Gransnet forums

TV, radio, film, Arts

Black Narcissus

(131 Posts)
Calendargirl Sat 12-Dec-20 18:22:38

Just seen a trailer for this new mini series, starting on December 27th on BBC 1 I assume.

Diana Rigg in one of her last roles.

Don’t know if it will match up to the original film starring Deborah Kerr, but something new to look forward to over Christmas.

Grammaretto Tue 29-Dec-20 11:25:01

Jane10 you're spot on! grin

Callistemon Tue 29-Dec-20 11:32:38

In a couple of sentences, say what you think should be happening, or what you hope happens!

Young prince marries young girl, takes over palace and throws out the nuns.
Gemma Arterton and Sister Ruth have a struggle on the bell tower (can't tell you quite what happens as I have my hands over my eyes and feel sick) but Ruth falls over, plunges down the Himalaya. Gemma runs away with Dean, her hair grows back and they live happily ever after because her passionate nature reveals itself.

The other nuns stay there and run the school for the Prince and his now expanding harem and children, smiling even more happily as they get frostbite and go steadily nuts.
They must all smell dreadful too, no hot showers or baths, just a bowl of ice covered water.

Callistemon Tue 29-Dec-20 11:33:52

Ps I can spell Clodagh but forgot her name for the moment.

EllanVannin Tue 29-Dec-20 11:40:50

On another channel was the Marigold Hotel. grin

Charleygirl5 Tue 29-Dec-20 11:42:05

I was wondering how the nuns' habits could be so pristine with no running water or electricity.

Very slow. I agree Ruth will jump and Clodagh will ride off with Mr. Dean into the sunset to live happily ever after.

Sparklefizz Tue 29-Dec-20 11:44:40

Callistemon

^In a couple of sentences, say what you think should be happening, or what you hope happens!^

Young prince marries young girl, takes over palace and throws out the nuns.
Gemma Arterton and Sister Ruth have a struggle on the bell tower (can't tell you quite what happens as I have my hands over my eyes and feel sick) but Ruth falls over, plunges down the Himalaya. Gemma runs away with Dean, her hair grows back and they live happily ever after because her passionate nature reveals itself.

The other nuns stay there and run the school for the Prince and his now expanding harem and children, smiling even more happily as they get frostbite and go steadily nuts.
They must all smell dreadful too, no hot showers or baths, just a bowl of ice covered water.

Sounds like my perfect night's TV.

Callistemon Tue 29-Dec-20 12:19:59

I just realised that I went on a bit - more than a couple of sentences!

I'll write a TV script just for you, Sparklefizz
?

trisher Tue 29-Dec-20 12:34:56

Hang on weren't they in the bath house in some sort of Victorian type undergarments getting washed? I did wonder at the time I thought nuns only undressed in private and never revealed their body even to other sisters.

Kamiso Tue 29-Dec-20 12:53:11

Perhaps it depends which order they belong to and how big the tv budget was. There hems got a bit muddy but fortunately there were no stains down the front of their habits.

Another one who nodded off for 10 minutes. OH offered to rewind it but I said not to bother. We wondered if CGI was used for some of the travelling scenes.

Sparklefizz Tue 29-Dec-20 13:28:15

Callistemon

I just realised that I went on a bit - more than a couple of sentences!

I'll write a TV script just for you, Sparklefizz
?

Ooh ... pleeeeease! smile

Callistemon Tue 29-Dec-20 14:21:05

It's better to use cold water to wash out blood, hot water 'sets' it.

There was plenty of blood.

MayBee70 Tue 29-Dec-20 14:26:03

Jane10

My main thought is that they must all be freeeeezing!
It is slow but that's because the book could be retitled 'Five go nuts in Nepal'!

grin !

trisher Tue 29-Dec-20 14:37:39

I was thinking how much more accurate the Sister in Derry Girls is as a depiction of a real nun.

Lona Tue 29-Dec-20 16:16:52

Calendargirl grin well, I got that wrong didn't I?
34!

Calendargirl Tue 29-Dec-20 16:19:58

Lona

Calendargirl grin well, I got that wrong didn't I?
34!

Actresses looked older back in the 1940’s.!

?

EllanVannin Tue 29-Dec-20 16:24:05

One of those ( background ) nun's looks like Rowan Atkinson.

dolphindaisy Tue 29-Dec-20 16:30:20

Just watched the first two episodes on Catchup, quite enjoyable but not one of the best dramas. It's also the first time I've seen a nun with a "trout pout"

Callistemon Tue 29-Dec-20 16:31:02

I like Sister Briony best, she could be fun.

Jane10 Tue 29-Dec-20 16:34:17

trisher I completely agree Sister Michael in Derry Girls is wonderful!

merlotgran Tue 29-Dec-20 22:04:41

Oh well!

Nun of this, nun of that and nun of the other. grin

EllanVannin Tue 29-Dec-20 22:06:07

They should have booked with Easyjet.

GrandmaKT Tue 29-Dec-20 22:07:27

Oh well. I stuck with it! Beautiful scenery, but the over-riding feeling is that there's another 3 hours of my life I won't get back!

trisher Tue 29-Dec-20 22:20:28

I can't decide why it came across as so flat. What should have been dramatic moments just seemed uneventful.
"Oh look mum there's two nuns dangling from a bell rope"
" Eat your breakfast they're just attention seeking."

Callistemon Tue 29-Dec-20 22:25:03

???

Well, that was a let down.
I thought he might have swept her off his horse and carried her off to his mountain lair.

It's me, Cathy

Callistemon Tue 29-Dec-20 22:26:34

Her horse

Oh dear