Gransnet forums

Chat

My lovely grand-daughter

(57 Posts)
annep Sat 26-Jan-19 06:08:29

What Dolcelatte says is true. You don't want her to feel guilty because then she will stop telling you what she is doing. I help my single parent daughter but I would never criticise her spending.

Dolcelatte Sat 26-Jan-19 05:27:24

Going against the flow, but I don't think £400 is a lot to be honest, when you factor in books for her course, which are often very expensive, travel costs, personal toiletries etc and socialising. I imagine that she is spending a lot of time out and about and meeting new friends, which is what students generally do if they can afford it.

I have two daughters at university and pay them each a monthly allowance of £600, but they have to buy their own food out of that as they are not in 'lodgings'. They both manage fine but they do not live in any way extravagantly, hardly drink etc.

I would be inclined to have a face to face conversation, ask her how she is settling in, what she is doing etc, and she is likely to tell you of any problems, if you have a close relationship, which it sounds as though you do. If you suggest that she is spending too much, she is likely to clam up and feel uncomfortable and potentially guilty when she is spending money on going out or doing normal things that students do. You are giving her a wonderful gift and you say that you can afford it, so let her just enjoy it. If it's her first time away from home it may take her a little while to learn to budget, but she will get there in the end!

annep Sat 26-Jan-19 05:24:09

When my daughter went to uni we worked out what she would beed for toiletries etc and based what we gave her on that. She was in halls too. (paid for by government at that time). I see no problem discussing how she is managing. It seems a lot of money but you won't know until you ask.

BlueBelle Sat 26-Jan-19 04:48:58

£400 a month spending is a lot of money ! More than I have ?
when you sat down and worked out with her parents before she went what brought you up to £100 a week as she’s paying no rent or utilities did she have an allowance of £100 a week when she was living at home as her situation really is no different she is not paying board and lodgings and obviously doesn’t travel to uni as she’s in halls
She will probably be spending most of it on socialising
I suppose I was lucky I had no money to spare after bringing my children up unaided so my children all worked their own way through Uni and happily got their degrees They left home with no allowances. They never asked for any money and were totally self sufficient, obviously times have changed

BradfordLass72 Sat 26-Jan-19 03:29:13

If this were my grand-daughter, who is 25 and currently working overseas, I certainly would be able to ask her.

I'd say how worried I was because there are some odd people at uni and was one of them bullying her for money?

It depends how she sees you nananina and I'm assuming she has a high regards for you, so if you think you can speak to her, do so.

I'd prefer to do it in person rather than by phone but then recently my beloved girl has been confiding in me via FB messages smile as she's half a world away.

Some would say it's up to her parents to question her spending but I know my granddaughter tells me things she wouldn't dream of confiding to her parents.
I do hope it's something and nothing: a more expensive call for equipment or replacement of stolen items (so much is pinched at uni). Please let us know how it goes. thanks

nananina Sat 26-Jan-19 01:17:27

I meant her parents were giving her £200 from both of them not each!

nananina Sat 26-Jan-19 01:15:24

She IS the love of my life, at uni now and enjoying it very much. Of course there are no grants these days, it is all loans so we are helping her out. I'm giving £200 a month and her parents give the same so I thought she'd be fine. She never asks for money but occasionally asks if she can have her allowance a bit early which is what happened this month. I sent the money as usual, but I am beginning to wonder what she is spending her money on as she has no bills or rent to pay as she's in halls and that's another loan.

I'm worried about asking her as I don't want to upset her and I can afford the £200 per month easily and I do say to let me know if she's running short. When we were working out what we'd give her,me and her parents, they were saying she didn't need £400 a month but we'd stick with that and see how she went (this is her first term).

I haven't said anything to her parents (my son is her dad) and I get on well with DIL but I can't trust them not to say anything. My plan is to talk to her on phone as I don't see her in person so often now.

What do you think?