hollysteers
M0nica
I have never watched Downton, come to that I have not liked the last few dramatisations of jane Austen's novels, but I can assure you that class has absolutely nothing to do with my enjoyment of her brilliantly written, witty novels, which when they were written were contemporary novels.
This is the problem with most historic dramas. they are modern interpretations, generally, by uninformed people, of life in a period before today.
I’m not denying the talent of Austen, but there are many more novelists whose works justify dramatisations, such as the rest of Elizabeth Gaskell’s books, which depict life of the poor as well as the gentry.
But oh no, we have to have another Austen. Do these programmers have no imagination?🙄
The OP mentioned Austen, so that is what Icommented on. There have been some brilliant dramatisation of Mrs Gaskell's books but not recently. I managed to get a DVD of a version made in the 1970s, with Patrick Stewart as Mr Thornton and also 'Wives and Daughters made, I think , in the 1980s.
A more recent version of North and South was a travesty, with Mr Thornton as a tall good looking young man,
The problem these days is that tv cannot take a book on its merits they have to be sexed up and made to accord to modern norms of behaviour. I seem to remember a recentish version of Middlemarch was not bad, but I now avoid any modern dramatisation of a book more than about 20 years old.