Gransnet forums

TV, radio, film, Arts

mapp and lucia?

(36 Posts)
Jane10 Tue 30-Dec-14 09:03:43

What did people think about this bbc version? I loved the old channel 4 one on years ago. I adore the books and was worried modern tv might not capture the nuances but it was OK. Certainly 'Tilling' looked perfect.

Falconbird Sun 04-Jan-15 20:27:59

Yes I loved it - it's so mannered and Amanda Richardson is brilliant although I do agree about the teeth being a bit distracting. The facial expressions on the actor's faces were so funny and so clever.

NanKate Sun 04-Jan-15 19:31:29

Loved it, especially the clothes.

Deedaa Fri 02-Jan-15 22:06:40

Even my American SIL enjoyed it and I would have thought some of it would have seemed really weird to him.

littleflo Fri 02-Jan-15 09:34:07

We went to Rye after the first series. We loved it, now I want to go back.

Veryoldbear Thu 01-Jan-15 16:15:43

Shorry. For "of" read "off". It's the Scotch, dear ones ...

Veryoldbear Thu 01-Jan-15 16:12:43

Bung ho! I can see why the dear fairies like this. I'm sure we'll get another series, and I look forward to Mapp and Lucia sailing of into the sunset on the kitchen table ...

Now off to the steam tram out to the links to play goff ...

Ana Thu 01-Jan-15 13:40:38

I agree! She was positively gurning all the way through last night's episode and it did detract from the subtleties of the actualy storyline, I felt.

FlicketyB Thu 01-Jan-15 13:23:52

DH loves Mapp and Lucia almost more than I do!

Having now watched all three episodes (and the ending was clearly set up for further episodes) I have found that just as I found the previous Lucia a bit OTT, in this series I have found the excessive gurning and physical distortions of Mapp just as irritating, to my mind Miranda Richardson is taking the part too far and her interpretation of Mapp has become a parody of the character in the book and I find it jarring and uncomfortable.

HildaW Thu 01-Jan-15 13:10:33

Must admit.....on reflection I have come to the conclusion that I prefer the characterisation of the original series.

whitewave Thu 01-Jan-15 11:52:22

merlot my DH didn't "get it" either. Too much stuff about relationships I suppose.

merlotgran Thu 01-Jan-15 11:49:24

We gave up after the first half hour as DH was bored stiff. I think I might give it another go on iPlayer though.

whitewave Thu 01-Jan-15 11:42:38

Agree with all the comments. Colours glorious, acting excellent.

Jane10 Thu 01-Jan-15 11:27:12

I reckon they must be planning to continue: the looks between Mapp and Col Flint etc The possibility of marriage between Lucia and Georgie etc. I wont give any spoilers here though! I think Miranda Richardson was terrific but wasn't so sure about Lucia. She didn't seem to come across as a strong enough character. I loved Diva! I always like that actress. Not sure why "Quaint Irene" was so heavily made up -not in character. Brave of EF Benson so have such clearly gay characters when homosexuality for men was a criminal offence. The whole programme was so beautiful visually. Well done BBC.

gma Wed 31-Dec-14 22:16:45

Just finished watching Mapp and Lucia, and what a joy it was! Had not seen the earlier C4 series, so was all new to me. Beautifully acted, and beautifully filmed. Miranda Richardson was stunning as usual,( shades of Queenie from Blackadder) and Anna Chancellor adorable, infact the whole cast were brilliant, BBC take note, More of the same please!!

Deedaa Wed 31-Dec-14 21:21:34

I love the Mapp and Lucia books. My mother always used to say that they were just like her aunts who were constantly at war. Having seen photo's of them - Elizabethan pageants and all - I can quite believe it.

Not certain whether this is as good as the Prunella Scales/Geraldine McEwan version (Prunella Scales was so gorgeously awful as Mapp) but I am enjoying it.

janerowena Wed 31-Dec-14 14:33:57

I used to live near Rye, so often went there for my shopping. I was there this summer, visiting my mother who lives nearby. I always think of Lamb's House as EF Benson's, I so loved the Mapp and Lucia books. I thought the acting was superb, and the photography certainly showed Rye at its best.

Anyone who has been there will know that in a couple of the streets, the idea of getting the Rolls out to get to a house two doors up is not such a silly idea. Non-slip climbing boots and a rope would be very welcome.

Nonu Wed 31-Dec-14 14:29:12

I haven't got round to watching the new series , too busy with other . I did so enjoy the original, maybe some 30 odd years ago.
I like the books although SOMETIMES they can be a bit SLOW, thing with reading a book about something you have seen on TV, you get that in your minds eye [well I do anyway] .
tchsmile

Soutra Wed 31-Dec-14 13:28:51

I think if you do not know the books (and love them) it might be quite difficult to "get" Mapp and Lucia, I am one of those who love the boks and am enjoying this dramatisation. Mt late MIL was a guide at Lamb House (Mallards) for many years and a former teaching colleague and her husband had Lamb Cottage as a weekend/holiday home. I have many happy memories of Rye from the years my in laws lived there.

FlicketyB Wed 31-Dec-14 13:23:51

It is a delight, and most of the characterisations - and how the characters look - are very close to the previous version. The big difference is Anna Chancellor as Lucia and I find her much better than Geraldine McEwan ( I think) in the previous version. GM was too OTT for my taste .AC is much more naturalistic in her approach to the part so she is much more at one with the rest of the cast.

Eloethan Tue 30-Dec-14 18:59:34

I haven't read the books and watched for about 20 minutes but didn't find it at all amusing.

We had a weekend away in East Sussex in the summer and went for a day out to Rye. It is a lovely place - with some fabulous tea shops!

rubysong Tue 30-Dec-14 15:32:03

I enjoyed it. It was lovely to see gardens in all their summer glory, also the old houses and cars. The story is a very funny poke at small town society. I think Miranda Richardson gave a very 'Prunella Scales' type performance.

HildaW Tue 30-Dec-14 14:52:33

I enjoyed it and yet also found Miranda Richardson's teeth a distraction....an actress of her calibre could have acted 'toothy' I am sure. Unfortunately I found myself paying them more attention than quite necessary.

ninathenana Tue 30-Dec-14 11:38:59

Whenever I see you post now Veryoldbear I will have a picture of that character in my head smile

MiniMouse Tue 30-Dec-14 11:20:04

Have recorded it, but haven't watched it yet. I have wondered what Dames Judi and Maggie would be like in the roles - Dame Maggie with the put_downs?!

Jane10 Tue 30-Dec-14 11:18:18

Mind your bibelots veryoldbear!