Gransnet forums

Chat

What or Pardon-Neither!!!!

(134 Posts)
trisher Tue 14-Jul-15 10:59:45

There's a Gransnet poll on facebook asking would you say "What" or "Pardon". I'm sorry but if you said "Pardon" when I was growing up you would be answered by "Why? What have you done?" Pardon is used to apologise when you have done something socially unacceptable. "What" is plain rude. The correct form of speech if you don't hear is "Excuse me I didn't hear." or "I'm sorry I didn't hear". Come on Gransnet get someone who at least knows how to use language. What really surprised me was 74% said they would say "Pardon" Really!!!

trisher Wed 15-Jul-15 11:47:06

Oh probably- but it is amusing and harmless because the person being spoken to thinks they are doing really well and they go away feeling quite good about themselves. Better than picking a public fight and berating them I think.

gillybob Wed 15-Jul-15 11:15:35

Yer what?

jinglbellsfrocks Wed 15-Jul-15 11:07:34

what a disgraceful way to behave.

trisher Wed 15-Jul-15 10:04:06

I have a relative who is so good at this. Unless you know her very well she can seem to be saying something really pleasant, and being ultra-polite. Those in the know recognise the sarcasm involved and squirm inwardly for the person who is being targeted.

thatbags Wed 15-Jul-15 09:04:12

I think how things are said matters a great deal more than what. One can be extremely rude (deliberately) while using words that are usually used politely, and one can be completely non-offensive using words that some regard as rude. Context and manner (body language) are far more important than diction.

Eloethan Wed 15-Jul-15 01:37:41

I agree with Anya. All this "U and non-U" stuff just perpetuates a climate of snobbery. As long as it is clear what is being said, does it really matter how it is said?

Katek Tue 14-Jul-15 23:04:11

'Say again' here....also military family.

merlotgran Tue 14-Jul-15 23:00:26

Well, if we ever need a re-cap we can always dip into Jilly Cooper's 'Class'

Gracesgran Tue 14-Jul-15 22:57:24

Whatever we grew up with many of these "rules" are out of date now. The idea of U and non-U came from an essay by Nancy Mitford in 1955 so things will have changed a little since then.

merlotgran Tue 14-Jul-15 22:01:48

I beg your pardon is very Margot Leadbetter (from The Good Life) grin

trisher Tue 14-Jul-15 21:44:41

Oh I loved that programme. Why can't they show some of these things again?
Got a song now-"I beg your pardon, I never promised you a rose garden"-can't remember anything else. Any ideas?

vampirequeen Tue 14-Jul-15 19:43:51

The programme was called, 'I didn't know you cared'.

J52 Tue 14-Jul-15 19:38:39

Jane10, yes there was Uncle Mort. I also remember it as odd, but good!
I think it was in black and white, which probably added to its oddness!

x

vampirequeen Tue 14-Jul-15 19:28:19

I always thought, 'I beg your pardon', was used as an exclamation of dissatisfaction when someone says something you perceive to be impolite or vulgar.

jinglbellsfrocks Tue 14-Jul-15 19:23:36

Yes. "I beg your pardon" sounds snotty.

jinglbellsfrocks Tue 14-Jul-15 19:22:58

I'm sure everyone says "pardon" sometimes. No one sticks to just one term.

Jane10 Tue 14-Jul-15 19:20:23

J52 was there not an uncle Mort? I do remember the programme. It was very odd (but good)

thatbags Tue 14-Jul-15 19:06:19

I don't think I was ever taught that anything was non-U. Just saying.

One can say "I beg your pardon?" in a very superior way wink

vampirequeen Tue 14-Jul-15 19:04:50

Oh dear I'm terribly common. Not only do I say, 'pardon', but I taught my children to say, 'pardon', too. Worse still when I was teaching, the entire staff encouraged the children to say, 'pardon'. What a common bunch of professional educators we were and how we let the children down!

vegasmags Tue 14-Jul-15 18:59:44

I say 'You will need to repeat yourself' and if it is to someone who doesn't know that I am hearing impaired, I will add a few words of explanation. If it is family or friends, I simply ignore them. On the advice of my audiologist years ago, I never apologise for not being able to hear.

J52 Tue 14-Jul-15 18:47:13

Hi back! 'I didn't know you cared' by Peter Tinniswood.
Uncle Stavely always said Pardon.

Sorry for disrupting this thread!

x

J52 Tue 14-Jul-15 18:43:46

Years ago there was a comedy series with Liz Smith and Stephen Rea, as mother and son. They had an Uncle??? Who had his gas mask box around his neck. His sole role was to constantly say "Pardon".

It was set in Northern England and written by a well known author, can't remember!

Off to google!

X

trisher Tue 14-Jul-15 18:21:08

Say again reminds me of the woman on Miranda who was always on her phone and kept saying, "bear with, bear with"

trisher Tue 14-Jul-15 18:18:18

Amazing isn't it- G. B. Shaw's words still ring true- "It is impossible for an Englishman to open his mouth without making some other Englishman hate or despise him."

Gracesgran Tue 14-Jul-15 18:17:29

I think you are taking it too seriously Ana. I was certainly writing tongue in cheek and I imagine others were too.