Gransnet forums

Ask a gran

New mattress or new bed?

(26 Posts)
Cabbie21 Sun 12-Jul-26 13:22:47

I think I need to replace my mattress.
I have a king sized bed, Harrison Spinks, with a four drawer base.
I have read that ideally a new mattress should not be put on an old base as it can affect the quality. If I am going to replace the base as well as the mattress I don’t need a king sized bed, now I am on my own, but then I’m not sure I will be able to reuse the headboard, which I really like.
I am also undecided how much I need to spend. Yes, the money is there, but I don’t want to spend a small fortune.
I am sure I shouldn’t need to, to get a decent mattress.

So do I need a new base or just a mattress?
Will a cheaper ( not dirt cheap) mattress be good enough? How much is it worth spending?
My spare room has just a narrow single bed which is not very comfortable. But realistically I never get overnight visitors.
Too many decisions. I keep putting them off.

tanith Sun 12-Jul-26 13:44:29

If you have the funds replace the bed I have a good double now I'm on my own. Half measures wouldn't be my option go for a new bed and have a good bed that will be good for years. A kingsize quilt fits fine on a double too.

Patsy70 Sun 12-Jul-26 14:26:43

Yes, I would go for a new bed. You could still use the same bedding and may even be able to have the headboard adjusted to fit a double. These decisions aren’t easy to make, are they?

cc Sun 12-Jul-26 14:30:44

If your base is the firm type (ie not sprung) you should be able to put a new mattress on top of it. I'm guessing that if it has drawers this will be the case.
If you decide to buy a new base and the headboard is fixed to the wall it really won't matter how wide the bed is.

Desdemona Sun 12-Jul-26 14:58:46

I would just replace the mattress if the base itself is still in good condition.

valdali Sun 12-Jul-26 15:24:30

I would just replace the mattress, especially if you really like your existing headboard.
Guidelines will encourage shoppers to spend more money -unless you are 100kg or more, I doubt your bedbase has deteriorated enough to compromise a decent quality new mattress.
Careful with the sizes though, not all "Kingsize" measure the same, get the tape measure out.

Cossy Sun 12-Jul-26 15:28:55

We’ve replaced our mattress on both my late mother’s bed (when she was alone and using it!) and our own.

Both were unsprung divans with drawers.

It worked well.

Smileless2012 Sun 12-Jul-26 15:51:24

cc is right, putting a new mattress onto a solid top base wont affect the quality.

MT62 Sun 12-Jul-26 18:07:53

If it’s in pretty decent condition you could alway sell, or give away your base & headboard.
Our old dunlopillo bed was sprung based, I just replaced the mattress.
Eventually we bought a king ottoman with beautiful winged headboard. Only downside is I find the wall light now isn’t bright enough to read as the wings block the light.
Some places offer a 30 night exchange on mattresses.
I would probably replace the whole lot either with a double or 2/3 bed.

MT62 Sun 12-Jul-26 18:08:55

MT62

If it’s in pretty decent condition you could alway sell, or give away your base & headboard.
Our old dunlopillo bed was sprung based, I just replaced the mattress.
Eventually we bought a king ottoman with beautiful winged headboard. Only downside is I find the wall light now isn’t bright enough to read as the wings block the light.
Some places offer a 30 night exchange on mattresses.
I would probably replace the whole lot either with a double or 2/3 bed.

I meant a small double

Cabbie21 Sun 12-Jul-26 18:14:26

Mixed opinions then.
Any comments on makes of mattresses, please?
They are all too heavy for me to turn or rotate on my own.

TillyTrotter Sun 12-Jul-26 18:15:17

We have recently replaced a mattress on a pine bed frame (no longer deemed fashionable but we like it).
We spent nearly £700 on a mattress and are well pleased with it.

Cabbie21 Sun 12-Jul-26 18:17:22

My son has ViSpring. Their top one costs over £10,000!

MT62 Sun 12-Jul-26 18:43:07

Cabbie21

My son has ViSpring. Their top one costs over £10,000!

My friend bought a vi-spring but unfortunately it was a little too hard for them, so waste of money.
What about those mattresses that come in a box? Emma.
I think they would probably be lighter.
You could alway go on to YouTube uk & look up best mattress in a box.

Charleygirl5 Sun 12-Jul-26 18:49:19

I am with tanith and I would replace the entire bed.

MT62 Sun 12-Jul-26 18:49:51

Simba do a 200 night trial (mattress in a box)

Jaxjacky Sun 12-Jul-26 19:12:41

My old pine slatted king size won’t be replaced, my son was born on it, a few mattresses ago, he’s 35!

Luckygirl3 Sun 12-Jul-26 19:30:25

Jaxjacky

My old pine slatted king size won’t be replaced, my son was born on it, a few mattresses ago, he’s 35!

Aw ..... smile

I replaced my super king size bed with a queen size (small double) profiling bed because I need to sleep slightly sitting up and with pegs raised a bit.
I went for the best hard mattress ... all made from natural materials .... and it was the most expensive part of the purchase... more than the bed and it's mechanism.

If you feel there is any chance that at some point you feel you might need a profiling bed it might be worth going for that now rather than expend a lot on a new mattress only to find you need to spend more again down the line.

Luckygirl3 Sun 12-Jul-26 19:30:48

Pegs! ... legs

MiniMoon Sun 12-Jul-26 19:33:08

I can recommend an emma mattress. I have one on my bed and haven't had hip pain since getting it.
I really want a new bed to put it on. The one I'm sleeping on is a metal framed bed which is too tall for me, my feet don't touch the floor when I sit on the edge of it.

Grammaretto Sun 12-Jul-26 19:36:30

I have my original double pine bed base but have a relatively new sprung mattress. I can't lift it easily by myself but it seems ok. I wouldn't want a smaller bed.

Yours is a king-size but even so I would get a new mattress if you need one. If you are sure you need one 🙂

MT62 Sun 12-Jul-26 20:09:20

Jaxjacky

My old pine slatted king size won’t be replaced, my son was born on it, a few mattresses ago, he’s 35!

Ahh 😊

Nandalot Sun 12-Jul-26 20:42:29

I was having the same quandary a month ago. Big dips in the mattress and waking up every morning with aching shoulders. I dithered for ages and then went for it from an online company that delivers the next day. Can exchange after 50 days if it doesn’t suit. It is brilliant! Shoulder ache has gone. It wasn’t overly expensive as mattresses go, around £500 for the kingsize. Went for medium firm. I kept the old base as it has a firm top with drawers.

Patsy70 Sun 12-Jul-26 21:42:12

MiniMoon

I can recommend an emma mattress. I have one on my bed and haven't had hip pain since getting it.
I really want a new bed to put it on. The one I'm sleeping on is a metal framed bed which is too tall for me, my feet don't touch the floor when I sit on the edge of it.

Friends of mine have recommended the Emma mattress, when we were discussing buying a new bed. We have had our double pine bed for 28 years 😳, changed the mattress a few years ago. It is comfortable, but so very heavy when changing the bedding and difficult to move round, as one is advised to do. 🤷🏻‍♀️

JaneJudge Sun 12-Jul-26 21:46:01

Do you have a Harrison’s slinks mattress?