to being given the opportunity to make music for himself. Most computers have music making programs.
But possibly that's why the, " hard man" grandpa is having those rather uncharacteristic music lessons. Will grandpa save the day, by taking the lad to his own music teacher? The pub is out, and he needs to keep his grandson amused somehow.
A few sufferers from Autism have amazing ' special ' talents in art, maths, and music for example. They used to be known as, "Idiot
Savants" but I assume there is now a more pc term for such geniuses.

Deedaa Wed 30-Mar-16 21:52:08

I think it's sad that GS1, who used to love school when he started, now mostly dreads going there. The constantly changing teachers haven't helped this year. The latest one thinks he's "a bit of a Diva" and needs to think about his future (He's 9 for heavens sake!)

DD took him on a trip the the Harry Potter studios with the Autistic group he belong to . It was great because they all had "issues" and nobody minded!

ninathenana Fri 01-Apr-16 00:25:24

Deedaa I find that teacher's comment out of order. I'm assuming he is aware of your GS diagnosis ? If so, he shows a total lack of understanding of ASD and needs some extra training.

durhamjen Fri 01-Apr-16 10:21:00

I think autism awareness should be taught to all teachers and trainee teachers.
The latest research shows that the average age at which autism is picked up is 4.5 years, so many children will be around Joe's age when it is diagnosed. This hasn't changed for the past ten years.

www.autism.org.uk/get-involved/world-autism-awareness-week.aspx

Starts tomorrow.

Greenfinch Fri 01-Apr-16 11:37:22

I am amazed by the fact that the average age for diagnosis is 4.5 years which is far too late in my opinion. My grandson was seen by the specialist when he was 2.5 and those 2 years before going to school were vital in his development.It gave us time to employ a good speech therapist and social services were marvellous in visiting him at home and helping him with social skills etc. They also were a good support to the family. Going by our experience it was fairly obvious by 2.5 years that there was some sort of problem. In our case it was delayed speech and lack of imaginative play as well as earlier signs like not unclenching his fist at 3+ months, the lack of pointing and waving, and walking on tip toes which he still does given half a chance. Obviously in themselves these are not evidence of autism but they are indicators of a problem if all occur together.

Because of good early intervention my DGS was able to attend main stream school with his twin. He has reached all his targets for his year and is in the middle group for comprehension .This has not been attained without hard work : he has to do all his homework even though he doesn't want to and he is disciplined in the same way as any child of his age.

Of course there are still many problems .Social skills are still lacking somewhat and he finds it very difficult to share and empathise with others.
The remains of his echolalia are still there and he often sounds like a mini adult with phrases he has picked up.

I can't believe that Joe's parents did not seek help earlier. Perhaps it was because they were both ashamed of him as suggested. I feel very sorry for him as they allow him to listen to music all day long without trying to involve him in their world.

hildajenniJ Fri 01-Apr-16 14:50:27

I will not watch any more of this. I saw the first episode and was very disappointed. My DD has watched both episodes and says it is utter clap trap. She has three boys with ASD's so knows all about it!

durhamjen Fri 01-Apr-16 15:37:55

My grandson was picked up early as well, Greenfinch. The research was mentioned on the radio this morning. It was Newcastle University, looking at the past ten years.
I think Joe's parents did not look for help earlier because nobody in the family seemed remotely aware of the possibility. It 's still like that in many cases.
The sister in law arriving on the scene like that was very fortuitous, but I suppose there had to be someone to help, otherwise he would just have been left sitting on the sidelines at school.
Having gone back to school, hopefully, he will be statemented and get one-to-one help. What's the betting it will be with the girl who lost her job in the factory, who was possibly a primary school teacher in her home country.
It may seem like utter claptrap to some of us who know someone with autism, but it's the others who need to think about how the child who is different is treated. I do not think it is aimed at those who know someone with autism.
We all feel sorry for him being missed out of the party, but it happens quite often, as does standing with your back to the wall looking the other way to cut out sound and movement, swinging looking up at the sky all the time, and lots of other small things that single Joe out from the others in his class.

This is from the autism.org.uk website.

www.autism.org.uk/get-involved/tmi.aspx

A video called too much information.

Jane10 Fri 01-Apr-16 15:59:33

I think I've said before that the average age of referral to our diagnostic service was 38. Oldest referral was 84. So actually 4.5 is a BIG improvement!

