Well, it has got 49 people talking about it on here, and if you multiply that over the Internet, it seems to have been pretty successful.
3 of these posts are from you, BlueBelle even though you say above Well it hasn’t got me talking Sparkle
If an ad gets people talking about it, even negatively, it's spreading the brand and getting attention. Doesn't matter if it shows Martians or spaceships .... a large group of small children all taking part and thoroughly enjoying themselves, watched by proud parents .... what's not to like?
A previous JL Christmas ad showed a bear in a cave waking up from its hibernation - no one said what have bears got to do with Christmas and John Lewis?