Gransnet forums

News & politics

Significant rise in both anti-semitism and Islamophobia

(97 Posts)
Whitewavemark2 Mon 20-Apr-26 07:43:02

What is it with all this hatred and division?

Do people prefer to live in a society where mistrust of one’s neighbour is the norm?

It has almost certainly got worse since the Middle East crises in Gaza and now spreading further afield, but it is staggering how people are so willing to “blame” their neighbour.

Allsorts Wed 22-Apr-26 06:47:53

There were rumours Annie that babies were put in ovens which were thoroughly investigated and found to be untrue.
The only way to get lasting peace is to respect the rights of both sides, you cannot keep pushing a whole nation about as they do. Netanyahu lacks respect or compassion for anyone if not Israeli. He is not the one to bring a resolution. It seems the World is at war to get more land and those that have most weaponry win. Trumps at it and Putin, they have more land than they could ever use anyway.

Smileless2012 Tue 21-Apr-26 12:23:28

not true said the majority posting because it wasn't true Annie. There is and never has been any evidence that babies were put into ovens so whoever stated so at the time was lying.

Anniebach Tue 21-Apr-26 11:59:33

Thank you Smileless, when we first talked of the attack on Israel and Israel’s reaction it was stated then the babies were put in ovens, not true said the majority posting, everyday Hamas gave the number killed, the majority believed Hamas !

Smileless2012 Tue 21-Apr-26 11:29:47

There is noevidence that babies were put into ovens Annie. What happened that day was horrific enough.

foxie48 Tue 21-Apr-26 11:20:27

"Benjamin Netanyahu is considered a secular Jew who comes from a secular, right-wing Zionist background. While not personally observant or religious in his daily life, he often adopts religious traditions, such as wearing a kippa and reciting prayers, when his political role requires it. His ideology focuses on Jewish nationalism rather than religious observance." AI generated

Whitewavemark2 Tue 21-Apr-26 11:10:46

Caleo

Anniebach

The Israeli government are not Jews ?

Good question!

No, the Netanyahu regime are not Jewish- like Trump is not Christian.
Judaism is a good religion :
Christianity is a good religion :
Islam is a good religion.

Yes

Despite so much written on these posts, people are still conflating people’s religious faith with governments in their posts.

Caleo Tue 21-Apr-26 10:18:39

Anniebach

The Israeli government are not Jews ?

Good question!

No, the Netanyahu regime are not Jewish- like Trump is not Christian.
Judaism is a good religion :
Christianity is a good religion :
Islam is a good religion.

ferry23 Tue 21-Apr-26 07:51:04

sandelf

In both cases the ill will is fuelled by Observant Jews and Muslims who do not realise I can strongly object to the current regime in Jerusalem or to any Islamic governments' behaviour while being completely tolerant of them and their religion. The failure to make this separation has done huge harm.

This is an awful thing to say. I sincerely hope your use of the word "observant" was misjudged. What on earth has being "observant" (i.e., following the laws of a religion) have to do with them thinking that others are not tolerant of them because of the actions of their government?

YOU are making the kind of accusations towards religious groups that fuels ill will.

twaddle Mon 20-Apr-26 22:52:18

Anniebach

Add comment | Report | Private message | Quote valdali Mon 20-Apr-26 21:35:19
There is no evidence that babies were put in ovens in the 7th October attack, Anniebach.
You state it as fact.
Please do not accuse even terrorists of something so horrific with such certainty

Please do not tell me what I may post, many reports of the treatment of children by Hamas, the Bibas Family !

You can post whatever you like, but if you are going to post about babies in ovens, you can expect to be told that even Israeli sources discovered no evidence.

Anniebach Mon 20-Apr-26 22:41:54

The Israeli government are not Jews ?

Cossy Mon 20-Apr-26 22:30:26

valdali

I do think the antisemitism and the attacks are appalling.

I do blame Israel for souring the mood in countries that have long been their allies, by their indiscriminate use of bombs & drones & disproportionate armed force against their neighbours.

I know that British jewish people are in no way responsible for Israel's actions, I feel for their wrongs, but I think that as we have felt more able to openly criticize Israel's actions, that in itself has allowed people who've always been antisemitic to be openly antisemitic now.

Surely it’s the Israeli govt you blame, not the citizens of Israel?

Cossy Mon 20-Apr-26 22:27:52

Rosie51

There has always been antisemitism, long before the present conflict and I just don't understand why. Justifying or 'explaining' the current surge in the context of opposition to the Israeli government is unfeeling to say the least. Either you condemn antisemitism or you don't.

