Gransnet forums

Chat

Erbs!

(62 Posts)
MissAdventure Thu 06-Sept-18 19:48:09

Do you grow any 'erbs?
When did the pronunciation change?
Did it, in fact, change, or has it always been erb, and I just didn't know?

Lyndiloo Sun 09-Sept-18 01:34:36

Kittylester Your mum is absolutely right! An hotel (not pronouncing the 'h' is correct.

NanaWilson Sun 09-Sept-18 07:48:28

I believe it was pronounced ‘erbs in Shakespeare’s day, and changed afterwards

Bathsheba Sun 09-Sept-18 09:00:17

We're British and we pronounce the 'h', so it's herbs, not 'erbs.
If that lot across the pond like to retain the French pronunciation (even in words that aren't French confused), I'm guessing that when they go on their 'grand tours', they visit Paree. I'll have to listen out for that on telly. Could be a while before I come across an example though might not live that long

grandtanteJE65 Sun 09-Sept-18 11:29:30

When I was a child, some of the older generation (by which I mean my grandparents' generation) still said "an otel" instead of "a hotel" as they had been taught that some of the French words that had been incorporated into English should be pronounced in French.

I don't remember anyone talking about erbs, but that is probably because in the Glasgow area only parsley, chives and sage and onion stuffing every made their way to the table! Some people, not my family, used rosemary and thyme stuffing.

I say and write turmeric.

grandtanteJE65 Sun 09-Sept-18 11:31:46

No, Bathseba, they go to Paris, France and Venice, Italy to distinguish these major European cities from their namesakes in the US of A!

Oh, and probably, Vienna, Austria as well, but I don't think they know that Boston, England exists!

grandtanteJE65 Sun 09-Sept-18 11:36:13

While on the subject the Americans, or at least some of them, talk about uman beings, not human beings and I think say umane instead of humane, but I believe they teach the humanities, like we do, not the umanities in their universities.

Susangilley Sun 09-Sept-18 12:34:02

It is herbs for goodness sake. Surely erbs is a send up!

varian Sun 09-Sept-18 19:17:27

Not a send up, just the way Americans mispronounce herbs.

Bellanonna Mon 10-Sept-18 13:36:26

I like that grandetante ?

Bellanonna Mon 10-Sept-18 13:37:04

I mean the Paris, France etc... bit!

Beau Mon 10-Sept-18 14:15:34

I always remember Mia Farrow saying 'erb' in Rosemary's Baby - I was quite young and couldn't understand what she was talking about ?