I know what you mean about needing a pinker shade, I started to think I look like death warmed up a year or so ago, although I look ok in the summer.
I did feel for my sister, she is beautiful but for her daughter's wedding the makeup artist used a foundation that made her skin look almost pale green, it was so yellow. It was meant to have given her a lightly-tanned look. I can see why she went wrong, as my sister does have a slight yellow tint to her skin, but it needed counteracting, not deepening. It looked dreadful in daylight but brilliant in photos.