Gransnet forums

Chat

Forum etiquette.

(331 Posts)
Greatnan Sat 21-Apr-12 08:14:10

I think forum etiquette is no more than normal good manners. I would not correct someone's grammar if I were speaking to them in person, and I don't correct any member's grammar, spelling or punctuation on forums.
Not easy for a pedantic former English teacher!

I can ignore personal insults (I think they say more about the poster than about me) but I think they are usually considered to be in breach of forum etiquette.

imjingl Mon 23-Apr-12 16:59:11

nah

Bags Mon 23-Apr-12 16:56:20

jing, can I call you im for short?

imjingl Mon 23-Apr-12 16:53:23

Greenmoss, you could be overthinking this one. sunshine

soop Mon 23-Apr-12 16:46:06

green smile flowers

greenmossgiel Mon 23-Apr-12 14:44:02

Well, I hope it stays onwards and upwards confused. I've not looked at this particular thread since Saturday evening - however, I've read down through it all today, and realised that the 'troll phrase' - not song, came from me. I went back through all the threads and found my own comment in the midst of other comments and replies which were made about issues to do with bullying, not making new posters welcome, etc.
My comment was made on 2nd April on the thread 'Badly-behaved Children'.
I apologise if I have caused anyone to feel upset through any ensuing arguments to do with my particular comment. However, I feel that the argument/discussion itself didn't only have to do with my comment. sad

Greatnan Mon 23-Apr-12 14:14:33

Accepted. Thank you. Onwards and upwards.

nannym Mon 23-Apr-12 13:57:03

I seem to have made the classic error of taking a comment the wrong way - you just seemed to be slightly defensive. Apologies if I have taken a remark out of context.

Greatnan Mon 23-Apr-12 13:40:55

Not a sore point at all - just stating a fact. Why should it be a sore point?

nannym Mon 23-Apr-12 13:36:01

Oh dear! Obviously a sore point! Perhaps I should have pmd GN blush

Greatnan Mon 23-Apr-12 13:08:13

I send pm's to anyone I want about anything I want - I don't think we have to justify them - they are there to be used.

nannym Mon 23-Apr-12 13:08:05

Josie, thank you too.

nannym Mon 23-Apr-12 13:06:51

glammanana I fully understand why you should do that, and appreciate you taking the time to respond to my comment. I just don't understand why people feel the need to pm about a query as to what has been said previously in a thread.

glammanana Mon 23-Apr-12 12:55:44

nannym just a quick note pm's I have pm'd people with information re personal medical stuff which is a bit to private to put on line if they are having similar problems and also I pm glass alot re school PTA and fundraising ideas which we share.flowers

imjingl Mon 23-Apr-12 12:55:05

And I'm sure they do!!!!

grin

Greatnan Mon 23-Apr-12 12:54:34

Of course one can always just send a pm without mentioning it on the open forum!

JosieGransnet (GNHQ) Mon 23-Apr-12 12:50:28

Hi nannym

Thanks for your feedback on the PMing issue. As Greatnan mentioned, there are many reasons why someone may use the PM function, but we can see what you mean that there may be certain implications in some situations.

We don't tolerate personal attacks on our members, so if you do feel that, in the context of a particular thread, a comment about PMing is a personal attack, do let us know and we'll take a look. We look at every post reported to us.

Hope that answers your query smile

Greatnan Mon 23-Apr-12 12:37:43

nannym - I think you are finding something sinister where it doesn't exist. It could be that they just don't want to bore everyone by repeating on a thread what somebody has missed.

imjingl Mon 23-Apr-12 11:58:23

petallus - you do realise it's for St George's Day, don't you?

He's cuddly, not threatening. grin

imjingl Mon 23-Apr-12 11:55:59

bags! It wasn't a tearful sniff! It was a put-out one. grin

nannym Mon 23-Apr-12 11:21:06

Geraldine very helpfully made clear GN's netiquette policy, but made no mention of the pm. It just seems to me that if someone tells another person that they will pm them in reply to a query as to what has gone on, as opposed to just answering normally, then they are (possibly inadvertently) indicating that what they will say is less than complimentary. Could be wrong and am quite happy to be corrected.

petallus Mon 23-Apr-12 11:09:10

I wonder what the new emoticon signifies. Maybe that at the time of writing we are breathing fire? grin

Ariadne Mon 23-Apr-12 10:40:09

Always associated dragons with Wales...

petallus Mon 23-Apr-12 09:55:36

That was a masterly intervention Geraldine. Thanks!

Gally Mon 23-Apr-12 09:53:01

I DID ask some time ago after the shamrock appeared if the rest of us could have a leek, a rose and a thistle - silence came the stern reply! Perhaps they could be permanent so we could use them to indicate our origins grin

bagitha Mon 23-Apr-12 09:52:37

There are tissues in that box over there -->