Gransnet forums

TV, radio, film, Arts

In thinking Rowan Atkinson is a prat (is that word acceptable if not replace it ?)

(25 Posts)
FlicketyB Fri 24-Feb-12 00:56:14

He is reported as saying that the discrimination laws that enabled Miriam Reilly to take the BBC to an Employment Tribunal for ageism should not apply to the 'creative industries'.

He seems to believe that the creativity of (broadcast) media is such a sensitive plant that it will be crushed and destroyed if it is expected to be representative of Society as a whole. In which case, presumably, whole groups of society, starting with older women and no doubt stretching to the disabled, those with regional accents and any other personal attribute that might distress those delicate creative media types will be removed from our screens and radios.

Now I can understand that if you are filming Pride and Prejudice you want the actress playing Elizabeth Bennett to look as if she is 20 and that Darcy would be unconvincing if played by an actor in his 80s but much media output is news, documentaries, and other factual programmes and there, providing the person presenting or whatever is capable of doing the task well, I really cannot see why it is not reasonable to expect that over the full range of programmes they should not be representative of society as a whole.

Granny23 Fri 24-Feb-12 01:24:16

Hear! Hear!

bagitha Fri 24-Feb-12 06:12:32

Yep, he's a prat.

Nsube Fri 24-Feb-12 06:19:35

Notorious as the meanest man in the Business, so my actor friends tell me.

Greatnan Fri 24-Feb-12 06:42:42

I agree. 'Luvvies' seem to think they are exempt from all normal rules.

Carol Fri 24-Feb-12 06:42:48

He should have kept his mouth shut - 'better to remain silent and have people think you're a fool than to speak and remove all doubt.'

glassortwo Fri 24-Feb-12 08:14:30

Well said carol

Annobel Fri 24-Feb-12 08:48:56

A number of male newsreaders have white hair. John Craven is quite grizzled. When did you last see a silver-haired female newsreader or Country File presenter? I think Mr Atkinson would not be expressing these views if he was a woman.

nanachrissy Fri 24-Feb-12 08:57:26

Typical luvvie prat!!

Butternut Fri 24-Feb-12 08:58:12

I couldn't agree more, Carol.

Seventimesfive Fri 24-Feb-12 10:01:03

Yes, he is. I always thought so.

Joan Fri 24-Feb-12 11:31:39

Well, I liked him in Blackadder, but when you think about it, he is being as big a prat at his character Blackadder!! Or worse....

Still, there are plenty of actors who have disappointing private lives and opinions.

gracesmum Fri 24-Feb-12 11:48:26

So all the time he wasn't actually "acting" in Blackadder or Mr. Bean? Figures.......

absentgrana Fri 24-Feb-12 11:50:55

FlicketyB Actors have always said that only an actress in her eighties has the depth of experience to play Juliet and dancers have always said pretty much the same thing about dancing Giselle (but fifties rather than eighties).

absentgrana Fri 24-Feb-12 12:20:24

Oh yes, and Rowan Atkinson is buttocks.

bagitha Fri 24-Feb-12 13:38:11

Nice pert buttocks or more of the saggy bum kind?

bagitha Fri 24-Feb-12 13:43:01

Don't tell anyone, but I sometimes get his name mixed up with the ArchBish's (Canterbury). Just the names. But, actually, Atkinson could probably do a good ArchBish. Not sure Williams could do Mr Bean. Maybe they could do a Two Rowans Show.

GoldenGran Fri 24-Feb-12 13:59:39

I heard him say it, he's a ptat, suffering from LS (luvvie syndrome)

GoldenGran Fri 24-Feb-12 14:00:02

oops, I mean prat!

absentgrana Fri 24-Feb-12 14:26:38

bagitha Didn't Rowan Atkinson do a spoof sermon in Beyond the Fringe or some other subversive production? I'm almost sure he uttered that immortal line, "God said and I am inclined to agree with him…

He may be a prat but he's not wholly bad – just another one who believes his own legend and thinks he's more important than he is.

jeni Fri 24-Feb-12 14:38:17

Can't stand the man! Perhaps I have no sense of humour?

Swansong Fri 24-Feb-12 15:12:01

Agree with jeni I cant stand him either - prat

Anne58 Fri 24-Feb-12 19:12:31

Bagitha like your style!

With regard to Rowan Atkinson, I like some of his work, dislike some.

At the risk of sitting on the fence to the extent that I get splinters in my bottom, I can, to an admittedley very limited degree, see both points.

Of course we still have the Bumblebee (sic) presenting "Any Questions" , Paxman too with his programme that I cannot bear to watch, and in both age or gender (or perhaps more specifically the combination of the two?) shouldn't be an issue, however considering some of Alan Bennetts monologue plays (just as a random example) required a very specific actor/actress age?

But in conclusion, I do think that Rowan Atkinson made his point badly.

(prepares to don tin helmet and get into bunker)

feetlebaum Thu 22-Mar-12 14:51:12

"Didn't Rowan Atkinson do a spoof sermon in Beyond the Fringe or some other subversive production? I'm almost sure he uttered that immortal line, "God said and I am inclined to agree with him… "

-- he certainly did. But the same gag had surfaced in 'That Was The Week That Was' with Lance Percival doing his Montgomery impression 'And God said unto Moses... and I think he was right...'

Greatnan Thu 22-Mar-12 15:32:26

Mr. Bean has always made me feel uncomfortable.