Gransnet forums

Chat

How stupid is Corbyn getting

(291 Posts)
12Michael Wed 26-Aug-15 07:48:59

Just seen the latest proposal of that possible Labour leader he wants women only carriages n trains, some of his ideas are stupid hope he does not win, because things like renationalisation of rail etc costs money, to pay for most of his ideas in his world , it would increase the basic rate of Income Tax to 35%.

Penstemmon Sat 05-Sept-15 23:02:53

In any conflict I believe it is wise to keep talking and leave open even the smallest possibility for a negotiated settlement. That does not mean you have to abandon assertive, or the possibility of aggressive, actions.

I think that the nuclear option is too dangerous for everyone in the world.

Gracesgran Sun 06-Sept-15 08:37:28

I could happily (wrong word) agree with that Penstemmon.

POGS Sun 06-Sept-15 12:50:40

Well I did say we wouldn't agree re Corbyn .

I don't see the likes of Hamas , Hezbolla, BNP anything other than political organisations that cannot be viewed as one being more worthy than another, I have no fondness for any of them, others obviously can.

My point has been lost Corbyn has chosen to say he uses dialogue and shared platforms with the likes of Hamas, Hezbolla because he considers dialogue is the right way to put over your views. He obviously also has the ability to be selective when it suits and that causes me to think there is a valid and commendable reasoning behind what he says but he is not being genuine if it only applies to those political organisations he has sympathy with.

I wish I could bring up his his interviews on Russia Today they have been very enlightening.

durhamjen Sun 06-Sept-15 14:26:13

www.newstatesman.com/politics/elections/2015/09/what-does-our-latest-poll-mean-labour-leadership-race

Less than a week to go.

durhamjen Sun 06-Sept-15 14:44:01

www.taxresearch.org.uk/Blog/2015/09/05/we-could-have-peoples-qe-next-week/

The Bank of England uses QE all the time now. The difference is that all it does is buy and sell bonds so it looks as if things are okay in the financial world.
So why not have PQE, which will build houses, improve infrastructure, buy back PFI, etc., and at least ordinary people get something out of it, like jobs and decent pay.

Notso Sun 06-Sept-15 14:58:35

Polls can be odd can't they?

The New Statesman article reports that an average of 76% of Labour Councillors polled agreed with JC's plans for publically run energy supplies/nationalising the railways/50p top tax rate/mansion tax.

Yet less than 20% of those polled thought JC would win the next General Election......which he'd need to do for the plans to be implemented I imagine.

Strange.

durhamjen Sun 06-Sept-15 15:02:29

Yes, I thought that, Notso.
Not much faith in the man beyond next week.
Hopefully that will change if the rest of the party get behind him.

Anniebach Sun 06-Sept-15 15:47:21

Tristam Hunt has said the there will be no split in the party,

FarNorth Sun 06-Sept-15 19:20:17

Possibly the 76% of Labour councillors, who agree with Corbyn's plans, would like to see him win the General Election, but maybe they don't believe that enough voters will also agree and will vote for that to happen.

durhamjen Sun 06-Sept-15 19:22:40

Tristram Hunt changes his mind every week. Wasn't he one of the ones who was going to start a breakaway party?

durhamjen Sun 06-Sept-15 19:43:55

www.berfrois.com/poets-for-corbyn

Anniebach Sun 06-Sept-15 19:50:26

The press have named him as one who would but I haven't heard him say so Jen. I wonder why he chose to say it before Saturday , is he now sure Corbyn will win !

durhamjen Sun 06-Sept-15 20:25:37

Prescott named him, too. He was setting up a group called Common Good along with Chukka Umunna who is also telling everyone to get behind Corbyn now.
I think they know. Tristram Hunt is a Kendall supporter and has said he will not serve in a Corbyn cabinet. I wonder if he's changed his mind on that.

durhamjen Sun 06-Sept-15 20:28:16

www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2015/sep/06/stewart-lee-jeremy-corbyn-new-christs-bin-laden

Anniebach Sun 06-Sept-15 21:37:36

No idea Jen, I just find the timing strange , perhaps they tried the - we will leave the party if Corbyn win, didn't work did it? Perhaps he wants to stay in the shadow cabinet

durhamjen Sun 06-Sept-15 22:35:58

Interesting times next weekend and the week after.

Anniebach Sun 06-Sept-15 22:53:47

And if Corbyn wins for some time to come

soontobe Mon 07-Sept-15 07:47:31

Out of interest, if Corbyn wins, will everyone think it is a "fair vote".

And if he doesnt win, will everyone still think it is a "fair vote"?

Because it seems to me, that the whole process has been a bit of a mess.

Gracesgran Mon 07-Sept-15 08:20:37

We certainly live in interesting times Jen and Annie. I believe that whatever the outcome things will change .

Anniebach Mon 07-Sept-15 09:38:51

Things need to change Gracesgran,

durhamjen Mon 07-Sept-15 11:12:43

Panorama tonight on Corbyn, titled Labour's Earthquake.

POGS Mon 07-Sept-15 11:19:50

Merkel and Hollande have joined together in another 'dictat' to the countries in the EU and they have just announced :-

That EU members must take their fair share of refugees. They said the EU will take 120.000 refugees over the next two years. Germany will take 31.000 and France will take
24.000.

This will be confirmed by Juncker later today.

Well if that is correct how do you square the 800.000 mooted for Germany to accept. I am completely puzzled by it all. Over 130.000 arrived in Germany over the laser weekend alone, if the figure I saw was correct.

I asked days ago if this could see the break up of the EU and I at least believe this will prove to be the EU's most difficult problem to date. I am not sure that the other 26 nations in the EU will do as instructed especially those in eastern Europe.

durhamjen Mon 07-Sept-15 11:40:02

What's it got to do with Corbyn?

POGS Mon 07-Sept-15 11:47:41

DJ

Bugger all 'at the moment' I obviously posted on the wrong thread.

You will I am sure note I have posted on the refugee thread.

Gracesgran Mon 07-Sept-15 13:24:26

POGS grin I am glad to see that I am not the only occasionally "confused of Gransnet"