Gransnet forums

Chat

Do I say anything?

(86 Posts)
thuberon Wed 07-Sept-16 09:20:55

DH has, it turns out, bought a large map of Mars as a birthday present for ur 8 year old GD. So far so good. But he has had it framed. I feel this is a misguided present on so many levels. The size, indestructibility, the safety aspect of a large framed picture in a very small bedroom, the need to keep it displayed so as not to hurt his feelings, the GD probably not having more that a fleeting interest in Mars, my DD having just moved into her very small and forever home and thrilled to decorate it with her own things etc etc

DH intends to present it to GD later today. I know it is not my problem but my instinct is intervene and suggest he ditch the frame no matter the cost, as it turns the map into a massive permanent obligation.

Elegran Wed 07-Sept-16 11:41:26

Put down that caps lock, jings! It is dangerous ! smile (I did notice that you said that about the highlighting, BTW, and that you didn't mention MLP. Reply was a general one.)

jinglbellsfrocks Wed 07-Sept-16 11:35:57

smile

jinglbellsfrocks Wed 07-Sept-16 11:35:24

Elegran I have already said, I ONLY PUT THE "GIRL" IN BOLD BECAUSE OTHERS WERE REFERRING TO A GRANDSON.

I HAVE SAID NOTHING ABOUT MY LITTLE SODDING PONY (WHICH I WOULD NOT WISH ON ANY KID, BOY OR GIRL.)

EmilyHarburn Wed 07-Sept-16 11:29:55

Let him enjoy giving a present. He must have taken care and thought and time to come up with this gift for the right day.

don't spoil the joy of giving and receiving by pouring cold water on the process.

Six months later this will either be on the wall or not. if not then you have plan of action no 12. I would favour the lamination so that it can be taken into class etc.

Elegran Wed 07-Sept-16 11:27:30

And the child loves her Grandad, who is giving her something for their shared interest. The frame is a detail. And are you so sure that being given a real framed picture won't give her a thrill at being treated like a grownup, not a silly girl who only wants pink My Little Pony?

Leave it be - this is between grandad and granddaughter. No need for anyone else to step in and "improve" it.

Alima Wed 07-Sept-16 11:26:55

It sounds like a really thoughtful present to give to your DGD to foster their mutual interest in astronomy. If the framed picture is too large for her bedroom you can always suggest that you keep it in your living room for her. Simples.

jinglbellsfrocks Wed 07-Sept-16 11:21:32

Oh come on Elegran! It's the child's birthday. Grandad's feeling have to take second place.

Stansgran Wed 07-Sept-16 11:16:21

I would have given it un framed ,laminated as someone up thread said with a packet of blu tack and helped stick it to the ceiling.

Elegran Wed 07-Sept-16 11:14:34

I would let it be given and received as it was carefully planned by Dh, without interfering. Then make helpful suggestions when/if it proves too big and permanent.

DH has tuned in to GD's interests and bought her a present that he thinks will please her, and it probably will even if it later gets altered. Don't rain on his parade, this kind of involvement should be encouraged, not changed to fit what you think is suitable (though you may well be proved right - do try not to say then "I knew that would happen")

Desdemona Wed 07-Sept-16 11:04:12

If it was me, I wouldn't say anything. Your grand-daughter and daughter can decide what to do with it at a later date.

thuberon Wed 07-Sept-16 11:03:25

Ha ha Jinglebellsfrocks Instead of "Do I say anything?" I should be asking "What planet is he from?"

Eloethan Wed 07-Sept-16 10:55:33

I think it's quite a nice present. My husband took close-ups of the moon and our granddaughter, who is nearly 6, was so taken with them that she stuck them on her bedroom wall (in our house) herself with blutack.

It's not as if this is the only present the little girl is going to get. If it does prove too cumbersome or of limited interest, no doubt in the future it can be quietly re-located.

Theoddbird Wed 07-Sept-16 10:26:14

Ditch the frame. This then gives your daughter and grand daughter more choice. In a frame they have no choice.

jinglbellsfrocks Wed 07-Sept-16 10:23:17

This seems to me to be a classic "Men are from Mars, Women are from Venus" thing. ((no naff pun intended) Thuberon's DH thinks entirely differently from how she thinks. grin

radicalnan Wed 07-Sept-16 10:21:08

A lovely frame is a fab present, never mind the map, tell her she can re use that frame over and over as her interests change and never forget who bought it for her.

pollyputthekettleon Wed 07-Sept-16 10:19:13

I wouldn't intervene, it's a really thoughtful present & with respect it's nothing to do with you.

jinglbellsfrocks Wed 07-Sept-16 10:15:08

I only put "girl" in bold because other posters were thinking it was a grandson, btw.

jinglbellsfrocks Wed 07-Sept-16 10:10:25

Sigh! Of course that is true sunseeker. hmm But you can bet yer life there will be other things, girly or otherwise, she will want to put on her walls (small bedroom - huge frame - bit unfair?)

Tbh I think a map of the solar of the solar system might have been a better idea. But that is neither here nor there.

sunseeker Wed 07-Sept-16 10:03:30

Could this gift not be construed as encouraging GD not to be constrained by the fact she is a girl but realise she can be or do anything.

thuberon Wed 07-Sept-16 10:01:13

Thanks for your views. I have no problem with the map itself and agree it is a delightful present and I am thrilled that she and DH have any interest in astronomy. My issue is with the presentation of the map in a frame that is armwidth wide. It just seems such an unwieldy and permanent object to foist upon a young family in their new (small) house

sunseeker Wed 07-Sept-16 10:00:59

jbf why wouldn't an 8 year old girl be interested in the solar system? Not all little girls want to decorate their rooms in pink with pictures of My Little Pony!

Christinefrance Wed 07-Sept-16 09:57:59

I agree with Elegran tact is called for. Don't over think , your granddaughter will make her own decision. So good your husband actually did this for her.

Ana Wed 07-Sept-16 09:51:01

Yes! That's the ideal solution, anno! smile

It could even be stuck on the bedroom wall if she wanted, with blu-tack.

Elegran Wed 07-Sept-16 09:50:33

After it has been handed over as it is (lovely big chunky parcel to open) and admired, it will be taken into the bedroom and tried out against all the walls.

THAT is the moment to say "You know, it would actually fit better without the frame! - and you could trace it then, or roll it up and take it to school to show it to everyone"

annodomini Wed 07-Sept-16 09:48:50

Second thought - It would have been more sensible to have had the poster laminated. Then, if her class was studying the solar system, she could have taken it along to school without damaging it.