Elegran
MaizieD
Elegran
So why do you pull up the ragwort year after year, MaizieD? It isn't all that ugly, in comparison with some other weeds, and if your horses ate it, you would be saved the effort.
What on earth are you on about, Elegran?
I was replying to you saying "I think that there is a bit of over dramatisation of the ‘dangers’ of ragwort happening on this thread. And I speak as one who has horses, dogs and ragwort (which we pull up year after year after year)"
You think the comments about ragwort are overdramatic, yet you yourself have horses and dogs and pull up the ragwort every year. Why? Aesthetics or animal safety?
The comments are overdramatic.
I did a lot of Googling
There is no question about the toxicity of ragwort. If eaten it causes liver damage. But there is a big question mark over how much needs to be ingested before it causes death. For large animals, such as horses and cattle it certainly wouldn't be one plant. It would need to be repeatedly eaten over a long period, or eaten in very large amounts, before it caused acute liver failure.
It's most likely to be eaten when dried and more palatable. This is why, as a responsible horse owner I pull all ragwort where the horses graze. They're big animals who don't watch where they put their feet, they can cut down a plant by walking on it and that's when it becomes dangerous as it dries out. Conversely, they are pretty expert at not eating plants which are not palatable to them, live ragwort is unpleasantly bitter. Which is why I don't panic when I see live ragwort plants in their field, I just pull them up and burn them.
Of course I keep a sharp eye on our hay field and remove every single plant I find.
Ragwort in fields is unavoidable, the seed get blown in and can survive for years in the soil until conditions are right for them to germinate. Regular removal is tiresome but necessary because the seeds come in from other areas every year.
Interestingly I was recently told of a lad who was doing casual work for a farmer and spent the day pulling ragwort. The reason that the ragwort was there was because they had been able to spray herbicide to remove it this spring, contrary to the farm's usual practice. If the ragwort was regularly sprayed annually to destroy it how come it grew in quantity when it wasn't sprayed?
As for dogs, how many dogs regularly eat growing plants of any sort (apart from grass)?
I'm sure Charles was cross about the ragwort because it shouldn't have been in a pristine garden area, not because he though his dogs would eat it.
As for poisoning watercourses, I couldn't find any reference to that but I'd be happy to see any reputable research that says it does.