Gransnet forums

Chat

Abortion Time Limit

(136 Posts)
Lyndiloo Mon 02-Apr-18 16:33:59

I'm thinking of starting a Government Petition to reduce the abortion time limit from 24 weeks to 10, and am researching what amount of support I could expect.

I became interested in the subject recently (not knowing much about abortion) when I came across the statistics for abortion in the UK. Since 1967, when the Abortion Act was first introduced, nine-million abortions have been carried out. That's 180,000, per year - equating to 493 per day!

Now, I'm not an anti-abortion fanatic, and I realise that some abortions are necessary for medical or other reasons, but when I delved a little deeper into the subject, I was horrified by the circumstances of late abortions.

Please take a look at my blog (Abortion - 50 Years On) - lynwaites.wixsite.com/writer-poet

I would appreciate your views. Would you consider signing the Petition?

Many thanks for your help.

Nonnie Mon 02-Apr-18 16:41:45

Quite controversial for a first post but I did tell you to go for it!

I don't think you would get enough support, too big a change. If you tried to 20 weeks I think you would get a lot more support. These things are probably better done in smaller steps.

Cold Mon 02-Apr-18 16:50:25

In the UK
81% are carried out below 10 weeks
92% are carried out at 12 weeks or below

Most late terminations are carried out because of problems that are not detected until the 20 week scan or because of serious health risks to the mother.

gillybob Mon 02-Apr-18 16:53:25

Most late terminations are carried out because of problems that are not detected until the 20 week scan or because of serious health risks to the mother

Exactly cold would you be hoping to stop this Lyndiloo ?

MissAdventure Mon 02-Apr-18 16:54:55

I wouldn't sign a petition.

Ilovecheese Mon 02-Apr-18 16:58:18

What Cold said

MawBroon Mon 02-Apr-18 17:02:12

I would imagine much support at all. 10 weeks sounds to me like the point at which only an unwanted pregnancy could be the deciding factor, unlike following a 12 week scan or the 20 week “abnormality” scan cut offs.
I do t see what it would achieve.

ninathenana Mon 02-Apr-18 17:17:04

I didn't even know I was pregnant with DS until I was 11 wks.
This seems far too early too me. I agree with what Maw says.

minesaprosecco Mon 02-Apr-18 17:24:59

What's your justification for the 10 week limit?

SueDonim Mon 02-Apr-18 17:30:15

No, I wouldn't sign your petition. I agree with Cold's post.

janeainsworth Mon 02-Apr-18 17:58:22

No from me too. I wonder if the OP has any compassion at all for women who have to make the grim choice between aborting a longed-for child, and giving birth to a child with severe disabilities.

I notice too that the OPs username is very similar to at least one other GNer who sometimes posts.
I wish GN would have a system of not approving very similar usernames. It’s not fair on the person who thought of it first, particularly when a controversial thread is started in the new name.

maryeliza54 Mon 02-Apr-18 18:01:18

None from me -can you tell me why you hate women so much?

Eloethan Mon 02-Apr-18 18:05:40

Only a very small number of abortions are carried out over 12 weeks' gestation.

I would be very much against lowering the limit to 10 weeks. Whether it is because the child is likely to be profoundly disabled or very sick, or whether it is because the woman/girl feels, for whatever reason, she cannot continue with the pregnancy, I think it should be a woman's choice.

mcem Mon 02-Apr-18 18:06:37

I was surprised and delighted to discover at 37 that I was 14 weeks pregnant. No question of abortion but it does show me that 10 weeks is far too early a cutoff point.
There's a heck of a difference between 10 and 24 weeks.
I won't be signing.
Don't quite get the significance of Nonnie's post.

trisher Mon 02-Apr-18 18:35:27

No No No. 24 weeks is fine. 10 weeks would mean abortions because of abnormalities probably wouldn't happen. Would you force a woman to give birth to and care for a disabled child? Would you force woman to give birth to a child she doesn't want and can't care for simply because she didn't realise she was pregnant until after 10weeks?
You claim not to be an anti-abortion fanatic, but you seem pretty fanatical to me.

Scribbles Mon 02-Apr-18 18:39:53

No. I would not sign your petition.

NanaandGrampy Mon 02-Apr-18 19:02:37

No I would not sign your petition

BlueBelle Mon 02-Apr-18 19:17:48

A no from me too and why do you want us to read your blog is that because you have books to advertise

MissAdventure Mon 02-Apr-18 19:25:03

I've just read the blog, and it does very much come across as anti abortion, whatever the gestation.

Iam64 Mon 02-Apr-18 19:40:28

No from me as well.

Grannybags Mon 02-Apr-18 20:56:49

It's a no from me too.

Claudiaclaws Mon 02-Apr-18 21:06:29

And a no from me.

mcem Mon 02-Apr-18 21:23:20

I've now read some of the OP's blogs and my conclusion is that they are simplistic, dogmatic, narrow-minded, poorly written and lacking in credibility.
Some blogs display nothing more than high-handed self indulgence.

Saxifrage Mon 02-Apr-18 21:50:15

I agree mcem.

Thank goodness we live in a country where government, for the last 50 years, has shown intelligence and compassion for women in this situation.

Let's hope that northern (and Southern) Ireland will soon follow suit.

nanaK54 Mon 02-Apr-18 21:53:18

A firm no from me too