Gransnet forums

News & politics

Is the UK now on a "war footing"?

(129 Posts)
Wyllow3 Tue 03-Jun-25 12:09:35

Several news outlets are using this as a headline, somewhat OTT imo, but I'm referring to the Review published yesterday by the government and of course the different POV around how much we can spend and the timing of changes (and tax implications!)

The basics:

The review of Armed Forces came out yesterday, it was the first one since 2010.

"Led by Lord Robertson – a former defence secretary and Nato secretary general who conducted Labour’s last defence review in 1998 – it has consulted 150 external experts, received 8,000 submissions to a call for evidence, and runs to 48,000 words"

Apparently "the armed forces “lack the mass, resilience and internal coherence necessary to maintain a deterrent effect and sustain prolonged conflict”. Philip Stephens of the Financial Times wrote that those conclusions “are viewed within Whitehall as wholly uncontroversial”. There are 62 recommendations all of which the government accepted.

There are lots of detail in the all the newspapers, with disagreements about is it enough and is it soon enough.

As well as an increase in troops the main shift takes account of new ways of warfare (AI, robots, lasers) and a fundamental change in the overall picture of what the threats are, and of course how much we should spend on the military as opposed to other needs.

(I noticed that the government are considering a scheme where young people can do an optional one year sampling of military life (as opposed to Sunak's ideas of a compulsory military service)

news.sky.com/story/ai-robots-lasers-and-gap-years-in-armed-forces-key-details-as-uk-to-become-battle-ready-13378251
is a good summary

escaped Tue 03-Jun-25 14:38:43

DUncle of mine was a former Defence Secretary and now sits in the H of Lords. He made an interesting speech last week in Paris about Europe/UK/Nato.

www.lorddavidowen.co.uk/refusing-to-pay-for-our-own-defence-has-kept-america-dominant-in-nato-it-was-a-grievous-error-that-must-never-be-repeated/

nanna8 Tue 03-Jun-25 14:45:53

You never want war. It is awful, beyond awful. The uk tends to get involved in wars and I hope the politicians think very ,very hard before they lead people into death. It would be good if only those in positions of power fought the wars and left the rest of us alone. It is always someone else’s fault somehow.

AGAA4 Tue 03-Jun-25 14:55:13

escaped I agree that Europe have relied too much on the US for defence and now find ourselves with Trump who puts the US and himself first. We cannot now count on the US.

Wyllow3 Tue 03-Jun-25 15:02:26

nanna8

You never want war. It is awful, beyond awful. The uk tends to get involved in wars and I hope the politicians think very ,very hard before they lead people into death. It would be good if only those in positions of power fought the wars and left the rest of us alone. It is always someone else’s fault somehow.

After WW2 I was brought up by parents very concerned to end wars not start them, in the peace movement and CND. I too hate any discussion, but have long accepted its inevitable - plus watching our troops employed as peacekeepers has helped. I'm glad to live in a country that talks about defence not attack.

We did wait far far too long for a review when war has changed so very much. and money is short and very difficult to make strategic decisions with competing demands.

The US "pulling out" is a plus and a minus in Europe.

GrannyGravy13 Tue 03-Jun-25 15:02:48

The new submarines will not be in service until the late 2030’s

It will take years for the new ammunitions factories to begin production.

So no the U.K. is not on a war footing as such.

Allira Tue 03-Jun-25 15:29:59

nanna8

You never want war. It is awful, beyond awful. The uk tends to get involved in wars and I hope the politicians think very ,very hard before they lead people into death. It would be good if only those in positions of power fought the wars and left the rest of us alone. It is always someone else’s fault somehow.

We did not get involved in Vietnam, thankfully.

Yes, wars are started by poopticians, never by soldiers.

Allira Tue 03-Jun-25 15:31:26

Increasing our defence is sensible as it has been decreased substantially over many years.

It does not mean we are on a war footing.
Using such language is scaremongering.

