Gransnet forums

TV, radio, film, Arts

Dr Who - 50th anniversary feature length one-off

(35 Posts)
JessM Sat 23-Nov-13 15:42:27

Are you going to watch it tonight? Its got David Tennant in grin
It is being transmitted around the world. Congratulations BBC Wales!

feetlebaum Sun 24-Nov-13 11:13:53

@Lona - John Hurt was playing a character who had never appeared before - so casting a known 'ex-Doctor' would have been something of a no-no...

Lona Sun 24-Nov-13 11:38:12

Thanks feetle I get it now.
I don't watch it very often blush

ginny Sun 24-Nov-13 14:21:06

I seem to be in the minority too. Never liked it as a child and not interested now.

broomsticks Sun 24-Nov-13 15:15:34

Ah, I was wondering where the John Hurt Doctor fitted into the line. Just before the Christopher Eccleston Doctor does make more sense than anywhere else.
I think David Tennant is a really good actor but I preferred Eccleston as Doctor Who.
It was great to see it back with him but I think the BBC was right to junk originally. It had got quite stale and very violent and sick. Brilliant when it came back though.

Deedaa Sun 24-Nov-13 21:25:11

I enjoyed it but found Elizabeth 1st rather annoying. Much more Queenie from Blackadder than the offspring of Anne Boleyn and Henry VIII.

HildaW Mon 25-Nov-13 11:19:05

Deedaa, yes the Queen Elizabeth was a huge miscast, am aware that Dr Who is hardly a deep historical drama but the series does expect us to become wrapped up in the suspense and drama which is hard to do when you cannot believe a character who plays quite an important part of the plot.

broomsticks Mon 25-Nov-13 15:37:02

Yes, I agree Elis. 1 bit didn't work too well. I suppose it didn't matter that the Doctor there was David Tennant as he would have time travelled there, but she was a bit 'Who's Queen?' certainly.

Pentillie Mon 25-Nov-13 20:35:29

Pretty disappointing.

Joan Fri 06-Dec-13 02:51:27

Much as I love Doctor Who, it has a lot to answer for. I was walking to my writers' group the other day, when i heard Christmas carols in the distance. And what popped into my mind first? A group of homicidal robotic Santas with trumpet guns, playing carols!!

I laughed out loud at myself - must have looked a right idiot.