Gransnet forums

TV, radio, film, Arts

JL Christmas ad

(194 Posts)
J52 Thu 06-Nov-14 10:14:23

Just seen John Lewis's Christmas ad. I'm not sure about it. What do others think? You can see it on You Tube. X

hildajenniJ Sat 15-Nov-14 20:04:19

Seen it at last. Don't think much of it. It's not as good as Bear and Hare.

Soutra Sat 15-Nov-14 19:55:50

Well I think it's sweet and won't change my mind .grin

Ariadne Sat 15-Nov-14 19:28:20

All quite nauseating, I think. Fast forward is the answer.

rosequartz Sat 15-Nov-14 16:19:34

£95 shock

more money than sense some people grumble grumble

Ana Sat 15-Nov-14 16:08:24

Bump

jinglbellsfrocks Fri 14-Nov-14 17:07:58

Oh God! No!

No. JL don't own the Beeb yet. Do they?! shock

merlotgran Fri 14-Nov-14 16:41:39

Please tell me we're not going to have to suffer 'Happy Feet' on Christmas Day again. hmm

annsixty Fri 14-Nov-14 16:37:40

Nearly all the penguin products,and there are lots and lots,are currently out of stock at JL.Now that really is the power of advertising.

jinglbellsfrocks Fri 14-Nov-14 16:29:16

shock

You are only going to look at it aren't you soutra? I don't think you'd get it under your coat.

Soutra Fri 14-Nov-14 15:57:00

Who said anything about paying for it? gringringrin

Ana Fri 14-Nov-14 15:52:15

For £95.00? confused

Soutra Fri 14-Nov-14 15:46:02

I am uncomfortable with the Sainsburys ad too - it is an over-sanitised version of a well know WW I incident but all the time you know it is pushing up the millions of profits for Sainsburys. I am delighted that they are giving generously to the British Legion, but there are some areas I personally would prefer to see kept out of commercial advertising.
And bottom line - would it make me go to Sainsburys? Actually no, not on account of their advertising, only if I wanted to anyway.
Now I might go looking to ppppick up a penguin at John Lewis....!

Eloethan Fri 14-Nov-14 14:48:00

The Sainsbury's advert is, in my view, emotionally manipulative and unprincipled - but then that's what all adverts are, aren't they? But I find it especially ghastly that they are piggy backing on the tragedy of war and the plight of soldiers.

The fact that the RBL approved this advert does not reassure me. The RBL also approved BAE's and Lockheed Martin's sponsorship of various Poppy Day events - something which I think takes irony to a new level.

stopwar.org.uk/news/good-for-the-killing-business-how-the-world-s-biggest-arms-dealers-exploit-remembrance-day

Pittcity Fri 14-Nov-14 11:05:32

I try to avoid watching ads by pausing and fast forwarding. I suppose this is why businesses have to make them a talking point so that we make an effort to watch them.

Iam64 Fri 14-Nov-14 09:25:45

So far as food is concerned, I'm with roses are red and anasixty, you get what you pay for.

I saw the Sainsbury's ad again last night, I still found it very moving and the fact it's approved by the RBL and that profits from the chocolate bars go to that charity makes it ok for me.

rosequartz Thu 13-Nov-14 15:32:13

This thread is making me giggle! grin

The British Legion don't always get things right
Greenfinch like all big charities their marketing is done by a huge marketing team these days and, to continue to keep the public's interest when there are so many charities claiming our money, I suppose they have to keep thinking of new ideas.
Many of them are run like big businesses.

merlotgran grin

Well, they have got Peter Andre for their advert. Nuff said!
The thing is jingls Peter will be counting his millions on his fingers, not his pounds! (not-so-daft).

rosesarered Thu 13-Nov-14 14:50:02

No Ann you are not being too picky! You get what you pay for. At the height of the horsemeat fiasco, Iceland had their products checked. The chicken pie didn't contain horsemeat or ANY meat of any description. The experts said they didn't know what it was, just unidentified vegetable matter! Don't go there.

annsixty Thu 13-Nov-14 14:23:51

When I see their ads when everything seems to be far too cheap to be true I have to wonder at the quality (or lack of it) or am I being too picky?

jinglbellsfrocks Thu 13-Nov-14 14:17:53

Well, they have got Peter Andre for their advert. Nuff said!

merlotgran Thu 13-Nov-14 14:00:40

I remember taking Mum to Iceland a few years ago because she wanted to try their fish pie. I remarked that everything seemed to be priced at £1.

'Yes dear,' she said - VERY LOUDLY. 'That's because the people who shop in here need to add up on their fingers' shock blush

jinglbellsfrocks Thu 13-Nov-14 13:49:48

Dunno. But the ad makes it look good! I might pay a visit. grin

(Although they used to call it Fatland over at the Other Place)

merlotgran Thu 13-Nov-14 13:44:49

I haven't been to Iceland for donkey's years. Is it any good??

jinglbellsfrocks Thu 13-Nov-14 13:23:33

Oh, that Chocolate Mountain Pavlova from Iceland!!!

That's what I call an advert. grin

Ana Thu 13-Nov-14 12:15:04

grin Pitticity!

Pittcity Thu 13-Nov-14 12:13:58

I'm off out to buy a frozen lobster from Peter Andre grin