GrannyGravy13 Tue 03-Jun-25 15:32:27

Allira 👍🏻

Allira Tue 03-Jun-25 15:34:42

poopticians
Oh dear, an unfortunate typo 😯

Wyllow3 Tue 03-Jun-25 15:41:51

Yes but a great one 😂

and its another 👍 for Allira's post

FriedGreenTomatoes2 Tue 03-Jun-25 15:43:10

😳

petra Tue 03-Jun-25 15:43:29

Allira

poopticians
Oh dear, an unfortunate typo 😯

One of your best yet 😂
I love them.

Oreo Tue 03-Jun-25 15:56:19

Casdon

I don’t think there is any option but to re-arm. Europe as a whole has been way too complacent about the threat of invasion, and isn’t currently in a position to effectively defend itself. I don’t think this is a Labour Government issue either, I think whichever party was in power would be doing the same thing. Having said that, I don’t think we are actually on a war footing at the moment, we are preparing for if we need to be.

I agree.

Oreo Tue 03-Jun-25 15:57:11

FriedGreen I love the joke😂

M0nica Tue 03-Jun-25 17:51:50

Sarnia

I don't feel we are on a war footing but with the world as it is the Government need to increase spending to improve our defence.
As seen with the wars going on at the moment, drones and modern technology will play a big part in any future conflict.
My Dad always said that scrapping conscription was a bad idea. Young people in this country will need to be trained and ready if and when war affects us.

There was no alternative to scrapping conscription. Conscription belonged to the days when armies were dependent on men in boots fighting hand to hand,cannon fodder, and taking places over.

Modern armies from the youngest private upwards are highly trained technically, psychologically, they are taught how to peace-keep, deal with natural disasters and many other specialised fields. There is no room in a modern army for school leavers, many with no qualifications, to swamp a highly trained army,

LizzieDrip Tue 03-Jun-25 17:54:51

Oreo

FriedGreen I love the joke😂

Yes🤣

Perhaps a ‘spat’ would be even cheaper🤣

FriedGreenTomatoes2 Tue 03-Jun-25 17:58:35

Indeed! We might be able to afford a spat! 😂

karmalady Tue 03-Jun-25 18:13:24

GrannyGravy13

The new submarines will not be in service until the late 2030’s

It will take years for the new ammunitions factories to begin production.

So no the U.K. is not on a war footing as such.

Actually we ae on a war footing. I can say no more

Nanna8, China is observing your part of the world, I hope your defences are ready

karmalady Tue 03-Jun-25 18:16:20

Correct Monica, my dgs will be entering sandhurst with hopefully physics, chemistry and maths A levels

karmalady Tue 03-Jun-25 18:19:22

I also know of some of the processes being developed by our very well -run, high tech engineering companies. We still have a lot of innovation in this country. The expertise is still with us. The focus is very much on defence of the realm

GrannyGravy13 Tue 03-Jun-25 18:26:04

karmalady there are many levels of readiness

When our AC tells us to be worried, then I will be.

Wyllow3 Tue 03-Jun-25 18:30:21

Perhaps there is space for these school leavers if its the one year scheme - someone said this on another board -

If its young people with no qualifications, someone has to cook, medical orderlies, stock food and equipment, clean uniforms, mend vehicles, help dig people out in national emergencies..

If they do have qualifications, it could be a doorway for those with qualifications to deciding whether they are interested in a career like this whatever their skills are.

FriedGreenTomatoes2 Tue 03-Jun-25 18:35:50

GrannyGravy13

karmalady there are many levels of readiness

When our AC tells us to be worried, then I will be.

And then tell us too GG13? I can then park any concerns whipped up by the newspapers until you tell me otherwise.

Thank you in advance.
Your pen pal.
x

Parsley3 Tue 03-Jun-25 19:00:05

The armed forces train new recruits.

winterwhite Tue 03-Jun-25 20:08:14

Is there a definition of ‘being on a war footing’? How would we know?