Gransnet forums

News & politics

Trans women and single-sex spaces

(955 Posts)
RosieandherMaw Mon 14-Apr-25 07:58:00

Is this common sense at last?
From ‘The Times’ this morning
Organisations will be told that they can no longer call a space single-sex if they admit transgender people who do not have a gender recognition certificate.
Updated guidance from the equality watchdog will say that services described as being single-sex will not be able to make the claim if they also allow transgender women to use them on the basis of self-identification
Last week the Equality and Human Rights Commission (EHRC) sent ministers its updated code of practice, which guides organisations on how to apply the Equality Act. It is expected to be presented to parliament before the summer. The Times understands the recommendations include an overhaul of how single-sex spaces are defined.
A source said of the guidelines: “The upshot [of the guidance] means it's not lawful to have a self-ID service. The fact is that if you let a man in, it's no longer a single-sex service, and that includes trans people without GRCs [gender recognition certificates] .”
The change would prevent those who rely on self-ID from being able to access women-only care homes or domestic abuse refuges without an exceptional reason

My question is just why has this taken complicated legislation - and so long?

Doodledog Tue 31-Mar-26 21:08:51

I’d say it was a sex issue, not a gender one. A man wanted to show he could dominate a woman- even though she was best in her class. The boxer may have been in it for the money (goodness knows there would be no glory in it) but that is exactly what the trans ‘movement’ wants. Women to get back in line.

NanKate Tue 07-Apr-26 22:01:55

Sadly true Doodledog.

NittWitt Thu 09-Apr-26 13:12:16

That's a good point about the categories Betony. Are they really so wide that those boxers were considered evenly matched?

Apparently the Algerian was born female, but has XY chromosomes, internal testes, and no uterus.
Imane Khelif may have appeared to be female at birth but clearly was not. He's a male with a DSD - difference or diversity of sexual development.

NittWitt Thu 09-Apr-26 13:17:03

I think there is a difference between intact males and surgically 'transitioned' ones. Yes, both are male, but the one who has undergone surgery is (a) obviously committed to the cause, and (b) much less likely to be a risk to women.

We can't assume that.
It's been proven that castration isn't a cure for sexual offending because the motivation is aggression towards (usually) females.

Obviously most transwomen aren't sexual offenders but neither are most men.
Transwomen can't be considered safer than other men.