Greenfinch Fri 01-Apr-16 16:09:42

What is the point of such a late referral ?What help can be given at that age ?

You are right durhamjen.It is easy to forget that many people would not recognise autism.

I was interested in young Alexwho promotes the "advertisement" and does it very well. At 10 he knows he has autism and I was wondering what is the best age to tell a child.We have explained his problem to my grandson but have not used the word autism. However he still thinks he is stupid because he has a one to one helper.

rosesarered Fri 01-Apr-16 16:40:21

We talked to our DGS ( with his Mother there) about him having autism when he was almost 8, the fact that his brain is wired up differently, but also that so many other children and adults had the same ( he was comforted by those two facts.)
Children need to know why they are different, but you have to judge the moment to tell them.

ninathenana Fri 01-Apr-16 16:40:56

Greenfinch although my son is 25 not 38 or older. He , his dad and I feel it was the right thing to do. He now spends much more time in our company rather than shutting himself away in his room (communication is still on a speak when spoken too basis) He will be attending the local ASD community get togethers and his ASD case worker is helping with his PIP appeal. None of this would have happened without referral. Yes it's too late for his education but that's not all that's involved.

rosesarered Fri 01-Apr-16 16:41:12

He also knows that many well known people both now and in the past were the same and achieved many things.

Jane10 Fri 01-Apr-16 16:42:34

Its not a matter of getting help. Its understanding themselves and looking at life from a different perspective. It can be very useful for partners and people's children to understand why the individual is the way s/he is. They can give themselves permission to eg not go to parties or staff nights out. They can identify sensory strategies that help them etc etc. Sometimes just self understanding can make a lifetime's problems click into place and make sense. There are 5 times as many adults as children on the spectrum and most are not diagnosed as they don't need to be.

Deedaa Fri 01-Apr-16 17:50:37

ninathenana No I don't think the teacher was aware of all the problems, he's one of many they've had filling in this year which has been far from ideal. It's really only in the last couple of years that there has been a real problem. Previously he seemed pretty normal, although now we can compare him with his younger brother we can see he's always been a bit different. When he was little his dislike of certain foods (well most food actually) and certain clothes didn't seem symptomatic of anything. Lately noise has become a real issue. He is still waiting for an official diagnosis but the school is taking it as read.

Penstemmon Fri 01-Apr-16 18:11:21

Often parents do know something is not right about their precious child but, understandably, find it very hard to face. Some of the hardest situations I have had to work with and support were parents who did not want a diagnosis even though school, friends and often other family members were very aware of the child's specific needs. We had one child who was with us all through nursery, reception and KS1 but parents would not allow us to have him assessed. It was devastating for them to think that ther child was 'different' to the one they had planned and dreamed about having. Meanwhile we supported as best we could but had no additional funds to provide specialist therapy or to provide an extra pair of hands in his class to support the teacher to meet his needs.

My nephew, aged 25, was recently diagnosed as having Asperger's Syndrome. We all knew he was slow to reach major milestones, found learning quite tricky and was rather 'quirky' but put all this down to his very early birth (26 weeks). It is only as he got older that his inability to fully empathise, and to be brutally blunt on occassions, caught the attention of people at the job center! He was referred to a specialist at the local teaching hospital and diagnosed.

durhamjen Sat 02-Apr-16 00:53:27

One of the reasons my grandson was diagnosed early was because there are so many teachers in the family and we all recognised the signs, so suggested having him tested, particularly for language development.
We also knew that if he wasn't statemented before he started proper school, he would not get the help straight away.

Unfortunately most families do not have that help.

Greenfinch Sat 02-Apr-16 08:01:26

My grandson had an early diagnosis because a doctor at A and E picked it up.My daughter was asked where GS said he hurt and she said that he didn't actually say very much. Within 3 months he was seen by a paediatrician and labelled!

durhamjen Sat 02-Apr-16 10:19:49

The GP in The A Word was a bit hopeless, wasn't he, Greenfinch?

Being labelled is a good thing. It got a lot of pull-ups for him until he was able to control himself at school.
We are reading a Robert Winston book called What Goes on in my Head at the moment. Lots of stuff in there about what happens automatically that didn't with him. He has to learn a lot more than the neurotypical child, e.g., his sister.
What is good is that he can see it, and talk about it, about how he is different and what to do about it.