Gransnet forums

News & politics

Diane Abbott quits the shadow cabinet.

(334 Posts)
Urmstongran Sun 23-Feb-20 23:10:50

She’s stepping down, no matter who is selected as the next leader of the Labour Party.

I think it’s a vote catcher quite honestly.

tickingbird Wed 26-Feb-20 14:19:33

The secular religion of 'Social Justice' and its radical adherents can be just as fanatical, unforgiving and aggressive as religious fundamentalists.

So true. Social justice warriors who are determined to find racism where none exists are creating so much division and it’s all coming from middle class, white liberals. This from a black man. There are some fanatics on here and it’s quite fascinating to read how entrenched they are in their assertion that we’re all racists.

GagaJo Wed 26-Feb-20 14:22:14

Quite a lot of people on here AREN'T racists actually. To be honest, on this WHOLE site (rather than just on the contentious threads) I would say there are less racists than those that ARE.

However, there are an entrenched minority that are not just ignorant (because that implies they don't know better) but that are willfully so.

tickingbird Wed 26-Feb-20 14:22:29

* Disgraceful behaviour on this thread by people who are racist.*

Can you direct me to some of this disgraceful, racist behaviour on this thread please Gagajo?

Chewbacca Wed 26-Feb-20 16:08:55

Who are you referring to specifically Gaga?

ananimous Wed 26-Feb-20 17:26:25

We should agree to disagree, and try to get along, or just ignore each other...

POGS Wed 26-Feb-20 19:53:56

trisher

'POGS It isn't racist to consider why someone else behaves as they do'
----

Precisely! If I consider or anybody else considers why Dianne Abbott or any other politician behaves it is not racist!

It would be if the colour of the skin of said politician was of concern or interest for making considered opinions of said MP then racism may be a possibility.

If you are making that comment towards me personally, intimating once AGAIN I am racist, then that is not evident in my posts and consider away because it is in your head that I am racist.

Grandad1943 Wed 26-Feb-20 19:56:41

And so it goes on and on and on. ?

POGS Wed 26-Feb-20 20:06:15

trisher

' But you really should learn to draw a distinction between examining motives and suggesting reasons and holding those views yourself. In fact the less you examine and the more you state constantly that there isn't racism and you aren't racist the more likely you are to be unconsciously racist.'
----

I do not have to learn anything because my views are NOT motivated by the colour of an MP' s skin, you however do and attribute the same to others.

You can bugger off to the moon with your comment ' and the more you state constantly that there isn't racism and you aren't racist the more likely you are to be unconsciously racist.'

As I said previously on various threads certain posters are throwing around accusations of posters being equivalent to Nazis or racist because they intentionally go out of their way to twist, misrepresent posts and think they can do so because it must be the case ' because they say so.'

Oopsminty Wed 26-Feb-20 20:06:29

Oooh, Grandad. I'm not doubting your post

But compared to my upbringing, yours was very different

I was at a private school. We had children from all backgrounds. Different faiths, nationalities, colour etc etc

My parents never mentioned anything remotely racist and happily entertained whoever I brought home with me

No matter what colour they were

ananimous Wed 26-Feb-20 20:07:53

Urmstongran I think it’s a vote catcher quite honestly.

? Yes.

POGS Wed 26-Feb-20 20:07:57

Greymar Wed 26-Feb-20 12:39:50

' I think if you are White British and " older" you will be unconsciously racist.'
-

Speak for yourself!

In fact that is a racist comment which is pure irony.

ananimous Wed 26-Feb-20 20:10:15

[Hmmm]

Gransnet BunsNet ? ?

POGS Wed 26-Feb-20 20:18:22

GagaJo Wed 26-Feb-20 12:48:39

'And lets face it, there is a LOT of racism on this forum and there are almost certainly racist Private Messages shooting back and forth between some members. Pity GNHQ don't monitor those too.'
-

WHAT!

How the hell would you know. Are you making that accusation out of personal experience, is that what you are doing?

If you like Gagajo you have my permission to contact GNHQ to ask when and how many Private Messages I receive. You will find nothing, nada, zilch in my Private Messages to confirm your wild allegations.

Anniebach Wed 26-Feb-20 20:22:23

I don’t know if there are racist private messages shooting back
and forth between some members, only those who send and receive racist private messages would know.

POGS Wed 26-Feb-20 20:23:32

Gagajo

'However, there are an entrenched minority that are not just ignorant (because that implies they don't know better) but that are willfully so'
----

Amen to that. However who ' the minority' are is in the eye of the beholder.

ananimous Wed 26-Feb-20 20:31:50

Diane Abbott was unable to attend HOC today because she was stuck staring at her orange juice box - It said "Concentrate". ??

Grandad1943 Wed 26-Feb-20 20:32:34

Oopsminty, I have for several days now resisted posting in this thread in total disgust at the way the substance of the debate has turned on continual accusations of racism between forum members.

Should it be possible to debate on this forum British public attitudes in the post-second world war decades then I would happily contribute.

I do hold strong views in regard to people judging previous historical actions by today's standards, which I believe would make for an excellent thread.

However, I am very busy workwise at the moment and therefore feel I could not open such a thread and give it the attention I feel that opening posters should, but as stated I would contribute as much as my time allows to such a thread.

However, and with every respect, I will not be contributing further to this thread which I feel has descended to the lowest level of debate that I have ever witnessed since being a member of this forum.

Greymar Wed 26-Feb-20 20:32:48

POGS, don't be so silly. If you are of a certain vintage and white British you will have been affected be negative images and words for many many years. It will have gone in at some level.

Greymar Wed 26-Feb-20 20:33:32

No it is not racist one bit.

tickingbird Wed 26-Feb-20 20:47:57

No it is not racist one bit What isn’t? Or is? I’m lost. It’s all gone a bit loopy lou!!

tickingbird Wed 26-Feb-20 20:49:37

Add comment | Report | Private message ananimous Wed 26-Feb-20 20:31:50
Diane Abbott was unable to attend HOC today because she was stuck staring at her orange juice box - It said "Concentrate".

You’ll get told off!

Chewbacca Wed 26-Feb-20 20:50:00

Mind you don't put your back out when getting down off that high horse Grandad1943.

Greymar Wed 26-Feb-20 20:54:28

This certainly isn't bringing out the best in people. Ah well, perhaps that was the intention all along.

ananimous Wed 26-Feb-20 20:55:35

tickingbird

Is that fake news?

ananimous Wed 26-Feb-20 20:56:50

Greymar

Only YOU can bring out the best in yourself.