Gransnet forums

TV, radio, film, Arts

Elaine Page

(18 Posts)
specki4eyes Sun 03-Jan-16 17:35:46

Need to get this off my chest!

Do the big chiefs at the BBC ever listen to their 'presenters' with an objective ear? I switched on Radio 2 today to give me some background musak whilst I took down and packed away the Christmas decorations. I happened upon the Elaine Page show. For ten minutes I became increasingly aghast at the dreadful delivery of her script, before I had to switch off in disgust. Clearly she was sitting there reading her script with barely a soupcon of enthusiasm and her boredom shone through the airwaves like a beacon. I kept expecting to hear a yawn as she stumbled inarticulately through her script in the most deadpan fashion. It was even possible to detect when she came to the end of a line and had to drag her eyes down to the next one.

A similar situation with the BBC news presenter Naga Munchetti (sp?)(cant spell or type the surname). She clearly hates her job and delivers her script in the same manner. i.e. "I'm bored silly, just let me get to the end of the show so I can go back to bed". She makes no attempt to mask the clearly evident problems with the autocue system. Most of the time she appears to be displaying symptoms of depression!

Some years ago I worked as a video presenter for a well known UK service company. The effort required to inject enthusiasm into every word of the script was huge. Enthusiastic delivery was of prime importance in order to engage the interest of one's potential viewing audience. BBC presenters? Jobsworths!

Ana Sun 03-Jan-16 17:40:49

I never listen to Radio 2 on Sunday afternoons because of Elaine Page's programme. For one thing it's not my type of music, and yes, her voice and delivery are annoying!

feetlebaum Mon 04-Jan-16 08:30:41

My ex- always referred to Ms Page as The Poison Dwarf...

What really ground my gears was that she was introduced as a presenter in a slot which had been sacrosanct for years to Benny Green and then Russell Davies - Russell being shooed off until 9:00 pm, and finally disappearing altogether. That programme, Benny Green/Russell Davies had been the jewel on the Radio 2 dunghill,,,

Lona Mon 04-Jan-16 08:38:50

Yes, I agree! I used to love Russell Davies too.

Marelli Mon 04-Jan-16 09:00:00

Cannot STAND Elaine Page, and agree with everything everyone's already said!

annsixty Mon 04-Jan-16 09:01:03

Another vote here to get rid of her,I stopped listening years ago. That irritating giggle did it for me.

grannylyn65 Mon 04-Jan-16 09:10:08

Me too ☹

Teetime Mon 04-Jan-16 09:13:58

I loathe Elaine Pages programme but then I don't like music from the 'shows' anyway. Cant agree about Naga though BUT I have stopped watching BBC Breakfast - apart from Bill and Naga all the other presenters are dire and the whole thing is like Blue Peter.

gillybob Mon 04-Jan-16 10:17:38

Blimey I thought it was maybe just me who can't bear the sound of EP's voice (singing and speaking). I love to listen to radio 2 on a Sunday when I'm doing housework, pottering etc. but as soon as I hear her grating voice I reach for the OFF button.

On the other hand I love Lisa Tarbucks slot on a Saturday evening.

henetha Mon 04-Jan-16 10:22:42

Well. I neither like nor dislike Elaine Paige. But I now feel really sorry for her.
As for Naga Munchetti, she seems absolutely fine to me.

rosequartz Mon 04-Jan-16 10:37:59

henetha I feel the same, neither like nor dislike EP but now feel sorry for her.

What a pity there is only one radio channel and no off button.
I have not come across Naga Munchetti, perhaps I didn't use the 'on' button.

GillT57 Mon 04-Jan-16 11:12:13

well thats odd.......I never listed to Radio 2 but on Sunday, in the car, I turned it on, and had to turn it off after five minutes as the dreary, bored, delivery of Elaine Page was impossible to put up with. I have never been a fan of musicals anyway, but her delivery as a presenter put me off the programme.

Eloethan Mon 04-Jan-16 15:21:53

I have not heard Elaine Paige on the programme mentioned so can't comment.

I think Naga is OK. Whilst I would find a droning monotone off-putting, I don't particularly like the rather unconvincing over-enthusiastic delivery of some presenters - and that lifting and lowering of the voice, which sounds really unnatural to me.

AyjayF Mon 04-Jan-16 16:36:17

I never listen to Elaine Page. Wrong time of day for me.
I must agree that the Lisa Tarbuck show is brilliant though.Great voice + fantastic mix of music. The only person I've heard play Jake Thackeray for years.

crun Mon 04-Jan-16 18:56:41

The type of music she plays always reminds me of this. Ironically, the only show tune I can think of that I actually like is this.

Jane10 Mon 04-Jan-16 19:49:09

If she comes on the radio its an instant switch off for us. Her cloying irritating childish giggle sets my teeth on edge.

Deedaa Mon 04-Jan-16 19:58:53

Dear feetlebaum thank you for reminding me about Benny Green! My mother and I used to love listening to him years ago, lovely man smile

And wasn't Jake Thackeray great? So funny grin

HannahLoisLuke Sun 10-Jan-16 18:02:10

I agree with everything that everyone has said about Elaine Page, I can't stand musicals either but although I like her singing voice I went off her when she was so dismissive of Susan Boyle who worshipped her.
Lisa Tarbuck? Can't stand her either, irritating voice and laugh and that squeaky toy she uses must send the nations dogs barmy. As soon as either of them come on I switch to Radio 4.