Gransnet forums

Chat

Here's summink to stir youse up

(12 Posts)
thatbags Tue 05-Aug-14 14:44:34

Outrage about a smoking scarecrow in the children's storybook. Chuckle.

I agree with the writer of the article.

Aka Tue 05-Aug-14 15:03:46

What do Scarecrows smoke? (I've not read the book)

Aka Tue 05-Aug-14 15:05:59

Mine is stuffed with straw - a H&S/fire hazard issue. Does he go up in flames?

Nonu Tue 05-Aug-14 15:07:00

If memory serves- cigarettes!
grin

Nonu Tue 05-Aug-14 15:14:23

Not cigarettes--cigars!

Aka Tue 05-Aug-14 15:16:24

How can a Scarecrow afford to smoke cigars?

Nonu Tue 05-Aug-14 15:18:09

L O L !!

Terrafirma1 Tue 05-Aug-14 22:27:31

The scarecrow in question is clearly an immigrant benefits scrounger snd the wedding a marriage of convenience. Julia Donaldson is of course well known for her gritty reality(what do you mean, theres no such thing a a Gruffalo?)

absent Wed 06-Aug-14 05:24:38

Never mind the smoking. I thought children had to be taught to share. Why aren't the two scarecrows made to take turns with the lady scarecrow?

Didn't snowman always have pipes once upon a time?

I realise that the Hobbit and Lord of the Rings weren't written for children but would point out that tobacco looms large in Hobbit lore. Did they - hobbits, dwarves and Gandalf - smoke in the film?

MiceElf Wed 06-Aug-14 06:53:24

Oh naughty Julia Donaldson
Winding up the po faced
And having lots of fun

ffinnochio Wed 06-Aug-14 07:04:19

grin

WBundecided Wed 06-Aug-14 11:00:54

Years ago a friend read Burglar Bill to her son, he was shocked. Not that Burglar Bill was a burglar, but because he dunked biscuits bin his tea shock