Gransnet forums

Chat

Modern attitudes

(32 Posts)
grannyactivist Fri 01-Jul-16 11:30:18

A lovely Christian friend of mine was about to buy hot sausage rolls for her and her husband one lunchtime when she spotted a man sitting on the street. He looked like someone in need and she was reminded that Jesus said whenever you 'feed the hungry' (paraphrased, but you get the drift) you are feeding me. So she bought an extra sausage roll and offered it to the man. He very politely refused on the grounds that he doesn't eat pork. My friend's response was to smile to herself - and as she recounted the story to me later she said, 'of course he doesn't eat pork - he's Jesus'! smile

As to the man mentioned in the OP - when you have very little materially it becomes very important to hold on to your sense of who you are and being vegetarian is clearly a major part of this man's identity.

At Christmas I cooked a halal meal (chicken) for our Muslim guests, a traditional Turkey and trimmings meal for our Malaysian guest, but the homeless man I was cooking for loves birds and said he'd rather not have a Christmas dinner if it was going to be a bird. I made him roast beef! smile

jinglbellsfrocks Fri 01-Jul-16 11:29:10

It's even possible that some of the kindest and most socially aware people are sleeping on our streets.

sunseeker Fri 01-Jul-16 11:13:57

When I buy food for someone homeless, I always ask first if there is anything they can't eat. For instance I am allergic to fish so if, God forbid, I was ever in that situation I also would have to turn down the sandwich. Surely by asking first you would be giving him some dignity in being able to choose what he eats.

jinglbellsfrocks Fri 01-Jul-16 11:12:29

He's as much entitled o his code of ethics as anyone else! Why should being on your uppers mean you have to abandon your honestly held beliefs? shock

dramatictessa Fri 01-Jul-16 11:07:49

Vegetarianism isn't a pseudo religion, so no beliefs to be suspended. Just because you are homeless doesn't mean you have to give up your principles or your ability to make choices. The person buying the meal was very kind; the homeless person does not have an obligation to accept that kindness. This does not negate the kind act, nor mean that the homeless person is ungrateful. And the story should not put anyone off buying meals for people sitting in doorways - they are all individuals who will react to generosity in different ways.

breeze Fri 01-Jul-16 11:02:05

Reminds me of the story a while back where 'begger' (charlatan) was exposed as not only having a roof over his head but was making a very comfortable living out of begging. So maybe it was him and he'd dined well the evening before! If you're cold and starving you'd eat anything surely. Or even scrape the tuna out if you'd die for your cause!

thatbags Fri 01-Jul-16 10:54:35

This is the story: man sitting in doorway on the street. Someone buys him a meal: baguette, muffin, hot drink. He turns down the baguette because it has tuna in it and he's a vegetarian.

Two phrases popped into my mind when I read this story:
Never look a gift horse in the mouth (I was talking to Minibags about this concept only the other day).
Beggars can't be choosers.

The kind person who bought and offered him the meal described him as being "down on his luck". If he makes a habit of turning down good luck, is it surprising?

I can understand anyone choosing to be a vegetarian when they are buying their own food. I can understand vegetariansim being given a very high status in one's belief system. What I don't understand is how anyone but a determined martyr cannot suspend pseudo-religious beliefs about food when he is jobless and homeless. I guess he just wasn't really hungry which, if so, I'm glad about for his sake, but I think a more flexible approach to life might help him improve his lot.

Anyway, the story kind of puts me off buying meals for people sitting in doorways. If they can turn them down then they are not so hard up as one might have thought.

What do other people think?