I personally do not like eyeliner, it can make your eyes look smaller, and can look harsh and ageing, instead use a soft powder blend it in, less is more, I’ve found you don’t have to use the expensive brand make up. It’s taken me decades to realise this, lol love NYX lipsticks, if you want to make your face look brighter wear pink lipstick, having worked on beauty counters for a few years before I had my children, I learnt lots of tricks, the only make up product I do splash out on is, benefit mascara, but the rest of my brands are mostly nyx or rimmel