Gransnet forums

Chat

plastic £5 notes

(97 Posts)
jordana Wed 30-Nov-16 15:20:04

The news reports that vegans are offended by the new £5 plastic notes because there is tallow in them - seemingly a kind of fat from animals. This seems a bit absurd to me but I am not a vegan or know anyone who is.

Jalima Wed 30-Nov-16 23:17:44

I think most soaps are made with palm or other oils, not tallow.

durhamjen Wed 30-Nov-16 23:19:25

New Scottish ones do not have tallow in them, so it is possible to make them without.
I'd much rather they had thought about vegetarians and vegans, as well as all the religious groups that do not like it and are signing the petition. Much rather not need a petition about it.
However, minorities don't count, do they? The majority don't care, so that's okay, they can be as sarcastic as they like.

Jalima Wed 30-Nov-16 23:20:42

wtkr.com/2016/11/30/these-countries-have-animal-fat-in-their-money/

So what happens when people who object to the use of a minute amount of tallow in the notes want to go overseas - other countries use the same source of polymer to make their notes.
Will they just not go?

Jalima Wed 30-Nov-16 23:22:45

What about packaging?
Or do vegans buy only unpackaged food?

Genuine question.

Elegran Wed 30-Nov-16 23:25:02

The Bank of England didn't know about the minute trace of tallow until very recently, so I don't think you can blame them too much for its presence, or for not thinking earlier about vegetarians and vegans. Let's face it, you don't automatically think of a connection between treasury notes and vegans.

Jalima Wed 30-Nov-16 23:29:29

Why not just refuse notes, use a bank card or credit card and coins until the notes are taken out of circulation and replaced - if they ever are.

Or is that too simple? Many people use a card for everything these days and don't carry cash.

durhamjen Wed 30-Nov-16 23:40:40

Never thought about packaging, Jalima. What packaging did you have in mind?
I try and avoid excess packaging, but I can't think of any packaging that could have animal ingredients in it.
It took a long time before we could have decent non-animal shoes. Clothing, I never buy silk or wool.
My youngest granddaughter has just got her first pair of Doc Martens. She's nine, and she loves them because they make her feel grown up like her cousins.

harrigran Wed 30-Nov-16 23:45:30

Tallow is the least of your worries when it comes to bank notes.

durhamjen Wed 30-Nov-16 23:50:36

Why?
What else is embedded in the material?

Elegran Wed 30-Nov-16 23:59:55

I have a feeling that polymers for other uses may include traces of the same stuff.

thatbags Thu 01-Dec-16 02:35:55

There are serious ethical problems associated with palm oil as well as with tallow.

grumppa, grin

Elegran Thu 01-Dec-16 13:56:41

Scottish polymer bank notes are vegan-friendly. Just thought you'd like to know.
Bank of Scotland, RBS, Clydesdale

Granarchist Thu 01-Dec-16 14:06:14

is not true that most notes have traces of cocaine and other drugs on them?

One of the reasons for the start of the Indian Mutiny in 1857 was the rumour put about that pig tallow was used in greasing the cartridges of the Enfield rifle (which upset the Moslems) and beef tallow (which upset the Hindus) = thus resulting in millions of deaths over the following 10 years.

By comparison I think we can live with minute traces on a £5 note.

Ceesnan Thu 01-Dec-16 14:13:11

Surely it is possible to refuse to have the £5 note and ask for coins instead if you feel that strongly? Or will that lead to a mass wail of "Why should we have to refuse it?"

nightowl Thu 01-Dec-16 14:52:19

It's just another unnecessary use of animal products. I would find it extremely inconvenient to keep refusing £5 notes, and I'm sure shop workers and others would not be too happy about it. I don't understand why people who don't care about it feel they need to object because people who mind have asked for an alternative to be found.

durhamjen Thu 01-Dec-16 16:05:13

I await complaints that the new pound coin when it comes out in March 2017 makes holes in people's pockets.
Of course, I will just rubbish the complaint.

DaphneBroon Thu 01-Dec-16 16:05:18

Made from recycled ethically farmed haggis I believe Elegran.

tiggypiro Thu 01-Dec-16 16:10:44

Can I ask durhamjen why you do not buy wool? Shearing sheep is very good husbandry and prevents some nasty problems - tick and maggot infestation to name just two.

Like rosesarered I too would like to know why some vegetarians find it fine to wear leather shoes.

I think in our world today it must be almost impossible to avoid everything we would rather was not there.

durhamjen Thu 01-Dec-16 17:28:43

I don't buy wool because it makes me itch.
I also don't like the idea of wearing any animal products. I don't find it fine to wear leather shoes. I have one pair of boots and two pairs of shoes. I am sitting here in cotton socks at the moment.
Also, they are not two separate breeds; sheep bred for wool are also eaten. It tends to be the females kept for shearing and breeding and the males sold for lamb.

Granarchist Thu 01-Dec-16 17:33:05

duramjen - all sheep are shorn except for Wiltshire Longhorns which self shear (as it were) - if sheep are not shorn they over heat and much much worse get maggot infestations especially around the anus where maggots get in and eat the sheep alive from the inside out - I have actually seen this when I failed to spot the strike in time - believe me it was one of the most horrible things I have ever had to deal with.

durhamjen Thu 01-Dec-16 17:39:10

Therefore there shouldn't be so many sheep. Stop eating meat and buying wool, and the problem would be solved.

harrigran Thu 01-Dec-16 18:35:41

That concept is a little naïve, get everybody to boycott it and the problem goes away hmm

durhamjen Thu 01-Dec-16 18:42:57

I didn't say 'get everybody to boycott it.' I said stop eating meat and using wool. There's a difference.
At least I am not responsible for Granarchist's sheep problems.

Ceesnan Thu 01-Dec-16 19:00:38

But by saying "Stop eating meat and using wool" you are, in effect, encouraging a boycott! What is the difference?

aggie Thu 01-Dec-16 19:01:05

Think I will go read the Gardening Forum