Gransnet forums

TV, radio, film, Arts

Adaptions of books to TV drama

(3 Posts)
Rosiebee Fri 18-Sept-15 10:15:09

I'm reading a series of novels about the Rev Merrily Watkins - sort of supernatural detective/thriller. Opened Radio Times for next week to see that they are starting to adapt them for tv. Weds 'Midwinter of the Spirit' on ITV. Really looking forward to it but with some trepidation. How will it match up with the pictures I have in my head? I've read about six of the books now and have a clear idea of what each character looks like. It's like when the BBC does a photo shoot of the cast in The Archers. Never works.
Many, many years ago, when the world was black and white, they did an adaption of my favourite book, Cold Comfort Farm and got every character spot on, especially the brilliant Alistair Simm. The more recent adaption was a total travesty
It's great to see a book come alive on screen but do others have the same niggles about the 'wrong' actors taking on the vision you have in your head?
Think I woke up on the pernickety side of bed, this morning.??

Indinana Fri 18-Sept-15 10:27:31

Sounds worth a look. I haven't come across the books, so I would be watching the TV series with no preconceived ideas. But I do know what you mean about TV/film adaptations of books - they so rarely measure up to our imagined characters, settings etc, do they?

NanKate Fri 18-Sept-15 10:42:50

There are two editions of this thread, so the next person might like to use the other one. grin