Mascara for soft, coloured lashes?

Have you thought about dyeing them? Unusually I have one set of black eyelashes and eyebrow and the other set blonde. I dyeing the blonde set to match and of course it gives more definition to the lashes.
I've always got on with Rimmel mascara. I think they do one in a soft blue container, sorry forgot the name which is gentle for sensitive eyes. L'Oréal makeup is also good.
Good luck as mascara can be a minefield. X

I haven’t found anything better than the black Rimmel mascara in a blue container, it’s waterproof too.

I saw this product demonstrated on TV so gave it a try. It has a very fine brush which gives good, accurate, non-clumping, soft coverage close to the base of the lashes. Unfortunately it comes with an eyebrow balm, which I don't use. It is a tubing mascara which is non-smudge but comes off with plain water. I can swim with it remaining as long as I don't rub hard. The included balm makes it more expensive, but I think I will stick with it.
I did try buying fine disposable brushes to use with other mascaras, but they were too messy to use.
Good luck with your search, it can get expensive!
rubyhammer.com/products/mascara-brow-duo?variant=44014225228025

I really like Maybelline mascara...Sky High version. I've struggled in the past with sensitivity but have never had a problem with this brand.

I dye my lashes and brows so no longer need mascara

Game changer

I would advise you to use whatever mascara doesn't upset your eyes. I haven't yet found a mascara that doesn't clump if you keep using the same brush.

The answer, I've found, is in tools. Buy yourself an eyelash separator comb and a couple if spoolies so you can "comb" the lashes and use a clean brush each time so less likelihood of clumping. The comb was an eye opener (literally and figuratively) to me. The tools are cheap to buy and easy to use.

Thank you very much everybody. I didn't realise that Rimmel did a mascara for sensitive eyes, Redrobin51, so will definitely give that a try. And will also get an eyelash separator comb - hadn't even thought about that, PoliticsNerd. The mascara you mentioned looks lovely, shysal - quite expensive, though. And Maybelline Sky High mascara looks good, too. Lots to think about!

What comes around goes around! I didn't know Rimmel had a mascara for sensitive eyes either Genevieve, so thank you for asking the question .

Another thing I've thought of is using the folded edge of a tissue under the lower lashes allows you to get more coverage as you aren't worried about splodges and can go down instead of up so it's going on the bit that shows.

I seldom use as I have dry eyes and wear contact lenses occasionally but for special days use lancome always black. I'm fair skinned and have white hair xx

I find mascara irritates my eyes with the clumps falling into my eyeballs and scratching them. I now have a lash lift and tint done by a professional, and I love it, they look like they have mascara on and stay in shape nicely curled up, would be fab especially as you have fair lashes

I have very sensitive eyes and find ICONIC LONDON ENRICH & ELEVATE a fabulous mascara. Have used now for a few years and it never clumps, separates your lashes and leaves them soft. It also conditions your lashes. Quite a few of my friends use it now. Good luck.

I have blepharitis and the dye could cause a reaction

I'd go with PoliticsNerd's suggestion. I have suffered with what was diagnosed as dry eye for years. Carbomer gel not much good. Became so bad optician carried out procedure twice to unblock tear duct. No success, now referred to Opthalmology awaiting appointment. I have had blepharitis, treated with lotion and hot eye pad. I wear waterproof mascara and use a lash brush.

Genevieve489 get them tinted

I have sensitive eyes and can recommend Avon Lash Genius from Amazon - best I've used and reasonably priced.

PoliticsNerd, never heard of spoolies or eyelash separator comb so thanks for the tip. Mascara is pretty much the only make up I use so very helpful!

Just as an aside, and as it has been mentioned several times, can anyone recommend a good eyelsh dye?
What colour is best to use?

I've had ongoing problems with eye allergies for years and a few years ago after much research discovered a make called Bell which is available on Amazon for about £5 really easy to remove too.

I have dry eye and blepharitis, also awaiting cataract surgery. I use Rimmel brown/ black but have been advised by ophthalmologist never to use waterproof mascara.

Yes I agree. I bought a pack of disposable spooly's very cheap off Am.z.n. I wash them so will last ages

You right - is the best ! 😀👍

ELF from Superdrug has brilliant mascara, doesn't flake or give you panda eyes and is very hood value.

4allweknow - slightly off task but I found Carbomer gel irritated the skin underneath my eyes and brought me out in a rash there. The eye specialist at the Glaucoma Clinic said it's quite common and recommended Hylo-Forte Drops. I contacted my doctor (eye drops are on prescription), swopped to them and have no problems.