Woman's Hour Power List

I hate these lists. I wouldn't nominate anyone and I wouldn't bother to read them when they are published. Meaningless media rubbish.

Go for it Lucid if that's what you want to do.

I already have Ella...

Well Lucid are you going to tell us WHO (or should that be WHOM?) you have nominated, or do you want us to guess?

The judges all seem to be journalists, writers and politicians. It would be nice to see a few lady industrialists, City-folk, scientists, judges etc. on the panel, giving a bit of balance if nothing else. Maybe they were too busy - or had better things to do.

Granny23 if you really want to know I nominated Justine Roberts...I feel that she has influenced the lives of a great many women through Mumsnet and Gransnet.

I don't always get chance to listen to Woman's Hour, but did this morning. I like this idea and listened to a few suggestions on the programme. Any opportunity to fly the flag for women, especially when they empower other women, is good for me.

A very good and well deserved nomination Lucid Well done you.

" Who has the ability to inspire change as a role model or a thinker?"

The only people I can think of who really have that ability is every mother of every child.

Couldn't narrow that down to a single name.

True, jingl, but not everyone has a mother during their developing years.

That is unfortunately true Ana. And not all mothers are good ones.

But I agree with the old adage, "The hand that rocks the cradle rules the world".

I can't honestly think of any woman in politics or anywhere else who would have had the power to influence me except my very good Mum. (And my Gran)

Not sure that Justine would be called powerful. Don't HQ deliberately try not to assert influence?

Flip me! Justine Roberts and Carrie Longton (creators of Mumsnet) in at number 7!

The Queen at number one!

The whole of Mumsnet must have backed them! But to be fair, they did create something special and if Mumsnet hadn't existed, would we be doing this now? But I can't think why anyone nominated Victoria Beckham.

I still can't quite understand the difference between influence and power. I would have thought being able to influence people would be a powerful thing.

#loadofcodswallop?

I suppose we will have to listen to the programme. Perhaps.

The list shows just what a dearth of really powerful women there is in this country.

I'm not a fan of Victoria B but I can see how she made the list - she's a big influence, along with her hubby, in the celebrity & fashion worlds. And she deserves credit for manufacturing her very successful clothing line in the UK.