Gransnet forums

Chat

Refugees

(856 Posts)
Katek Fri 28-Aug-15 08:32:59

I could hardly believe it when I looked at the news on my phone this morning to discover that 70 people had died in the back of the lorry in Austria. It's appalling, how can one human being allow this to happen to another?

petra Wed 09-Sept-15 07:36:48

If there ever was a wife and baby.

NfkDumpling Wed 09-Sept-15 08:42:59

I found CelticRose's link yesterday (8.41) very interesting. Thank you CR it explained a lot.

magpie123 Wed 09-Sept-15 09:02:21

vegasmag What kind of man would leave their wife and baby, only a coward.

Nelliemoser Wed 09-Sept-15 09:05:25

I blame the Irish look how many of them invaded Britain in the 1840s they started this. Perhaps we should start by repatriating all of them. They weren't really dying of starvation because of the potato blight crisis. They were just pretending their children were dying so they could come over here to take our jobs.

Only about 1 million people died and a million more emigrated from Ireland. "Well they were only Irish so it didn't matter." was almost the British attitude then.

As for Petra's And I live very close to Foulness Island where the MOD do a lot of testing. What if these Aliens get on to the island and steal bombs.

Petra do you not think that the MOD might have thought about that already? Or are you thinking about little green men in flying saucers?

Etheltags I was told today by a local person that many people are saying we will be invaded by terrorists and people are scared.

FGS GNrs stop listening to people "who say" or you "heard it on the bus."
There are a lot of people who enjoy going around spreading alarm.
I think it was an offence in the last war to spread panic.

Yes there is a serioius risk here at present I am not denying that.
There were very serious terrorist times in the 1970s from Irish republicans with a lot of killings on the mainland.
We need some perspective and compassion here.
It could so easily have been us seeking refuge in WW2.

merlotgran Wed 09-Sept-15 09:09:18

Where do you suppose we could have sought it, Nellie? hmm

Bellanonna Wed 09-Sept-15 09:10:17

Good post nellie

vegasmags Wed 09-Sept-15 09:29:27

Armed men in speedboats cut fuel lines to refugees' boats, leaving them adrift.

www.cbsnews.com/news/uniformed-men-accost-refugees-leave-them-adrift-at-sea/

Quite shocking.

Anniebach Wed 09-Sept-15 09:51:45

Who has blamed the Irish?

Bellanonna Wed 09-Sept-15 09:54:52

Wasn't that just a bit of irony ?

Anniebach Wed 09-Sept-15 09:58:06

Sorry, I thought I had missed a post, am half asleep, sorry Nellie

harrigran Wed 09-Sept-15 10:21:27

So CBS news reporters follow the refugees and film them at sea in a boat that is not seaworthy, in my book they exploited them for a news story. Why aren't they telling them not to risk their lives ?

annodomini Wed 09-Sept-15 10:27:07

Who wants facts? Hearsay and panic-mongering are far more interesting? Well, here is a link that might give us all something to think about.

jinglbellsfrocks Wed 09-Sept-15 10:31:41

I heard on the radio this morning that many of the young men coming here have just received their call-up papers and do not want to become cannon fodder for Assad. They hate that regime anyway so why risk life and limb for it. Sounds reasonable to me.

merlotgran Wed 09-Sept-15 10:42:57

I think if I were a Syrian mother I would tell my son to get the hell out and not worry about me.

Awful to think of young families being torn apart though. sad

TerriBull Wed 09-Sept-15 10:51:27

Yes I agree Jingle, why would anybody stay and fight for a tyrant. What a choice - Assad or ISIS - absolutely no choice.

Nelliemoser Wed 09-Sept-15 11:01:55

Anniebach in case of any doubt, my Irish remarks were intended as irony.
They were virtually blamed for their plight as well. Why did they not stay in Ireland and just plant more potatoes?

Joan Wed 09-Sept-15 11:04:11

If we think of the refugees as the modern equivalent of Jews fleeing the Nazis, then we might be a bit more compassionate. And let's face it, ISIL is every bit as vicious and murderous as the Nazis - they just don't have industrial scale mass murder to the extent of Nazi extermination camps - but they are trying their best.

I never thought there would be evil organisations in the world to compare with the Nazis, but it never ends - Stalin, Pol Pot, Idi Amin, Slobodan Milosovic and other Balkan mass murderers, Boko Haram, Al Qaida, the Taliban, and now ISIL.

No wonder people flee. No wonder the world is inundated with refugees. And we in the comfortable Western democracies simply cannot pretend it isn't happening and isolate ourselves.

Nelliemoser Wed 09-Sept-15 11:12:24

Anniebach I didn't see your "apology"either.

Merlotgran where would we Brits have gone? The Republic of Ireland?
Shetland islands, who knows? That is the problem and in a way the whole story of the plight of most refugees.

Our island status really helped protect us from invasion but if we had been invaded we would have been really stuffed.

petra Wed 09-Sept-15 11:13:25

Nellie. I was just trying to up the stupidity sakes following on from Ethel's post, ie, I know someone who knows someone.
And the island is protected from land and sea.

Jane10 Wed 09-Sept-15 11:14:10

I don't agree nelliemoser we would have fought.

Eloethan Wed 09-Sept-15 11:30:29

What do you mean "we would have fought"?

It is ridiculous to keep comparing the situation in Syria - a civil war with the complication of ISIS and various rebel groups which may or may not be affiliated with ISIS or Assad - to that in Britain during WWII.

For Britain there was a clear common "enemy" who had already invaded many parts of Europe and who were intending to invade Britain.

Nelliemoser Wed 09-Sept-15 11:36:59

Jane10 to the death no doubt. The German blitzkrieg war machine was very powerful.
The British fighters almost certainly would have fought, but the woman and children and elderly would have fled as this group usually do.
They have no alternative and trying to protect the children makes complete sense in any survival situiation.

As for the disabled. Well we know what the 3rd Reich would have done with them.
We were determined in WW2 but also very very lucky.

Anniebach Wed 09-Sept-15 11:39:26

We didn't defend the channel islands

Anniebach Wed 09-Sept-15 11:41:15

Nellie,i understood you were not accusing thr Irish, I though you were quoting a post and couldn't find it , sorry again x

Anniebach Wed 09-Sept-15 11:44:31

Well said Nellie, we had one enemy and they were not of this country