Some interesting points there DrWatson . Hopefully, we'll be excused for straying somewhat from the original intention of this thread. As I said earlier, I have no indepth knowledge of Italy or its history, but often it's beauty in the eye of the beholder that counts for me.
Just taking the comment about the language for example, there's no other tongue I'd rather listen to on both a good or a bad day. Italian is attractive to my ear because of its ‘melody’, like a beautiful song. I think that's because, being a Romantic language, it has lots of words ending in soft vowels, unlike say German which is full of harsh consonants. I'd speak to my grandchild and and to my lover in Italian, but I'd speak to my dog in the field in German, if you get my meaning!
And yes, your comment about jabbering Italian Street traders might have some truth, but isn't that also the beauty of language when it becomes authentically fashioned by those people who need to express themselves to interact in order to survive? I'd find that enchanting too in Italian.
But don't just take it from me. As I said earlier, it's no coincidence that the English writer of all times, Shakespeare, set his masterwork - Romeo and Juliet - with its long poetic monologues - to the backdrop of beautiful Italy.