Gransnet forums

News & politics

The U.K. is not like Italy

(121 Posts)
Whitewavemark2 Sun 17-May-26 11:40:02

The observer has a good editorial today.

It began suggesting that Italy has become our exemplar when it comes to shuffling PMs and the un seriousness of it all. All very depressing.

But then it goes on to argue that like Italy the U.K. is better than its politics, and this is where it cheered me up.
OK we don’t have Venice, Ferrari or sunshine, but we have music that the world loves story tellers that capture the world , and I would argue the performing arts that are second to none.
The pantheon that is Stonehenge, and in fact others even older., which speaks of an extraordinary concentration of endeavour and ingenuity that has been repeated throughout the intervening centuries to today. At least a dozen of the worlds best universities who produce some of the finest minds, science and technology not to mention the Arts and literature. A creative industry with a head start throughout the world because we speak English.
London remains one of the global financial centres and we have the rule of law - so valued by business the world over, to the extent that US business and wealthy Americans have been promoted to build lives and businesses in the U.K. because of the lunacy that is Trump where the rule of law means nothing.

We have a world beating pharma industry rivalling the USA

Food in our capital that rivals if not surpasses Rome.

That cheered me up.

Casdon Mon 18-May-26 20:03:50

Yes, I’ve been. It’s absolutely gorgeous, with stunning views, but buses can’t get into the town, and you need to be fit because it’s very steep and there are loads of steps.

Cath9 Mon 18-May-26 17:49:06

I would love to visit Italy but I do like to get far away during the winter when it is cold in Italy.
Has anyone visited Positano, if so did you like the place?

Casdon Mon 18-May-26 16:54:17

I’m not keen on horseradish, so that’s not for me. Perl Lâs is my favourite, but there are some great others too.

Emelie321 Mon 18-May-26 16:42:52

BTW, back to the Welsh cheese recommendations. Lots of greats here - but my personal favourite is Harlech. It has a horseradishy tang to it which to my mind sets it apart. Anyone else a fan?

MartavTaurus Mon 18-May-26 16:31:22

Allira

^I'd speak to my grandchild --and to my lover in Italian--^

Ooh, you are saucy!! 😲

Arrabbiata is my favourite. It's spicey and fiery!! ❤️ 🔥

Allira Mon 18-May-26 16:25:14

I'd speak to my grandchild --and to my lover in Italian--

Ooh, you are saucy!! 😲

MartavTaurus Mon 18-May-26 16:20:44

Some interesting points there DrWatson . Hopefully, we'll be excused for straying somewhat from the original intention of this thread. As I said earlier, I have no indepth knowledge of Italy or its history, but often it's beauty in the eye of the beholder that counts for me.

Just taking the comment about the language for example, there's no other tongue I'd rather listen to on both a good or a bad day. Italian is attractive to my ear because of its ‘melody’, like a beautiful song. I think that's because, being a Romantic language, it has lots of words ending in soft vowels, unlike say German which is full of harsh consonants. I'd speak to my grandchild and and to my lover in Italian, but I'd speak to my dog in the field in German, if you get my meaning!

And yes, your comment about jabbering Italian Street traders might have some truth, but isn't that also the beauty of language when it becomes authentically fashioned by those people who need to express themselves to interact in order to survive? I'd find that enchanting too in Italian.

But don't just take it from me. As I said earlier, it's no coincidence that the English writer of all times, Shakespeare, set his masterwork - Romeo and Juliet - with its long poetic monologues - to the backdrop of beautiful Italy.

DrWatson Mon 18-May-26 14:58:17

For MartavTaurus, YES, Italy is terrific in many ways. However, I'm not sure that the language IS the "most beautiful" -- listen perhaps to some street traders jabbering at each other, several thousand words per minute (?!) and it's not quite so appealing?

Plus, that lovely Catholic Church collaborated quite readily with Hitler in WW2, and Mussolini was very popular until his fans realised that they'd backed the wrong team.

That same racist swathe of opinion can still be seen today, as any team with black players is I'm told more likely to be barracked in Italy than most other countries in Europe ((the former Yugoslavia also fails in that respect, apparently).

Oh, and Venice - lovely as it is -- positively REEKS in the summer! However, if the Italian Tourist Board would like to remind us of the country's many plus points, we'd likely be persuaded by a week or so by Lake Garda or Como?!!

Mamie Mon 18-May-26 14:05:12

Allira

MartavTaurus

ronib

The Italian state pension is one of the highest in Europe.

My guess is that, like in France, their contributions in Italy are probably a lot higher too?

Hey, I've just thought of another "better" for Italy, they tend to live longer than we do in the UK!! So, at the end of the day, they actually receive far more from their government than we do in our poultry pensions.

