Gransnet forums

Education

Is it ever possible to make a curriculum that is neutral and unbiased?

(38 Posts)
EmilyHarburn Tue 29-Sept-26 15:01:21

Sungi give the problem to AI asking them to structure your response for and Oxford style debate and it will be done in seconds. You can then flesh the response out and make it more personal.

Skye17 Tue 29-Sept-26 15:00:59

In my experience teachers definitely lean left.

I think there can be a more or less biased curriculum, but probably not a completely neutral one.

Alison333 Tue 29-Sept-26 14:47:55

sungi

So i got an oxford style debate tomorrow on this topic and i have to speak as opposition against—

“Thbt there is no such thing as a neutral curriculum.”

That is, i suppose— there is, and must be such a thing called a neutral curriculum.
Lets exchange views. Do you think it is possible to have such a curriculum? Why?

No, all knowledge in any curriculum is filtered by the opinions and agendas of the people who design them. Therefore a 'neutral' curriculum is impossible.

Ziplok Tue 29-Sept-26 14:37:03

David49

Teachers in general are a pretty left leaning bunch and they do take the opportunity of steering children towards their own agendas.
Years ago we had an English teacher that tried to instill socialist ideas into my class as 14 yr olds, he failed. It wasn't that we were especially rebellious, we were being told what to think.

A rather sweeping assumption about teachers there, David49.

Nanny27 Tue 29-Sept-26 14:32:26

I like to think that the curriculum I delivered for all those years was as neutral as it could be. However, I tend to agree that the political leaning of most teachers is towards the left.

M0nica Tue 29-Sept-26 08:23:20

No it is not. Anymore than anyone can claim to be non-judgemental.

Grantanow Tue 29-Sept-26 08:18:16

No, it's not but I don't think teachers are generally 'Lefties'.

MartavTaurus Tue 29-Sept-26 07:57:03

MawsRosie

David49

Teachers in general are a pretty left leaning bunch and they do take the opportunity of steering children towards their own agendas.
Years ago we had an English teacher that tried to instill socialist ideas into my class as 14 yr olds, he failed. It wasn't that we were especially rebellious, we were being told what to think.

What a sweeping generalisation -with which I do not agree.
But how odd, my English teacher would have written “instil” with one “L” as per UK English.
Was yours perhaps American?

My English teacher would have written ^ a teacher who, not that^. Seeing as we're criticising teachers and their worth.

Marydoll Tue 29-Sept-26 07:50:31

Teachers in general are a pretty left leaning bunch and they do take the opportunity of steering children towards their own agendas.

Wow! Certainly not the colleagues, with whom I have worked,

Sungi, I suspect English is not your first language, going by your spelling and grammar. Either that, or you are a teenager, who is trying to get others to do your homework!

MawsRosie Tue 29-Sept-26 07:39:23

David49

Teachers in general are a pretty left leaning bunch and they do take the opportunity of steering children towards their own agendas.
Years ago we had an English teacher that tried to instill socialist ideas into my class as 14 yr olds, he failed. It wasn't that we were especially rebellious, we were being told what to think.

What a sweeping generalisation -with which I do not agree.
But how odd, my English teacher would have written “instil” with one “L” as per UK English.
Was yours perhaps American?

David49 Tue 29-Sept-26 07:29:44

Teachers in general are a pretty left leaning bunch and they do take the opportunity of steering children towards their own agendas.
Years ago we had an English teacher that tried to instill socialist ideas into my class as 14 yr olds, he failed. It wasn't that we were especially rebellious, we were being told what to think.

MawsRosie Mon 28-Sept-26 21:59:20

You've left it a bit late haven't you?
I was going to suggest you outline your argument and invite comments- not ask your or anybody else's grans to do your homework for you!

sungi Mon 28-Sept-26 21:06:57

So i got an oxford style debate tomorrow on this topic and i have to speak as opposition against—

“Thbt there is no such thing as a neutral curriculum.”

That is, i suppose— there is, and must be such a thing called a neutral curriculum.
Lets exchange views. Do you think it is possible to have such a curriculum? Why?