Gransnet forums

Ask a gran

Precocious or just confident?

(29 Posts)
kircubbin2000 Fri 04-Sept-26 14:29:14

My 11 year old GS attended a family funeral at the weekend. After the service he went round and introduced himself to the people he hadn't met before and had a chat with them.
My other son told me he thought this was precocious as most children don't behave this way. What do you think?

J52 Fri 04-Sept-26 14:33:12

Sounds like he’s been well brought up. Some children have an innate sense of being social and are confident.
My 11 year old GD introduced her class individually to the new class teacher when she was 7!

fancythat Fri 04-Sept-26 14:36:35

I think that was super.

kircubbin2000 Fri 04-Sept-26 14:37:14

He is very much into drama and music so I think that has made him like this.

SueDonim Fri 04-Sept-26 14:41:43

My youngest GC (8 & 5yo) both do this. It’s an after effect of Covid, I think, when they were so deprived of company, they’d stop and talk to anyone!

62Granny Fri 04-Sept-26 14:42:51

I think I would be impressed as long as he did it in a kind considerate way,
your other son sounds a touch jealous/ envious.

Greenfinch Fri 04-Sept-26 14:43:30

It is certainly unusual behaviour for a child of that age but I wouldn’t label it precocious. Everyone is different and it is lovely that a child felt confident enough to do this. It should be encouraged.

Sarnia Fri 04-Sept-26 14:49:34

kircubbin2000

He is very much into drama and music so I think that has made him like this.

When my 16 year old GS, obsessed with music and drama, went in for his interview at the Brits, before he sat down he went along the line of people on the interview panel and shook hands with each one.
He is autistic, not suggesting your GS is, but rarely have I found autistic youngsters to be ill mannered.

Luckygirl3 Fri 04-Sept-26 15:06:24

Polite boy. I would have felt proud of him.

Calendargirl Fri 04-Sept-26 15:17:48

I think it sounds ok, especially if it were to older family members who didn’t have a clue who he was.

“Hello, my name’s John, I’m Mary’s son, she was the niece of Auntie Flo whose funeral this is” or words to that effect.

If that were me, I would be thinking “Oh, so this is Mary’s son”…

MT62 Fri 04-Sept-26 15:37:24

I would have been proud to have a son like that. Sounds like he’s a credit to you 😊

BlueBelle Fri 04-Sept-26 15:39:09

It is unusual behaviour I think he’s a very confident young man, I would have hid in the corner hoping no one noticed me at that age Perhaps his drama group has given him more confidence than most
None of my children or grandchildren would have approached adults in this way, they would answer or chat if approached but they wouldn’t initiate it

Fallingstar Fri 04-Sept-26 15:43:13

I imagine is not the way many 11 year olds would behave but all children, like adults, are different, my old mum would have said ‘he has an old head on young shoulders’, which is a compliment.

ReturningFromExile Fri 04-Sept-26 15:56:09

What lovely manners! Very grown-up for his age, in a positive way.

ViceVersa Fri 04-Sept-26 16:03:14

He sounds lovely - and yes, it could be the drama classes which have helped him feel confident in himself. Mind you, my GS would probably do something similar - he's 'not backwards at coming forwards' as we say around here! grin

crazyH Fri 04-Sept-26 16:14:14

That’s really lovely and shows he is very confident.
I have a 11 year old GS too, but I can’t see him doing that - he is a shy boy , not painfully shy, but shy.

ginny Fri 04-Sept-26 16:30:29

He sounds like a lovely confident, polite young lad.

Astitchintime Fri 04-Sept-26 16:35:50

He sounds a very confident young man and you should be proud of him.
Being at a funeral often means being amongst people who you don’t know well, how lovely that this child struck up conversation with everyone some of whom might have felt a bit isolated.

Visgir1 Fri 04-Sept-26 16:40:03

My Son would do this from about 10 years old, with confidence, he was happy to chat to ladies on the supermarket tills. Even younger about 8 he saw a Wasp in a Car he then knocked on the drivers window, saying "Excuse me, you have a Wasp in your car" the lady flew out of the car thanking him.

Oreo Fri 04-Sept-26 16:40:40

Greenfinch

It is certainly unusual behaviour for a child of that age but I wouldn’t label it precocious. Everyone is different and it is lovely that a child felt confident enough to do this. It should be encouraged.

I agree.
It sounds similar to a boy I know with Aspergers.

GrandmaT2010 Fri 04-Sept-26 16:49:45

I have to disagree with most comments here. This sounds like a child who is very attention seeking. I have come across this before. A child of 6 at a family wedding who, encouraged by the mother, stood on a chair to deliver an unscheduled speech. An 8 year old (not a relative) at a an elderly person’s birthday party who decided to conduct the guests in a rendition of Happy Birthday. I have also witnessed the precocious children in school, they are not well liked!

SpinDriftCoastal Fri 04-Sept-26 16:53:41

He sounds delightful. It is not precocious, it is called having social graces. Precocious is boasting and having a big ego. I once taught a boy of 11 who wore a signet ring and wore aftershave. He went far in life.

Madgran77 Fri 04-Sept-26 16:59:33

What a brilliant job his parents have done giving him developing his self confidence, politeness, interest in others. Presumably it is considered "precocious" because he is 11 years old? I think its brilliant and setting him up for life

ViceVersa Fri 04-Sept-26 17:08:47

SpinDriftCoastal

He sounds delightful. It is not precocious, it is called having social graces. Precocious is boasting and having a big ego. I once taught a boy of 11 who wore a signet ring and wore aftershave. He went far in life.

I agree - it doesn't sound precocious to me.

Magenta8 Fri 04-Sept-26 17:12:34

One of my GCs, age nine, is like that. They have two siblings who are nothing like that so I don't think it is their upbringing. Neither parent is like that either.

I don't think it is a sign of precociousness and I would far rather see my GCs being self confident than being wracked with self doubt and low self esteem.