What do they say about people who start with "I'm not racist....."

The 2021 census put Jews as 0.5% of the UK population, and Muslims as 6.5% of the UK population. The number of incidents of antisemitism is a much higher percentage than the equivalent Islamophobic incidents. Jews are definitely the most vulnerable group in present day society. All prejudice and oppression is wrong, none can be justified, and it all needs stamping out.

🫶👏👏👏👏

Anniebach Mon 20-Apr-26 22:09:53

Add comment | Report | Private message | Quote valdali Mon 20-Apr-26 21:35:19
There is no evidence that babies were put in ovens in the 7th October attack, Anniebach.
You state it as fact.
Please do not accuse even terrorists of something so horrific with such certainty

Please do not tell me what I may post, many reports of the treatment of children by Hamas, the Bibas Family !

valdali Mon 20-Apr-26 21:35:19

There is no evidence that babies were put in ovens in the 7th October attack, Anniebach.
You state it as fact.
Please do not accuse even terrorists of something so horrific with such certainty.

Anniebach Mon 20-Apr-26 21:28:17

Babies were put in ovens in Israel 7th October attack

Maremia Mon 20-Apr-26 21:23:18

Children have been killed in Gaza. Was that just 'collateral damage' or wrong doing?

foxie48 Mon 20-Apr-26 20:53:53

The Iranians voted in the Islamic regime in 1979, the Germans voted Hitler into power, Castro had widespread support during the 1959 revolution. At what point are the descendants of those who made these decisions free from the consequences of their parents and grandparents? IMO civilians, especially those who are children are never culpable for the misdeeds and wrongs of the governments who rule them when they have no chance to overthrow those governments by democratic process.

MartavTaurus Mon 20-Apr-26 20:47:10

But people were antisemitic a decade or more ago, and all over Europe too. I was teaching part time in France 10+ years back and remember the awful Toulouse attack outside a school where 3 little children were killed. Then a couple of years later the kosher supermarket killings where 4 Jewish men died.
These attacks sparked intense fear within the French Jewish community, and this led to a record number of Jewish people emigrating to Israel. I remember Netanyahu visited the scene and encouraged French Jews to leave France. Jews in France were scared to death. And all because they were Jewish.

Anniebach Mon 20-Apr-26 20:30:45

Maremia the children of Gaza didn’t vote for their Hamas government I agree, their elders did.

valdali Mon 20-Apr-26 20:14:06

I do think the antisemitism and the attacks are appalling.

I do blame Israel for souring the mood in countries that have long been their allies, by their indiscriminate use of bombs & drones & disproportionate armed force against their neighbours.

I know that British jewish people are in no way responsible for Israel's actions, I feel for their wrongs, but I think that as we have felt more able to openly criticize Israel's actions, that in itself has allowed people who've always been antisemitic to be openly antisemitic now.

valdali Mon 20-Apr-26 19:58:48

AGAA4

20% of Jewish people are thinking of leaving the UK as they no longer feel safe here.
This rise in hatred in the UK is worrying and upsetting.

Well they're not going to be queuing up to go to Australia, and Israel (especially if you define Israel by their internationally acknowledged boundaries) is full.Europ seems to be similar to the IK in the wake of the Gaza / Lebanon violence.

There's always the US but - not a country I'd want to uproot my life to immigrate to at the moment.

Maremia Mon 20-Apr-26 19:25:13

Yes sandelf, conflation is a problem.

Maremia Mon 20-Apr-26 19:24:09

AnnieB
Hamas declared that.
The children of Gaza did not.
Genocide is not the answer.

sandelf Mon 20-Apr-26 18:57:36

In both cases the ill will is fuelled by Observant Jews and Muslims who do not realise I can strongly object to the current regime in Jerusalem or to any Islamic governments' behaviour while being completely tolerant of them and their religion. The failure to make this separation has done huge harm.

Oreo Mon 20-Apr-26 18:37:51

Allira

AGAA4

It is a blight on our society that some Jews have an 'exit plan' presumably for when they feel it is too dangerous to stay in the UK.
On the other hand the Rabbi whose synagogue was attacked in Manchester has said that this is his country and here he will stay. He prays for better times and believes they will come.
I do hope so for all Jews.

It is a frightening thought that some British Jews think that Israel would be safer than the UK.

I can see why they would, in Israel they wouldn’t have to be looking over their shoulders all the time and would be living in a country where the majority of the population is Jewish.