Sago
greyfur
foxie48
Sago the question I asked which you haven't answered was,
"if currently the ethnicity of criminals isn't recorded, what makes you think immigration is relevant? "
Actually the Ministry of Justice does collect information on the ethnicity of prisoners but it does not record immigration status. There isn't any evidence to suggest that immigrants, "illegal" or otherwise commit more crimes than British nationals but perhaps when they are convicted of a crime it is possible that this is more widely reported in the media? If you find anything that provides evidence that "immigrants" commit more crimes, if you attach a link, I will, of course, read it.
I suppose if you believe something, it's easy enough to find evidence to back up your thoughts.
While the MoJ does collect this data, tracking ethnicity is not mandatory. As a result, the statistics face several notable gaps:Missing Ethnicity Records: Approximately 33% to 36% of defendants' ethnicities are listed as "unknown" at the Crown Court and magistrates' courts. This frequently occurs in less serious offences handled via the Single Justice Procedure.Immigration and Status: The Ministry of Justice does not routinely publish comprehensive breakdowns of all crime perpetrators categorized by strict immigration status or nationality.Offender Characteristics vs. VictimizationThe MoJ focuses on the demographic characteristics of defendants and convicted offenders. In contrast, the Office for National Statistics (ONS) measures crime from the victim's perspective using the Crime Survey for England and Wales (CSEW).
Tracking Ethnicity is in fact mandatory at all stages of Criminal Justice System
Under PACE- Police and Criminal Evidence Act- it is mandatory in England and Wales to record the ethnicity of an arrested person, both SDE- Self Defined Ethnicity AND Officer Identified Ethnicity. The police also document an arrested person- usually photograph, finger prints, DNA but can also include, none intimate body search, intimate body search, blood samples, finger nail clippings etc etc. They take mobile phones from detained person which they send to down load to look for evidence. If a person refuses to provide their ethnicity Officer Identified Ethnicity will be available.
The arrested detained person has access to free legal advice via a duty solicitor and an interpreter if needed- all this helps identify ethnicity if DP withholds- which in my experience they hardly ever do.
The Police pass this information to the Crown Prosecution Service who then makes the decision whether to prosecute and also logs SIE and OIE ethnicity data.
The number of individuals prosecuted and convicted is recorded and ethnicity data recorded.
Various crimes are broken down further in the same way, e.g. rape., e.g for rape offences.
Ethnicity is mandatory to record as a convicted person enters prison also.