Gransnet forums

TV, radio, film, Arts

New series of Shetland

(152 Posts)
grannydarkhair Mon 28-Oct-24 16:04:32

The new series of Shetland starts on November 6th at 21.00 on BBC1 and iPlayer. Ian Hart and Vincent Regan, both well kent faces are in it, as well as the returning Ashley Jensen (Ruth), Alison O’Donnell (Tosh), Steven Robertson (Sandy) and Lewis Howden (Billy).
I was not a fan of the previous series so am hoping for both an improved storyline and acting this time.

Allira Thu 07-Nov-24 10:14:39

Yes, I think he did.

He felt he'd taken the part of Pérez as far as it could go.

NanaTuesday Thu 07-Nov-24 11:07:58

grannydarkhair

The new series of Shetland starts on November 6th at 21.00 on BBC1 and iPlayer. Ian Hart and Vincent Regan, both well kent faces are in it, as well as the returning Ashley Jensen (Ruth), Alison O’Donnell (Tosh), Steven Robertson (Sandy) and Lewis Howden (Billy).
I was not a fan of the previous series so am hoping for both an improved storyline and acting this time.

I viewed last night but felt it lacked a lot in terms of watcablity value . Ashley Jensen is a good actor however this series is definitely not going to be on my to do list in future 🥲

Ilovedogs22 Thu 07-Nov-24 14:57:16

Boz

It's just about watchable on a winter's evening, but not the same with out Henshall; a first-class actor who elevated the series.

Couldn't have put better myself Boz.
Shetland is now unwatchable with those 2 drippy women leading the investigations! Bring back Perezl 😫

Aveline Thu 07-Nov-24 17:19:35

Well I just watched episode one and enjoyed it so much I went to the BBC
i- player to see the next one. Drat! Only the first one available. No binge for me. Och!
The two women are very convincing together I thought.

pascal30 Thu 07-Nov-24 17:20:01

It's a gentle series with gorgeous locations.. and although I like Tosh she and the other policewoman often don't appear to have had any serious training.. it really needs Douglas Henshall back..

Ilovedogs22 Thu 07-Nov-24 19:40:04

Hear,hear pascal30 Yes bring back Douglas in order to save the program
The two women together are just not cutting the mustard I'm afraid!
They both seem very needy, touchy & whiny. Shetland has lost its teeth & I just can't watch those drippy twit, simpering actresses anymore.
Ps, Pardon my drippy, twit, simpering rant! 🥴

charley68 Thu 07-Nov-24 20:05:10

I love the Shetland detective series, and look forward to, and savour each one. Yes, Jimmy Perez was so very watchable - but so miserable, and he (Henshall) wanted to go.

I love the two female leads, they complement each other wonderfully. Both women have had their personal challenges, and have come out the other side more rounded. It is wonderful that we have a major drama with two female leads, and it really surprises me that so many posters on here are so insulting and derogatory about the women and the characters they play. It is upsetting.

I saw the same in the comments about Anna Maxwell Martin over the last couple of days. I think she is amazing too. I have not watched the current ITV series, but she was wonderful in Ludwig, and Motherland is a masterclass by all the female characters in it. I have rewatched Ludwig , and I am really looking forward to S2.
I like watching dramas with characters that are believable, and that includes women/female characters who look like normal people that we meet in daily life.

Aveline Fri 08-Nov-24 08:27:07

Hear hear charley68. My thoughts exactly.

Ilovedogs22 Fri 08-Nov-24 11:18:47

I don't understand why a poster can make a considered criticism about an actor or a poor-quality product or even a spoilt child, ect, without criticism. Yet, God forbid you if you post a comment validly criticising a lead actress for her lack of impact & suitability in a beloved TV role because you suddenly become the Anti-Christ. Ridiculous. 🤔

pascal30 Fri 08-Nov-24 15:11:39

Has anyone seen the new series on Channel 5 called Ellis.. now there's a wonderfully charismatic actress.. Sharon D Clarke.. she has the most amazing sculpted face and presence..
and the storylines are great..

Allsorts Fri 08-Nov-24 15:37:14

I don't find the actress playing Tosh credible. Did watch start of new series but it didn't seem go hold my attention. Do think the two actresses could be mother and daughter they have same mouth. Much prefer the originals

Wyllow3 Fri 08-Nov-24 15:40:13

pascal30

Has anyone seen the new series on Channel 5 called Ellis.. now there's a wonderfully charismatic actress.. Sharon D Clarke.. she has the most amazing sculpted face and presence..
and the storylines are great..

