Should I start messaging instead of phoning?

I live alone like many others, this week because I have not been well, haven't seen anyone, a text doesn't do it, listening to someone's voice makes such a difference. Keeping quiet why not send the odd text message as long as you still speak to your daughter each week. I wish Whats App had never been invented.

I think WhatsApp and the like are very destructive to relationships. Great for short practical messages, sending photos etc but for anything with any personal contact, make a cuppa tea, sit down, think about the person before you call and then call and chat, make an appointment if they are very busy. And probably don't have the video on! We are not designedto talk like that!
OP, tell your daughter! And tell her to look up research if she goes on about how it's 'the modern way'. Ask her what she does with the time she saves by messaging rather than talking to you.

Most of my conversations with my children.and family are messaging on WhatsApp. Rarely we actually talk to eachother.
One lives on Scotland and the other one Leeds.
I'm sure if anything important turned up they'd call. Otherwise I let them get on with it.
Although it was nice when my grand daughter actually face times.me to let me know she'll be a mum in November. That was nice. Better than a text!

I lost my son when he was 25 in 2009. I would give everything I own to hear his voice just one more time. Remember that when you say "oh its easier", oh its less time consuming" and oh, it a generation thing. Everyone, children and parents/grandparents should be able to spare 5 mins a week to speak to each other - to hear a loved one's voice beats any text or message. I don't care how busy you say you are!

Watching on iPlayer is nothing like as good as watching on a tv screen. Also, you’re missing the point, which is, why are paying all this money to watch sport that many of us don’t even want.
And don’t get me started on the constant repeats, and the repeats of the repeats.
If they took Sport and all the repeats away, what would we be left with?
I sometimes think we are seen to be idiots!

Crossstitchfan

Omaju

My daughter facetimes us on a Sunday evening, we see her and hear her, our SIL and our chillibeans.
If you need to hear your ACs voices, tell them. Explain that you know it's generational thing but you need it and would appreciate them taking the time for a 15 minute conversation once a week... if my daughter and SIL can facetime us and his parents once a week for up to an hour for each facetime call, then I'm sure most adult children can spare 15 minutes. I know they are very busy, our daughter is a Doctor of Philosophy and lectures at Oxford university and our SIL is quite high up in an auditing firm and often works evenings and weekends but they still find time for us and his parents.

And the relevance of your daughter being a ‘doctor of philosophy and lecturing at Oxford university’, and your SIL being ‘quite high up in an auditing firm’ is?? You could have just said your daughter is a lecturer and your SIL works evenings and weekends.
Oh hang on, it’s called boasting!

😂 Not much more I can add to that.

Exactly Leopard - which is what M0nica was saying.

Not at all the intimacy of both people being present. Just as a phone call womderful though it is does not compare with physically being with someone you love.

...and I was agreeing with.
Sometimes even the best technology is not enough.

Omaju

My daughter facetimes us on a Sunday evening, we see her and hear her, our SIL and our chillibeans.
If you need to hear your ACs voices, tell them. Explain that you know it's generational thing but you need it and would appreciate them taking the time for a 15 minute conversation once a week... if my daughter and SIL can facetime us and his parents once a week for up to an hour for each facetime call, then I'm sure most adult children can spare 15 minutes. I know they are very busy, our daughter is a Doctor of Philosophy and lectures at Oxford university and our SIL is quite high up in an auditing firm and often works evenings and weekends but they still find time for us and his parents.

And the relevance of your daughter being a ‘doctor of philosophy and lecturing at Oxford university’, and your SIL being ‘quite high up in an auditing firm’ is?? You could have just said your daughter is a lecturer and your SIL works evenings and weekends.
Oh hang on, it’s called boasting!

Most of my family are shift workers. I always send a WhatsApp message asking if they are free for a call before phoning if I want to speak to them. I never know when they will be in bed so I do this to avoid waking them. Quite often they are free and I get a message straight back, often leading to a phone call if one of us has a lot to say. Other times, I will get a message back asking if they can respond a bit later. This suits all of us just fine as no-one feels under pressure to speak right now if we are busy. One daughter has a 30 minute drive to work and will often ring me (hands free) on her way there or back a couple of times a week if it’s quiet en route. She might not have anything specific to tell me but we do enjoy our little chats. She and her husband are on holiday abroad at the moment and she has been sending lovely WhatsApps of the scenery (and plates of delicious food!)
My wonderful granddaughter had a baby a few months ago and she sends regular WhatsApps of things he does, which is lovely. I see them a couple of times a week as well so the WhatsApps are a very welcome treat for me. I feel very included in his little life which a great-grandmother might not normally be.
I love the set up we all have, particularly as we all live within 10 miles of each other and see one another regularly. I am very lucky.

