Gransnet forums

TV, radio, film, Arts

Child Genius 2016

(43 Posts)
Elrel Tue 12-Jul-16 20:20:33

Watching in horrified fascination! Not sure it should be allowed!!

Deedaa Thu 04-Aug-16 21:53:09

To be fair these aren't just bright children. Two at least were in the top 0.05% of the population and the rest were top 1 or 2% which is seriously clever.

gettingonabit Thu 04-Aug-16 09:18:15

I forgot about that bit....it was cringe worthy! Yes, Rhea was going to win no matter what. Even if she got the wrong answer.

Awful. Just awful.

petra Thu 04-Aug-16 08:51:05

I would like to have been a fly on the wall when the judges were questioned by the American woman. There was no way her daughter wasn't going to win.

LullyDully Thu 04-Aug-16 08:10:11

I think a pretty good case could be made to ban the programme or at least change the title.

mumofmadboys Thu 04-Aug-16 08:02:58

Some of the words they were asked to spell I hadn't even heard of! I liked Saffy the best.I agree that it was a horrific process and should be banned.

LullyDully Wed 03-Aug-16 21:18:45

Just as it should be lucky girl.

Luckygirl Wed 03-Aug-16 20:20:57

I have a GS who is known as The Prof in his class, because he is very bright indeed - but he goes to an ordinary village primary where he fits in just fine - the others in his class often ask him stuff because they know he will know the answer, but there is no sense of him being superior - it is just a trait of his along with all the traits of all the others in the class. They are all good at different things and he is a very popular member of the class. His intelligence is never commented on by any of us - we just foster his interests, answer his questions and expect the same of him as his brother in terms of good behaviour and treating others kindly. He has good social skills and enjoys everything that all the other little boys enjoy.

LullyDully Wed 03-Aug-16 20:15:25

A 10 year old said " I don't want to ordinary.I have to be the best." How sad to have it instilled into you that you MUST be the best all the time. She went to a high achieving school then crammed for 5 hours every evening.

I am sure many of us have reasonably bright grandchildren but want them to fit into society and to think about others whilst doing their best. What sort of adults will they become? There was a little peer support when someone was knocked out, but not much. Also not much fun and laughter. Very sad.

Luckygirl Wed 03-Aug-16 20:12:39

I find it hard to understand how the programme makers get away with what is basically encouraging child abuse.

rosesarered Wed 03-Aug-16 20:07:38

Mind you, he is a bit over dramatic and Meldrew like these days.grin

rosesarered Wed 03-Aug-16 20:06:16

Flicking channels, came across this last night, about half way through and watched in horrified fascination! The children, much as you would expect, having been coerced and hothoused by the parents....... But the parents especially the Mothers ,OMG.
DH said they should be taken out and shot.

Deedaa Wed 03-Aug-16 20:05:56

It was interesting that three of the finalists had entered themselves, while their parents hadn't been too keen on it.

Luckygirl Wed 03-Aug-16 15:12:41

I knew a teenage girl whose mother projected her failed musical career onto her. It was pitiful; and interesting that in a televised competition she was commended for her technical skill, but the judges recognised that she had no "voice" of her own in her interpretation of the music, so she did not win. Another part of the programme involved the young competitors getting together to go roller skating - this lass was completely nonplussed by it all - she had never done such a thing and had no social skills to bring to the situtiton. How very cruel it is. I once stood in the wings of a concert at which this lass was playing and her mother was pacing about angrily - when she came off stage mother berated her for closing her eyes occasionally during her performance. Ghastly - I had to bite my tongue.

I have not watched CG - the whole concept made me cringe.

gettingonabit Wed 03-Aug-16 13:33:50

I missed The Pog being eliminatedgrin.

I found the parents on last night's particularly obnoxious, somehow. Especially the girls' mothers. It was all about them and their "sacrifices", wasn't it. As if parents don't make sacrifices all the time for their kids....hmm.

Glad it's over.

starbird Wed 03-Aug-16 11:39:55

Agree with all the comments and have not been watching it but did watch final. Glad the Pog? was eliminated, that will take him down a peg or two, but poor kid will be teased to death over it, I hope he can cope with it.. The parents of the runner up seemed decent, I'd better not say what I think of the others. Couldn't be sure if the winner was hanging back at one point to help the other girl, who she kept looking at or if she genuinely couldn't answer. I didn't agree with the criteria for choosing the final two, it all came down to memory - I think it is possible to be a genius with a bad memory, especially with easily available internet to look up on.
The program should also be renamed, there are plenty of child geniuses probably more intelligent than those on the program, but more modest about it - and with enough common sense to be living relaxed, rounded, happy lives.

gettingonabit Wed 03-Aug-16 10:59:17

Anyone bear to watch the Final last night? Wow. Just wow.

Fantastically able children but..omg...the parents. Almost unbearable. Poor kids.

merlotgran Fri 15-Jul-16 19:54:36

I can't watch it. The horrible parents ought to be forced to suffer the anguish of a family trying to support a teenager with serious clinical depression.

They're beyond contempt.

M0nica Fri 15-Jul-16 19:50:05

In do not think it would work anywhere. The whole idea behind it is horrible and not being able to see the contestants/participants/performing seals makes no difference.

Alishka Fri 15-Jul-16 09:59:05

It might(?) work better on the radio, like Round Britain Quiz ( that still going?)
I watched the first, won't watch any more.sad

Stansgran Thu 14-Jul-16 09:00:03

Some people will do anything to get on tv. I saw an episode some time back and hated it. I like clever children but not like that.

Mumsy Thu 14-Jul-16 08:59:29

couldnt believe how some of these parents were allowed to bully their children like that!! the gloating parents!! omg!

annsixty Thu 14-Jul-16 08:54:09

Knowing someone who lives her life through her C and now GC I know just what they are like . The person I know has hardly any friends. I keep in touch because I do feel sorry for her , her H has died and her family are all she has. She moved 4 years ago and apart from one other widow the neighbours do not seem to have any contact with her. She cannot see why and I am too cowardly to tell her. I wonder if the parents now on TV will be the same.

glammanana Thu 14-Jul-16 08:33:30

I watched it for half an hour and switched off after seeing Christpher's father and listening to his boasting and self importance and the comment that his son didn't need to waste time eating food just amazed me,what an absolute idiot of a parent that man is.

harrigran Thu 14-Jul-16 07:32:40

Watched the programme and then deleted the series timer, it was excruciating. DD was eligible to join mensa but decided against it when she was a teenager, I would not like to see my child going through that on TV.

rubylady Thu 14-Jul-16 03:37:43

Well I tied my son to the chair as I hadn't seen him for a few days and put this programme on. We watched it together last time so I thought he would enjoy it again but alas, his computer was calling and he moaned all the way through to get back upstairs. Or it might have been the fact that 11 year olds are so much more intelligent than he is. grin

Do you think that these intelligent children are more likely to come from more financially stable families or do you think any child has the ability to be in Mensa?