And they're better lovers! ❤️ Even Shakespeare would have agreed with that.

And they're better lovers! ❤️
How do you know? 😁

Living longer - according to Tom Conti it's all that fish and olive oil!

From what I understand from my French friends the link between state and occupational pensions is far closer than in the UK, with the points based occupational bit requiring supplementary contributions to the pension.
They were always surprised that my state and occupational pension were separate.
I think it is hard to make comparisons.

Jaberwok Mon 18-May-26 13:59:30

That's where you are wrong Whitewavemark2, It maybe so on here, but not everyone is an intellectual with several degrees and an inflated opinion of their own intellectual prowess. We too have opinions, sometimes even valid ones!!

monami Mon 18-May-26 13:53:35

you would think we were the amount of unders who 50s serve pasta, pasta, pasta, its all they can cook

AGAA4 Mon 18-May-26 11:02:09

Sorry MartavTaurus I suffer from predictive text too.

MartavTaurus Mon 18-May-26 10:46:16

Both the successful Reggio Emilia and Montessori approaches in early education are Italian. I like them because they are child-led and encourage hands on education.

Casdon Mon 18-May-26 10:43:01

As well as their pension contribution level, is there not a much lower rate of people with private pensions in Italy though, and a lot of people on low wages? I’m not sure that you can do a direct comparison like that without the bigger picture, given 70% of a low wage is still a struggle for many I’m sure?

MartavTaurus Mon 18-May-26 10:41:46

AGAA4

*Poultry pensions* are you saying they are chicken feed? 😀

😂

vegansrock Mon 18-May-26 10:16:34

My brother lives in Italy with his Italian family. Their pensions are 70% of their working salaries.

Allira Mon 18-May-26 09:43:30

"The U.K. is not like Italy"

I was interested to see that the Princess of Wales went to Italy recently to explore pre-school innovations there. She visited an pre-school in Bologna, engaging with children up to the age of six. The focus is on environmental and outdoor learning and the scheme, the Reggio Emilia Approach, now worldwide, began there.

When my DGC were at primary school, they spent some time outdoors at Forest School which seemed to be similar, but of course, Italian children perhaps have more opportunities for outdoor learning because the weather is better! Looking out of the window, it's teeming with rain and 9C (feels like 7C).

AGAA4 Mon 18-May-26 09:38:14

Poultry pensions are you saying they are chicken feed? 😀

Allira Mon 18-May-26 09:30:14

MartavTaurus

ronib

The Italian state pension is one of the highest in Europe.

My guess is that, like in France, their contributions in Italy are probably a lot higher too?

Hey, I've just thought of another "better" for Italy, they tend to live longer than we do in the UK!! So, at the end of the day, they actually receive far more from their government than we do in our poultry pensions.

And they're better lovers! ❤️ Even Shakespeare would have agreed with that.

And they're better lovers! ❤️
How do you know? 😁

Living longer - according to Tom Conti it's all that fish and olive oil!

ronib Mon 18-May-26 09:22:24

Italy spends 12.8 percent of its GDP on pensions. The UK spends 4.7 percent.

Whitewavemark2 Mon 18-May-26 08:52:03

Jaberwok

Music that the world loves took a bit of a dive at Eurovision! Just one more thing to embarrass and humiliate the UK.

😄😄😄 nobody take the Eurovisions seriously.

MartavTaurus Mon 18-May-26 08:28:50

Poultry 🐔 😂 Paultry

Pollo alla Milanese anyone?

Jaberwok Mon 18-May-26 08:28:24

Music that the world loves took a bit of a dive at Eurovision! Just one more thing to embarrass and humiliate the UK.

MartavTaurus Mon 18-May-26 08:25:14

ronib

The Italian state pension is one of the highest in Europe.

My guess is that, like in France, their contributions in Italy are probably a lot higher too?

Hey, I've just thought of another "better" for Italy, they tend to live longer than we do in the UK!! So, at the end of the day, they actually receive far more from their government than we do in our poultry pensions.

And they're better lovers! ❤️ Even Shakespeare would have agreed with that.

MartavTaurus Mon 18-May-26 08:06:43

I agree with you 100% about the dissing of degrees relating to the creative industries.

Interestingly, Italy and the UK seem to contrast in their creative industries in that we rely heavily on technology, whereas Italy focuses more on heritage. The skill the Italians possess, is that they value innovation and originality in individuals above all else. You could say that that often requires less of a formal education, but more artistry and an out of the box boldness.
It would be enlightening to compare the educational paths of the two countries in these fields, but I don’t know enough about Italy to comment.