Genocide is being committed in Gaza by Israel

Not if defeated months ago

Hamas leaders are in Qatar Anniebach. Israel tried to bomb them recently and failed. Most of those in Gaza have been killed.

Proof? AGAA4

ronib

Proof? AGAA4

Have you proof that they are not?

Quote AGAA4 Wed 24-Sept-25 11:38:42
Hamas leaders are in Qatar Anniebach. Israel tried to bomb them recently and failed. Most of those in Gaza have been killed.

So haven’t been defeated

Hamas in Gaza was defeated months ago. The IDF told Netanyahu that it was over militarily but he wants to wipe out all the Palestinians for his own aims.
An IDF soldier admitted to a reporter who was given a 2 hour slot in Gaza at the beginning of the war that they don't kill civilians but then he laughed and said but they are all Hamas. Even children it seems.

anniei can only reiterate what agaahas said.

The IDF, have told the world that there is absolutely no point in carrying on militarily.

Hamas is not defeated if still operating,

Anniebach

Hamas is not defeated if still operating,

The ideology of Hamas will never be defeated as long as the Israelis continue to oppress the Palestinians.

In fact I suspect this war has been the biggest recruitment driver for years.

Many young orphans will grow up hating Israel.

The horrors of The Holocaust and those who came after ,

? Bit random?

Never Again

? Well yes I think we can all agree with that sentiment, but unclear what it has to do with the conversation.

Anniebach

The horrors of The Holocaust and those who came after ,

I was told ‘not that old chestnut’ when mentioning matters historical, so does that only apply to the history of Palestinian suffering?
Genuine question.

I replied to a post which spoke of next generations not forgetting

Whitewavemark2

? Well yes I think we can all agree with that sentiment, but unclear what it has to do with the conversation.

History lessons again WWM.
But don’t think that includes the history of the Palestinians, apparently there is no history worth noting there prior to Oct 7th 2023.

The Nakba Annie.
Look it up or I will be glad to provide the details. Again

Gosh several people still living who lived during historical event , not 1066,

Quote Babs03 Wed 24-Sept-25 12:39:20
The Nakba Annie.
Look it up or I will be glad to provide the details. Again

No thank you, pointless because you class The Holocaust as an old chestnut, in a very subtle way , time for lunch excuse me

Anniebach

Quote Babs03 Wed 24-Sept-25 12:39:20
The Nakba Annie.
Look it up or I will be glad to provide the details. Again

No thank you, pointless because you class The Holocaust as an old chestnut, in a very subtle way , time for lunch excuse me

Oh boy. Totally off beam with that one Annie and Oreo could put you right, she accused me of mentioning ‘that old chestnut’ when giving details of the Nakba. I didn’t refer to the Holocaust as that old chestnut because I believe it is extremely important to remember the horrors people an inflict upon others.
Especially now.

Enjoy your lunch Annie, and have some compassion for those who are literally dying for a bite to eat.

Australian doctors working in the remains of Al-Shifa hospital say it is just mass murder now.
They are doing their best with no anaesthetic and some beds have no mattresses. They saved a baby from his pregnant mother who had been killed by the IDF.
Mass murder by Israel in Gaza city.

Holocaust Day last January a poster spoke of a doctor who claimed he had to amputate legs of a little girl with half her face blown away and he did so without any medication for her, mmmm

Anniebach

Holocaust Day last January a poster spoke of a doctor who claimed he had to amputate legs of a little girl with half her face blown away and he did so without any medication for her, mmmm

Annie we are not comparing and contrasting here, we are not dismissing the horrors of the Holocaust by talking about the genocide unfolding in Gaza.
Am really not sure what your point is anymore.

So you don't believe the Australian doctors. Why would they lie? They are seeing mass murder and trying to cope with casualties. They are there in Gaza.