Gransnet forums

News & politics

Banning mobiles in schools or clutching at straws?

(31 Posts)
MerylStreep Mon 02-Oct-23 07:46:48

We have a school here in Southend which is described as an Alternative Provider school.
Drive past at break time and you will see teachers vaping with the pupils.
These are children who are there because for whatever reason they don’t fit with the normal school system. What hope for them?

Ashcombe Mon 02-Oct-23 07:44:16

At my DGS2's school, mobile phones are permitted and are sometimes used to support learning where research online is part of the lesson. There isn’t enough funding for other devices (eg iPads) to be provided for all. He is 13 and attends a state comprehensive in the next town to where they live so depends on lifts at times when attending after school clubs.

eazybee Mon 02-Oct-23 07:32:14

They should have been banned years ago, but parents protested that children needed to keep in touch with home 'in case they felt threatened'.
Vaping is a huge problem. Whenever schools attempt to ban items the protests come from the parents.

MerylStreep Mon 02-Oct-23 07:28:21

My granddaughters school have a system, where, without warning 2/3 classes are told, into the hall now with your bags.
The parents are informed if their child’s phone has been confiscated. It’s working.

GrannyGravy13 Mon 02-Oct-23 07:13:29

Disposable vapes are to be banned in the U.K.

CoolCoco Mon 02-Oct-23 07:06:58

In a big announcement it has been leaked that the education secretary will ban mobiles in classrooms. Most schools ban mobiles in classrooms anyway, so is it one of those clutching at straws moments? Maybe they should ban disposable vapes or something that is an actual problem.