I was just going to recommend "Ellis" too - two episodes in, well worth a catch up. You're right about her commanding and dignified presence.

Allira Fri 08-Nov-24 17:10:57

pascal30

Has anyone seen the new series on Channel 5 called Ellis.. now there's a wonderfully charismatic actress.. Sharon D Clarke.. she has the most amazing sculpted face and presence..
and the storylines are great..

Yes, we're enjoying it. She is very good and her sidekick is coming into his own too.

We like the fact that each episode is a complete story.

Allira Fri 08-Nov-24 17:12:33

pascal30

Has anyone seen the new series on Channel 5 called Ellis.. now there's a wonderfully charismatic actress.. Sharon D Clarke.. she has the most amazing sculpted face and presence..
and the storylines are great..

She'd make me quake in my boots if she was interviewing me. I'd probably confess to anything just to get away from her!

Allira Fri 08-Nov-24 17:21:28

charley68

I love the Shetland detective series, and look forward to, and savour each one. Yes, Jimmy Perez was so very watchable - but so miserable, and he (Henshall) wanted to go.

I love the two female leads, they complement each other wonderfully. Both women have had their personal challenges, and have come out the other side more rounded. It is wonderful that we have a major drama with two female leads, and it really surprises me that so many posters on here are so insulting and derogatory about the women and the characters they play. It is upsetting.

I saw the same in the comments about Anna Maxwell Martin over the last couple of days. I think she is amazing too. I have not watched the current ITV series, but she was wonderful in Ludwig, and Motherland is a masterclass by all the female characters in it. I have rewatched Ludwig , and I am really looking forward to S2.
I like watching dramas with characters that are believable, and that includes women/female characters who look like normal people that we meet in daily life.

it really surprises me that so many posters on here are so insulting and derogatory about the women and the characters they play. It is upsetting

Posters seem to be criticising the characters portrayed. Do either of the characters as portrayed in the latest script deserve to be Inspector? I doubt it.

Surely that is valid criticism and what many reviewers of productions do all the time?

An actor can only do so much with a script and storyline.

Aveline Fri 08-Nov-24 17:52:25

It's all a matter of opinion and there are no opinions more valid than others. Some of us like these characters and the actresses involved and others don't. We are all entitled to state our opinions. A poster saying they feel like the anti christ is just absurd

charley68 Fri 08-Nov-24 19:05:05

I agree, it is all a matter of opinion, and we are all entitled to our opinions.

I love Ellis too, a brilliant portrayal of a strong woman. I also liked Whitstable Pearl, S1 especially, S2 seemed to have lost the plot somehow.

Ilovedogs22 Sat 09-Nov-24 16:47:00

Allsorts

I don't find the actress playing Tosh credible. Did watch start of new series but it didn't seem go hold my attention. Do think the two actresses could be mother and daughter they have same mouth. Much prefer the originals

👌👍👏🌺 & one for luck 🦄

Allira Sat 09-Nov-24 16:52:41

I'd like to see more of Sandy and hear his lovely accent.

pascal30 Sat 09-Nov-24 17:26:47

Allira

I'd like to see more of Sandy and hear his lovely accent.

I agree.. it's so soft and mesmerising..

Ilovedogs22 Sat 09-Nov-24 19:23:12

Allira

I'd like to see more of Sandy and hear his lovely accent.

Yes Allira, me too. Sandy sure is an intriguing character & played beautifully by the actor.
He seems very buttoned-up & lacking in confidence. Yet he doesn't miss anything! He's very perceptive & a far more interesting, deeper character than either of the two slightly nimby irritating leads which seems at odds & rather unbalanced to me. 🤔

madalene Sat 09-Nov-24 19:32:53

I didn’t like the new woman much, but I’ll stick with it.

Allira Sat 09-Nov-24 20:12:00

Ilovedogs22

Allira

I'd like to see more of Sandy and hear his lovely accent.

Yes Allira, me too. Sandy sure is an intriguing character & played beautifully by the actor.
He seems very buttoned-up & lacking in confidence. Yet he doesn't miss anything! He's very perceptive & a far more interesting, deeper character than either of the two slightly nimby irritating leads which seems at odds & rather unbalanced to me. 🤔

💖 Sandy!!

Ilovedogs22 Sat 09-Nov-24 20:36:16

"Oooohhh! Sandy" isn't that a song from Grease the musical?
Get lost Olivia Newton Whatyerface! 🤭
SANDY!!!💞

Elrel Thu 14-Nov-24 23:43:20

Much prefer Ellis,