My daughter facetimes us on a Sunday evening, we see her and hear her, our SIL and our chillibeans.
If you need to hear your ACs voices, tell them. Explain that you know it's generational thing but you need it and would appreciate them taking the time for a 15 minute conversation once a week... if my daughter and SIL can facetime us and his parents once a week for up to an hour for each facetime call, then I'm sure most adult children can spare 15 minutes. I know they are very busy, our daughter is a Doctor of Philosophy and lectures at Oxford university and our SIL is quite high up in an auditing firm and often works evenings and weekends but they still find time for us and his parents.

Glad to hear that!😊

I messaged her- she rang me back- we chatted for about 30 minutes and had a few laughs.

Equilibrium is restored.

NotSpaghetti

You are right M0nica - sometimes we have to just "set eyes on" our loved ones.

And have a hug.

Which isn't a phone call though 🤨🤣

Use WhatsApp to set up a group chat. I'm an introvert and hate speaking on the phone.

I've been with my husband for 4 years and genuinely spoken to him on the phone about 3 times 🤣, we message each other - in fact that's how we met 😁

My phone is permanently on silent.

Well I didn't get my usual phone call slot from DD. I shall send her a text and take it from there...
Thanks for all your responses.

I'd abandon the phone calls if I were you, just isn't used so much nowadays. I use several different platforms like WhatsApp, Messenger, Zoom. Teams, Instagram, email etc but seldom text messaging. You can set up group chats on apps and I often have a 4way video call. on WhatsApp with dds/dil. I actually prefer a video call as it's good to see faces when talking. I do everything from my phone - amazing piece of technology. Thank goodness I had it in hospital during Covid, could have gone stir crazy without it!

“There is nothing to beat the freeflow of a conversation that wanders here there and everywhere, like a casual cnversation over coffee. Actually DD and I usually settle down with a cup of tea each while we enjoy each others company.”

This is my wife mantra, when a friend phones or visits, I know it’s going to last a long time she will natter for ages, over 2 hours is the record.

You just cannot do that in a message.

I always message my two grown up children. Never phone unless urgent. That way they are free to respond (or not) when its convenient for them. Fair play to them though they nearly always msg back either immediately or within an hour.

Unless, of course, you have a regular time to ring each other each week - which is what happens in our case. Whoever rings who, the call is expected.

On those rare occasions that a phone call does come at an inconvenient time, you just apologise, agree a convenient time, and ring back.

There is nothing to beat the freeflow of a conversation that wanders here there and everywhere, like a casual cnversation over coffee. Actually DD and I usually settle down with a cup of tea each while we enjoy each others company.

You're absolutely right StoneofDestiny, it's akin to butting into another conversation, literally, albeit unintentionally. Obviously, there are times when it really is imperative, but I'm always hesitant when it comes to phoning in a personal context in case I'm interrupting anything.

Problem is, phone calls disrupt and cut across what you are doing - whether you are driving, watching a film, out with friends, snoozing.......they need to be answered or shut off. Texts don't have to be answered .......you can read them when you are able and reply when you are able. It lets people organise their own days as they wish.

You clearly value your calls, but maybe your daughter prefers texting more now. Trying a mix of texts for updates and calls for deeper chats might help. Staying connected in whatever way works best for both of you is what counts

Well, me and DD are outliers! I'm almost 80, she's 53 and lives 100s of miles away. We speak on WhatsApp most days while preparing our respective evening meals. She cooks for DSiL while I get mine. Student-age GSs are also happy to speak via WhatsApp.

I’m all for messenger for the reasons Maybe70 said. Not intrusive can be spontaneous; keeps a thread record. So useful. I find phone calls somewhat presumptuous and intrusive! I know! Many men I know prefer phoning because they can’t be bothered with text. Having to put things down in words also makes you think and if you are not in the mood then no pressure. (How are you locked out of Facebook Maybe70! ?I hope you fix it. )
For some reason I don’t ever write much on sms more telegrammy. Short, practical. I don’t use WhatsApp ( prejudiced!) I love Messenger
My son is terribly difficult to get by phone but always responds to messages quickly. Often with just pictures.
We all have baggage here. My mum used to ring me at least once a week and always spent about an hour or more. Till I began to hate it. When she finally finished her monologue and knew I was needing to get on she’d ask me how I was. By that time I had had enough and just said. I’m fine ( just let me go). It was a bind but also at times a blessing. I used to know so much about sons of cousin’s wives..😄 and miss her deeply.

Sounds like things are changing for you on the communication front…
How about a combination of texting, WhatsApp and email? With email you can feel like you’re imparting whatever family news there is, and your daughter can read the news at a time of her choosing.
I use a combination of all 3, and often leave emails in my Drafts folder if I’m not sure I’ve got the tone right! ‘Sleeping on it’ and then sending.
WhatsApp is great for short chats; texting too.
Time for change, maybe? Good luck