We have been lucky enough to have a variety of cats through the years, and have been "gifted", mice, voles, shrews, rats, a mole, frog, baby rabbit and a variety of birds, the majority alive. Think, they just like the excitement of watching you run about! But must admit the 'present' which caused the most consternation was a young herring gull which our former feral boy decided to bring in. He had been in dispute with the gulls which liked to swoop low over the back garden for a long time, but as he was quite elderly and stiff we never thought anything would come of it. Ha! not only did he catch it, but managed to get it in through the cat flap, and up the stairs into one of the bedrooms.
Much chasing, and bad language, from the gull, me and the cat! (who had managed to get out from the bathroom, where he had been confined) and he was caught and taken to a wildlife rescue, where he made a full recovery.
The funny thing was, the feathers on his wing where he had been injured grew in white, so he as quite distinctive, and could often be seen glaring, is the only word for it, at our house from the nearest lampost, ( rescue always tried to release where an animal is from) while all the others gazed out towards the sea.
Oh, and we found a pint glass and table mat invaluable for catching small things. 