Gransnet forums

Chat

Seven years of therapy?

(55 Posts)
MawB Sat 08-Feb-20 13:26:22

Some problems are not solvable but therapy/counselling offer the opportunity to talk things out with a disinterested person - not family, not friends, not neighbours and not with someone who comes up with a “solution”.
As a nation we have for a long time believed in the stiff upper lip, “keep buggering on” , not wearing our heart on our sleeve, there are any number of cliches.
In Catholic countries, confession and absolution has been known to provide an opportunity to offload and for many people this is helpful.
The appalling statistics of suicide among young men who are not able to open up to anybody speak for themselves.
Counselling may not work for everybody, it certainly won’t make a problem like bereavement go away, but if it helps to cope with it, that has to be good.

Nezumi65 Sat 08-Feb-20 13:05:46

There are so many different types. For some issues there may need to be years or of undoing layers of problems. For others there may just need to be support in helpful to park a thought.

Trauma often needs a different approach than other concerns.

MissAdventure Sat 08-Feb-20 12:58:28

I think there is some research that suggests that just talking about a problem for years isn't all that helpful in some cases.

That's why things like CBT and EMDR are gaining popularity.

They deal with issues in a different way.

Sara65 Sat 08-Feb-20 12:52:11

Oh goodness, what a question, and how can you really know if you’ve never had it?

I’m certain it has its place, and without doubt it does a lot of good for lots of people.

For me personally? I don’t think I’d be very good at talking about myself, certainly not week in, week out.

But as they say, I suppose it’s a case of whatever gets you through the night.

Artdecogran Sat 08-Feb-20 12:46:41

This is not a post about you know who but a discussion about having therapy. Seven years to solve a problem seems a very very long time to me. Does not talking about a problem for so long keep reinforcing the problem in your mind. A bit like picking a scab endlessly and not letting it heal over. The prison service used to give 6 sessions with a therapist for staff to over come work stress/problems. I wonder if that was enough now to help people. Does therapy need to be lifelong, the Americans seem to have continual therapy. Has anyone had experience of therapy and if so, for how long and did it help. No need for personal details. My husband died 14 months ago after fighting stage 4 colon cancer for 7 years; during his illness I called the Macmillan councillors a few times and I found it immensely helpful, but I haven’t spoken to anyone since his death. If therapy was free would you use it and how long would you use it for? Or is it American ‘let it all out’ versus British ‘stiff upper lip’?