Gransnet forums

Education

Early reading v continental custom - teachers’ thoughts sought

(33 Posts)
Dylis Tue 18-Aug-26 13:05:04

Ex special needs teaching assistant here.
Many children find reading extremely difficult and eventually switch off and avoid it at all costs. It was heartbreaking at "reading time" to hear the collective groan of those who struggled.
I worked with some dreadful teachers who insisted they were heard daily. I would find something they had an interest in and we would "read" together.
The UK is obsessed with grades and hitting levels of learning rather than encouraging a love of learning.
I eventually worked along side a teacher who shared my views. She bought dozens of books from charity shops and children were encouraged to enjoy rather than forced to learn.

silverlining48 Tue 18-Aug-26 13:01:51

It’s normal in most of Europe for children to start school at 7. I am not a teacher but have many teacher as friends and believe we start them much too early here.

MaizieD Tue 18-Aug-26 12:58:38

Polish, like many other languages, is far easier to learn to read than is English. In Polish the sounds which make up the spoken word usually have only one way to represent them by letters.

Unlike English which often, very often, has more than one way to spell a sound, e,g the /oo/ sound as in in 'boot' can be spelled 'ui' - suit, 'ou' - you, 'ue' - blue, 'ew' ' blew .... or, one letter or combination of letters can spell more than one sound, e.g 'oo' spells /oo/ in boot, but a different sound in 'book' (though this can be dependent on regional accent, before anyone says that they pronounce it the same way in boot and book. grin.

This makes English far more time consuming to learn to read and spell. So we start teaching it earlier because we have far more to cover to achieve skilled readers.

Do tell your son not to worry, OP. His child will learn fast once teaching reading begins.

Madgran77 Tue 18-Aug-26 12:37:21

Some children will thrive on early reading; others just arent ready and it becomes a burden/sfuggle (pointlesxly) At 7 if no other problems eg dyslexia exist a child will pick it up quickly and progress faater through the reading stages - they will love reading or they wont, and the age they dtatted will make no real difference. The key thing is good teaching of reading; a range of methodology so that children can use different strategies; interesting books to catch the imagination.

To be honest there is plenty that parents can do regardless of what a school does. Read to them; lots of early fun books and trace the words as reading; flashcards games matching to pictures; phonics games and so on. The key is making it fun.

62Granny Tue 18-Aug-26 12:37:21

I am not a teacher but the statistics say it all really, the fact they learn how to speak properly is definitely a plus and will stand them in good stead as they learn to read. I am sure the curriculum here is more about learning through play for little ones these days.

Cabbie21 Tue 18-Aug-26 12:30:39

Not an ex- primary teacher, but I and my children and grandchildren loved reading from an early age ( 4/5) and books were a really important part of our childhood. So I do feel they are missing out by waiting until 7 ( provided they are not being forced unwillingly at 4)

ReturningFromExile Tue 18-Aug-26 12:24:28

I learned to read at 4, so did my elder daughter. I think that children do benefit from reading early, if it can be done without forcing them. Reading is fun, and opens up a world which children can choose for themselves, within reason.

sarahcyn Tue 18-Aug-26 12:18:32

I am posting this here as I have noticed a good number of experienced ex-teachers are on Gransnet and I would value their opinions.
My elder son lives in Poland with his Polish wife. They have 3 darling children. The oldest is 7 and starts formal school in September. Only then will he begin learning to read.
Until now it seems to me that his Polish preschool - he has been going since he was four - has focussed very much on social skills, getting children able to focus and sit quietly, teaching them to recite by heart, science experiments, lots of trips out, lots of music and dancing…oh and correct pronunciation of Polish - there is less tolerance of accents in Poland!
My son finds this all terribly worrying and feels his children are missing out. He was learning to read at a nursery school at 4, and was an avid reader, so naturally thinks that is the only way things should be done. Also the children have friends here in London whose early reading skills are very obvious.
Over the years I have come to feel that the Continental practice of delaying formal teaching of reading is probably very good for more children than our English obsession with early reading. When I think of my children at their private nursery schools in London 30 years ago having to sit tracing over letters endlessly - because that’s what we were told they needed to do- and compare it with the videos we get of my grandson and his class dancing the Polka with tremendous discipline and grace, I think I really got it wrong.
And statistics seem to show that Poland has a slightly higher literacy rate than the UK.
What do the Gransnet teachers think?
What is the evidence for either approach?